• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why is public participation so important in land use planning?

Extracts from this document...


Why is public participation so important in land use planning? Use examples to illustrate your answers. Public participation is so important in land use planning for many reasons such as the benefits to the overall development with the inclusion of all stakeholders and the tragic failures that occur when there is no public participation. In this essay there is a need to understand what public participation is and to understand the impact of participation and the failures of non participation. Put quite simply public participation is a categorical term for citizen power and true democratic process. It is the redistribution of power to citizens, those who are presently excluded from political and economic influence, and the right to be involved with the planning and provision of that services that affect them. (Taylor 1995). The important thing to note is the concept of participation is an ambiguous one and those with different interpretations will have different political philosophical bases (Thomas, 1996). The earliest definition of the different meanings to participation is probably Arnstein (1969) who used the symbol of a ladder to show the different degrees of direct public influence over decision making, there are eight "rungs" in this ladder, the first two (Manipulation and Therapy) ...read more.


An effective consultation process based on trust can be secured through allowing the process to be voluntary, making sure all the interested parties agree to be mediated, it is very important that the mediator has no special interest or stake in the process to avoid bias, making sure that all the interested parties agree to the final conclusion and they have a total understanding of the following procedures. The OPDM (2003) also emphasises the need in consultation of entering into a deliberative process of dialogue and listening, all while being sensitive to power imbalances and being inclusive. The benefits of active consultation are what could be the stabilisation of economic, social and physical decline in an area. Public participation and consultation may improve the social and economic prospects of the whole community, there may be greener and more effective management of the environment, the social infrastructure may be enhanced and the sustainability and stability of the existing community may be improved with better communication between local authority and a development with widespread acceptance by the public to be legitimate. (Thake 1995) Without public participation we see many expensive planning mistakes that could have been easily avoided, such as the erection of the numerous tower blocks that dominate Glasgow city, the problem ...read more.


Eventually the plan had to be scrapped as the Official IRA and UDA both made it clear to the authority they were prepared to take action should demolition and road be built, and construction companies were reluctant to commit equipment and personnel to these areas. (Weiner 1976). In 1982 the issue was raised again in the Housing Renewal Strategy with 42 smaller redevelopment areas and 15 housing action plans that rehabilitated 7500 dwellings, the regeneration of difficult to let housing estates. This time around public participation was valued more as Tenants Action Project and Community Places (CTA) were used to support resident in planning projects. In conclusion the reason public participation is so important is the fact that with an effective form of it, not only the community will benefit with improved social infrastructure and stability of the community but there will be a better relationship with the community and economic prospects for all sides could be better. What is seen with a failure to engage in public participation is the disruption of communities and possible negative social consequences that surround it, community distrust and perhaps outright hostility and an unsustainable economic and social landscape. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Planning section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Planning essays

  1. Applying the Theory of Constraints to Management Problems

    This is something of a constraint because it is not the most efficient way of doing the task, and could therefore be elevated. The real constraint is the checking of tobacco orders - this is a manual job that requires scanning every item picked, weighing it, and ensuring that the correct number of items have been picked.

  2. Sustainable House

    of the Code for Sustainable Homes and could be upgraded to level 5 or 6 with the addition of more PV. Approach for achieving low carbon status Fabric Walls, floors and roof are built with 360mm of insulation (300mm in the structure and 60mm additional overclad insulation).

  1. This document is an adaptation scheme proposal and feasibility study report for Manor House. ...

    has been adapted for use: Adaptation option Objectives/ Criteria Total weighted score Rank Fire and statutory requirements (1) 0.3 Extended service life (2) 0.1 Capital or Rented value (3) 0.3 Accessibility for disabled users (4) 0.2 Functional suitability (5)

  2. Urban planning of orchard road

    Present Land Use of Orchard Road 2.1 Orchard Road Today Today, Orchard Road is a very well established shopping street, renowned in the region and the world. It is a popular destination for visitors, with at least 70% of all tourists visiting it.

  1. Discuss why the way we think about places and imagine them to be is ...

    In this case he imposes and explicitly tries to draw readers' attention to his view of Liverpool as a place of outstanding buildings and famous architects. "What made one arrangement of bricks, stone, steel and glass good and another bad?

  2. The Development of Planning Ideas U.K Planning: National Parks

    the 19th century, inspired by the public demands to access the country and legal actions from people. Furthermore romantic poets such as Coleridge and Wordsworth who wrote about the inspirational beauty of the untamed countryside and James Bryce MP campaign for public access to the countryside through his failed first

  1. Sustainable communities report

    The report focuses on the argument that the Government will have to come up with better incentives for housebuilders if it wants to prevent plans for zero-carbon homes from falling apart. Millard backs up this argument using evidence from the House Builders Federation director of external affairs, John Slaughter.

  2. Major urban regeneration programmes in the UK

    In this schemes, the interrelationships between the property development process is directly linked to the developer objectives which is to obtain a maximum profit that can only be achieved if the developer guarantee a social or public benefit for the site to develop.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work