• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

If there were no God, would there be any morality

Extracts from this document...


If there were no God, would there be any morality? This question begins by assuming morals were created entirely by God and not just approved of by God. It also bypasses the possibility that there is no such God and man created morals using the authority intrinsic in the idea of a God in order to enforce them; thus raising the possibility that morals are learned but also partly innate and instinctual to humankind. The ideas raised target those who have no religious persuasion, namely those who consider themselves to be atheist or agnostic. The claim implicit in the question (in assuming that God exists) is that all morality and sound ethical values stem from religion, without which motivation towards virtuous behaviour becomes ambiguous. In assuming that the Ten Commandments were never written and a list of moral rules never set out, it is easy to imagine a world where barbarity and survival of the fittest becomes as natural for human beings as it is for wild cats of the African Savannah. With these rules to fall back on, humans have guidelines, discipline and structure to a subject that is often problematic. Morality is an ambiguous subject because, unlike natural laws that offer up a specific and tangible consequence when broken, moral laws ...read more.


Without God, without reward and punishment, love of God, obedience to or fulfilment gained from adhering to God's moral laws, atheists are still able to behave in a morally virtuous way. Why would this occur, when an atheist can steal, lie, commit adultery without threat of punishment from God? From birth, whether religiously or in a purely secular nature, morals are woven into learning and development. For example; when discovered lying a child may be reprimanded by its parents, therefore reinforcing a moral law that is commonly held in society as correct. Can it then be society that helps us to uphold moral laws? Secular law is a motivation to be considered. Founded by religion and only having limited coverage of moral laws such as 'Do not steal' and 'Do not kill', still created some incentive to do the right thing through a tangible punishment that occurs during ones lifetime, if found out. Society has also formed ways of protecting itself, for example; attitudes towards those who break ethical standards. An adulterer or murderers may be shunned by society or judged through that act. However, the question of where such ethical standards have arisen from hinders discussion. ...read more.


Substitute the word country for tribe and one notices far fewer differences in the idea of morality that appears to have been introduced without reference to the Ten Commandments or a Bible at hand. This is surely an example of morality without God and as such answers the question with one large yes. A society with a total lack of moral values is a difficult idea to comprehend and could only really be achievable though a George Orwell '1984' type vision of autocracy, a controlled immorality that feigned complete morality. This, although achievable is more likely to be bought about through a conscious decision as opposed to being a reference to human nature. It appears to be common sense that distinguishes morality from immorality and as seen in the case of people never exposed to Christianity or any large civilisation with a God, the same sentiments are still conveyed and held as beliefs. Loss of morality through choice is a far more reasonable suggestion than a complete lack of it if the idea of God has not come into existence. To therefore suggest that society would have no form of morality if there had been no God and no religion is as unsustainable an argument as a society with no form of morality. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. "Discuss critically religious and secular ethical arguments about environmental issues"

    There has long been debate among Christians concerning the meaning of the word 'dominion', in this context. Many would like to believe that it is more an instruction to look after the planet, rather than simply do with it whatever benefits us most.

  2. Living In a Plural Society.

    Salvation and the Afterlife Buddhism sees ignorance rather than sin as the roadblock to salvation. That is, the belief that the world and self truly exist, keeps the illusory wheel of existence rolling-only destruction of that belief will stop the mad course of the world.

  1. Explain the Ontological argument.

    Society depends on structure and organisation and those who have the responsibility to govern with authority will no doubly conflict with those of the individual. Religion provides a reason to submit to authority, explaining our suffering in terms of the need to obey an omnipotent God and the promise of the afterlife makes society bearable.

  2. Is God really there? If he is, does he care? And if he does, ...

    This develops the 'test of faith' theory even more strongly as it takes great religious faith to undergo suffering and still be aware that there will be a greater glory waiting. Gavin Reid, the bishop of Maidstone, tells of a boy who shattered his back falling down a flight of

  1. The Divine Command Theory of Morality.

    According to this view, charity is good because God has willed that charity is good. The claim here is not about what particular communities mean by the word "good" or what motivations people have to be good. Instead, the claim is that moral conduct is identical to the conduct which God commands of us.

  2. The God Question

    The answer given to this is that God's power is only limited to logical possibility and therefore he can only perform actions which conform with the logically possible. When looked at psychologically the reason the God question is so prominent for man is mainly because of our fear of eternal retribution if we deny the existence of the being.

  1. During the Middle Ages, one of the primary focuses of everyday life was to ...

    tithe, or a mason might take charge of laying the foundation for a new church. It was the hope that in giving back to the Father from what He had given, He would be gracious in return on the judgement day.

  2. Critically Assess the Claim that the Idea of God is Innate

    I am imperfect being. I have the idea of God which is that of a perfect being. I cannot be the cause of my idea of God. Only a perfect being (i.e. God) can be the cause of my idea of God. Hence, God must exist.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work