• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does art have to have meaning? Conversely, if something is meaningless, can it be art?

Extracts from this document...


By Charis Ow 12 B Mr Ballantine Theory of Knowledge Does art have to have meaning? Conversely, if something is meaningless, can it be art? Art is a thing created by an individual using a rare, natural and creative talent. Some people say that it is impossible to define the meaning of art. They could be wrong as if it couldn't be defined, then the word 'art' would have no value in our language. Since we use it all the time, it must have some meaning to it. Some people say art can be anything and everything. However, if everything is seen as art, then the word 'art' is in danger of losing its meaning because it no longer distinguishes certain things from others. According to the Theory of Knowledge, there are three possible criteria of what is classified as an art; the creative intentions of the artist, the quality of the work and the response of spectators. Beyond this, everyone's opinion about what art is compiled of differs from each other. ...read more.


Similarly to Van Gogh, another famous artist Picasso is another good example. For many years people criticized Picasso's work of art, described it as 'devilish' and -well - insane. The main reason was that his art simply looked rather unnatural in its ways. However, they are still universally known around the world just because of the meanings implied within his artworks as it provokes thoughts and feelings. On the contrary, what if a piece of work of an artist does not have a meaning within it? Is it still considered as an art? What if the artist refuses to provoke emotions, feelings and thoughts of the audience? Does it still make his piece of work an art? What if the artist wants his work to be meaningless? What if he has no message to convey to his viewers? Maybe that piece of work is constructed with the intention to spend the spare time that he has? As we view from a different perspective, it can also be considered that as long as artists have a creative intention and the urge to produce a piece of art, their work is definitely ...read more.


In this matter, from one point of view, art has to have meaning in much the same way as words written on paper have meaning considering how an artist intends to convey a message and to communicate emotions without words. On the other hand, art also does not have to be about anything to be good. In fact, the more people tried to scrutinize and understand the meaning of the artwork, the less interesting that work becomes as they are easily deciphered by the audience. It is also said that "the greatest art takes a lifetime to understand; the slightest takes a moment". While more people tried to make their own meaning from a piece of art, it does not mean that it is the initial meaning that the artist intended. Sometimes, many tried hard to figure out the meaning of an art but it turns out that the artist's intention does not want his art to have any meaning at all. I believe it is open to interpretation whether does something have to have a meaning or if it does not, is it still considered as an art? (1,108 words) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. TOK Paper. The dangers of stereotypes, comments on Chimamanda Adichie: The Danger of a ...

    If we allow ourselves to simply accept the stereotypes that are handed to us because of media, then the respect that every individual deserves will slowly diminish. The sense of one individual's strength in comparison to another individual's weakness

  2. Modular reflections for TOK. Identify a piece of art which has communicated beauty ...

    Even though the art can be replicated easily through the use of technology, people still regard it to be magnificent, and to some extent, "worship" its style. In the case of Leonardo da Vinci again, he is very famous for his various works, such as paintings, scientific contributions and inventions.

  1. TOK summer assignment - Art Questions. Experiencing art, artists reputations and "what is ...

    Does this make the artwork more or less successful? Explain your answer. If the work created by the artist inspires a completely different emotional response from what the artist had originally intended, the artwork would be considered less successful. The artist created the piece for at least one universal meaning.

  2. Problems With Interpreting Meaning. What do the problems with interpreting meaning discussed by ...

    the natural sciences therefore these categories are not often found in those areas of knowledge, while in the arts and ethics, each one is used frequently and purposefully - whether for amusement or deception. Both the theories of meaning and the five categories of problematic meaning expand on the versatility

  1. Identify a piece of art which has communicated beauty to you, what precisely is ...

    In addition, Leonardo painted it on a dry wall rather than on wet plaster. He had tried a new and unique style called âtemperaâ, which he created himself.

  2. Tok Art Assignment: My reactions on visiting the Art Gallery

    They dilute the piece?s meaning and may give the wrong response in the viewer causing confusion and/or misunderstanding. However, different possible responses can also be considered a strength of the piece. With different reactions to the piece, viewers can look at it in many different perspectives, making it very interesting to look at.

  1. TOK Speech on Art

    told you that for this image, the ukranian oleg shuplyak intended to portray a metaphor for individuals who have lost their loved ones just as trees shed their leaves in autumn, now some you may have had different interpretations running through your mind, you might think that this is actually

  2. Can it be plausibly argued that art is brought into being only in the ...

    Another example that validates the statement made previously can be made by taking into examination a northern Italian man who lived in the early 1800s. He was a very peculiar man who dedicated his whole life to the intellectual aspect of it, reading and learning possibly as much as his human mind could handle.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work