• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Animals have no rights- they are created for the benefit of man

Free essay example:

Animals have no rights- they are created for the benefit of man

This is a controversial issue as different faiths and people have contrasting views on this. One example of this is, in Christianity you are allowed use animals for the benefit of humans (e.g. for meat, in medical experiments) whereas in Hinduism you are taught to treat animals with respect and not harm them in any way as they are sacred.

Before discussing Hindu and Christian beliefs towards animals, I am going to give a brief background to the issue. The animal rights movement has grown in recent years in the west. For example, Britain banned fox hunting (2006) and there is a widespread disapproval of practises such as vivisection in the manufacture of cosmetics. It is therefore controversial to say that animals have no rights; few, if any religions, would condone cruelty. In wider society, many people around the world, irrespective of religion would have sympathy with the view of the 19th century philosopher, Jeremy Bentham who asked “…The question is not, Can they reason? nor Can they talk? But, Can they suffer?”

Christianity says that animals were made for humans and people are dominant. This is said explicitly in the bible; ‘And God blessed them, and he said to them, “Be fruitful, increase, and fill the earth and conquer it.  Reign over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the air… over every living creature that moves on the earth.”’(Genesis 1:28). This forms the basis of Christian teaching towards animals. However it is interesting to note that originally the Garden of Eden was created as a paradise in which humans and animals lived in harmony and ate only the vegetation.

Traditionally the Christian church has championed issues of human rights whilst ignoring those of animals. The majority of Christians are omnivores and there is no stipulation in Christianity for its followers to avoid meat. Human life, however, is viewed as sacred. Christian teaching on abortion emphasises the value of human life from the moment of conception. It is due to this reasoning that the church would support vivisection for the medical benefit of mankind. The Christian doctrine towards animals does not simply relate to benefits animals may provide for mankind. Pope Constantine sanctioned hunting ‘for hunting’s sake’ during his papacy (708-715 AD). Therefore Christian attitudes towards the rights of animals have historically been unsympathetic. Although animals are seen as secondary in value to humans, Christians believe that humans have an obligation towards animals and should not knowingly or deliberately cause undue suffering. Some Christians choose to be vegetarian and oppose vivisection, hunting and other practices which cause suffering using the justification that Christians should follow Jesus’ example as the Good Shepherd, and respect animals as God’s creation. In 1928, ‘General Advice for Quakers’ stated: ‘Let the law of kindness know no limits. Show a loving consideration for all God’s creatures’.

Conversely, Hinduism is the oldest modern religion to advocate animal rights. The primary reason for this is that Hinduism teaches that the atman is in all living things; therefore God is in animals, so in harming them you are harming God. There are many other reasons why Hindus believe that humans have a responsibility to help, rather than harm, animals. Hindus strive to follow the example of Krishna, who in the Gita ate only fruit and vegetables and worked as a cowherd when he came down to earth. It is for this reason and also that Shiva rides on the bull that Hindus regard the cow as sacred. The role of the cow in providing so much to benefit humans (milk, transport, etc.) is also a factor in their sacred status. Krishna’s example also supports the Hindu argument for vegetarianism.

Hinduism teaches that the universe is governed by the rule of Karma. This means that the integrated collection of good and evil that a person accumulates during their former life is repented in their present life. This, together with the Hindu belief in reincarnation supply a convincing argument for believers in favour of vegetarianism: those that slaughter in this life will be slaughtered in the next. Furthermore, the Law of Manu says that any form of slaughtering is a sin.

Hinduism is a polytheistic religion, and many of its deities are closely connected with animals. For example, Ganesha is an elephant, Hanuman a monkey, and Vishnu has appeared as various creatures. This adds weight to the Hindu belief that animals should be treated with respect; clearly Hindu deities respected animals enough to be incarnated as them. As Swami Vivekananda said,

‘He serves God best, who is kind to all living creatures’.

In conclusion, it appears that neither Christianity nor Hinduism condones animal cruelty if deliberate and unnecessary, although the philosophical outlook of Hindus requires them to obey stricter restrictions on any abuse of animals than Christians.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Zoology section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related University Degree Biological Sciences Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related University Degree Zoology essays

  1. Animal Cruelty – fiction

    We see highly graphical pictures of distressed animals in extreme states of health, and these are just for the public to see, imagine what other terrible scenes have to be viewed by RSPCA officers, and you can imagine the pain and suffering that some animals have to go through.

  2. Should Animals Have the same Rights as us?

    Tere is substantial financial pressure on the farmer to decrease the costs of producing meat.

  1. Cloning argument

    For instance, a infertile couple might not feel as comfortable with a stranger�s child they adopt than with a their own clone. Cloning may not work for everyone, but it does give people not able to have children a new option.

  2. This study attempts to explore the basis of people's fear of animals.

    Thus, as was seen above, through cognitive development, we can understand how: 1. Familiar animals are feared less, and 2. If a feared animal is experienced repeatedly, that fear will gradually fade away. Therefore we are able to understand the decline and peak of phobias at particular ages.

  1. Using the Grounded Theory to explore people's views on animal use: What factors influence ...

    that animals have individual personalities, intelligence and have the ability to express emotions. These all influence people when forming views on animal use as if someone believes strongly in animal mind, then they are less likely to feel positively about animal use.

  2. Why do we strive to achieve?

    Animal research is also leading to other new and exciting advancements in medical technology. One of the most public advancements is cloning. Since Dolly the sheep was first cloned, new issues and advancements have surrounded the idea of cloning. In USA TODAY, Elizabeth Weise reported that scientists were close to

  1. Discuss the Need for Osmoregulation in animals, using specific examples and environments

    Similar cells are found in the mammalian kidney, the most well-known example of an osmolatory organ. The epithelium is specially adapted to cope with the specific requirements of the animal concerned. Energy in the form of ATP, for example is generated and hydrolysed using different ATP pumps.

  2. Animal Rights.

    Such acts of violence may prove to be very detrimental to, not research, but the education behind it all. Students most likely find it very hard to concentrate on their research or topic of study when their labs are under siege.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work