• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Ariel Dorfman's Death and the Maiden 40 lines analysis

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The following forty lines from Ariel Dorfman's Death and the Maiden (1990), take place in scene 1 of Act 3, after Roberto has been tied up by Paulina and threatened with being tortured the same way as she had been, and then shot. In response to Paulina�s threats, Roberto begins confessing the brutality of his actions and his motives. This confession may be true; however, Gerardo has advised Roberto to indulge Paulina, to confess as this would save his life. Whatever the case, the extract is important because it portrays how a man can slide into brutality, without initially meaning to. Second, the extract is important because it helps expose the iniquities of dictatorial military governments. Finally, it is also important because it gives us an idea of Roberto's character and personality. In this extract we clearly see the stages by which a respectable doctor became a brutal sadistic torturer. Though Roberto's brother told him that helping the torturers could be a way to "pay the communists back for what they did to [his] dad," Roberto stresses that he accepted the job for "humanitarian reasons." ...read more.

Middle

The tragedy of Roberto�s slide from being a humanitarian to being a torturer is emphasized by the style of his speech, which reveals that he is an intelligent, educated, insightful man. Firstly we see how Roberto's diction indicates his intelligence and level of education. Words such as "brutalization" and "morbid," and phrases such as "he lost his capacity for speech," "humanitarian reasons" and "install a totalitarian dictatorship" clearly manifest his ability to speak articulately and in a high register. We also see how analytically capable Roberto is, as he does not just describe his own actions but explains why they occurred, carefully dissecting his his motives for working with the torturers, not to "pay the communists back" but "for humanitarian reasons." He can organize his account in clear, logical stages, with phrases like "It was slowly, almost without realizing how," "At first," "But afterwards," "By the time," "I began to," and "It became." Additionally, even in the circumstances in which he is giving this confession, in fear of his life, Roberto uses figurative language, suggesting that he has good rhetorical abilities. ...read more.

Conclusion

Finally, the fact that, throughout his speech, Roberto refers to the government only as "they" evokes the way in which such governments work in the shadows, secretly and anonymously, to torture and terrorize. Thus this extract does not only show how Roberto and men like him deteriorate when they become involved in torture; it also shows how dictatorial regimes can manipulate such men, facilitating and enabling this deterioration to occur. In conclusion, this extract is very important as, whether Roberto�s confession is true or feigned, it reveals how even the best of men may slide into such brutality and how military governments can create vile monsters out of exemplary human beings. Through the details of Roberto�s confession, Dorfman is inviting his audience to consider how a man becomes sub-human. If a respectable doctor, a benefactor to the community, could turn into such a monster because of the effects of such a regime, then what would happen to the rest of society? Dorfman tries to make the reader consider that this incident that has turned Roberto's life into a monster might happen to anybody in our society; especially in a switch of regime. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Languages section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Languages essays

  1. "Perfume" Extract Analysis

    Grenouille then realizes that nothing can stop him now that "the pack of demons was annihilated" and there are no more constraints in the beginning of his new life. Victorious, he stands up gloriously and portrays himself now as a god.

  2. Commentary on the Opening 40 Lines of the Novel Silas Marner by George Eliot

    and then to "pallid undersized men" (l.5) that [look] like the remnants of a disinherited race" (l.6). It is possible that the main character Silas Marner falls in love with one of the 'great ladies' and the conflict is that people are afraid of him because of his appearance and he cannot be accepted by society nor by the ladies.

  1. Analysis of 40 line estract of A Sea Change by Ernest Hemingway

    Phil however, who is willing to change this irresponsible life that they both had, does not want to agree to her lesbian affair. Through out the whole extract, the girl keeps trying to get Phil's approval, manipulating him and his ideas.

  2. Une confession dun jeune accus

    On commen�ait � se bagarrer. Il re�ut deux coups de poing sur le c�t�, non, au fait trois fois. On continua � se lancer des coups jusqu'� ce que les videurs nous s�parent. Vous savez pendant un moment je souriais..., c'est vrai, parce que c'�tait la premier fois que je me querellais.

  1. World Lit. - Comparative analysis: Death and The Maiden and Ghosts

    When she first encounters doctor Miranda, Paulina concludes without a doubt in her mind that he is the man who tortured and raped her, by drawing on particular details such as the Schubert quartet, which the play is named after, Miranda's quoting of Nietzsche, his smell, his voice, and the feel of his skin.

  2. Love or Lust? Women in Lysistrata compared to Women in Death and the Maiden

    The leader of the female band, Lysistrata, understood the wild libido of men, and manipulated man's weakness to in turn to her own agenda.

  1. Analysis of President Obama's speech on the death of Osama Bin Laden.

    chose to carry out the bin Laden mission there without first informing its leaders.? It looks that the president is hiding a number of issues that should be revealed to the public. Nor does the president comment on the ?downed helicopter that U.S.

  2. Ariel Dorfman. discusses the topic of bilingualism in America. The writer agrees with the ...

    ? I have developed a linguistic ambidexterity that I will be the first to admit is not at all typical. Even so, it is within reach of others if they start early enough, this thrilling experience of being dual,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work