• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Describe, compare and contrast one content theory and one process theory of motivation. Evaluate their appropriateness for the current business environment

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Describe, compare and contrast one content theory and one process theory of motivation. Evaluate their appropriateness for the current business environment. Assignment 1 Managing People Module 26302 Student Number: 2011432859 Motivation is a complex concept to define and is persistently explored not only by psychologists but also by many global organizations. With reference to the Oxford dictionary, motivation is "a reason or reasons for acting or behaving in a particular way". In contrast to the definition, there are numerous theories that attempt to explain the true nature of the concept. As a result of the diverse beliefs, it is argued (Wilson, 2010, 136) that there is no single reliable theory that can be used to solve motivational issues. Managers need to understand the principles of the leading theories in order to use motivation techniques effectively. It is perhaps one of the most desirable skills a manager can possess, as they would be able to influence their employee's behavior where a more satisfied and motivated employee would perform better and are less likely to quit their job. The theories based on this subject can be contrasting and are categorized into two types: content and process theories. Content theories assume that everyone possesses a common set of needs and looks at what motivates people at work. Process theories on the other hand stress the difference in people's needs and focuses on the cognitive processes. One of the most famous and influential content theories is the works of Abraham Maslow (1943). ...read more.

Middle

As everyone has distinctive beliefs, two employees in the same firm with the same roles and possibly the same rewards may still feel they are treated differently, and experience inequity compared to one another in the view that they will have different perceptions of what is equitable. Another limitation is when issues arise, it does not predict which response an individual will follow. Nevertheless, when such issues arise across the company's staff, it is up to the manager to find a solution and reduce the scale and influence of the matter. This can include adapting schemes such as job evaluation to maintain balance and to indicate that they are aware of the problems. Looking at the just the notion of the two theories discussed, it is easy to see that there are no similar features between them. However, from a managerial perspective, they do relate to each other in the sense of sampling them in the work environment. If a manager wishes to gain a better understanding of motivation in the workplace, studying one theory may be not be sufficient enough but the combination of both content and process theories will give a better insight to the topic. If an organization adopts Maslow's theory, they will have to look at meeting their deficiency needs situated at the lower levels of the hierarchy before moving onto the higher level needs and in the order they must be fulfilled. ...read more.

Conclusion

The theories are initially constructed to attempt to explain the phenomenal nature of motivation but applying theories into practice is easier said than done, and that they seen managerial guidelines for motivating staff than explanations of human behaviors. It is merely impossible to satisfy the needs of everyone and that the focus on satisfying the need of one individual may lead to the problem of inequity experienced by another individual. The success of a business is largely dependent upon the manager's ability to motivate their staff as a motivated employee' works best in the interest of the firm and will lead to be more productive and efficient means. The type approach the manager has to motivation will depend on the strength and desire of the needs and the number of different perceptions that taking a course of action will help satisfy those needs. The best strategy that a manager can adopt is to experiment with various content theories and process theories as there are undoubtedly multiple challenges that they will come across. Every single company will have a distinctive group of employees, therefore they will have a different set of needs and perspectives. The effectiveness of the motivational strategies for one company may not work for the other, as there is no single solution. The best outcome is for the company to discover which strategy brings a greater impact among their employees and adopt the principles whilst being flexible. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. The nature of motivation.

    However, while McDougall saw instinct as purposive and goal-directed, other instinct theorists defined the concept in more in terms of blind and mechanical actions. The second major concept associated with instinct theories is that of unconscious motivation> Freud (1915) ardently advocated the existence of such a phenomenon.

  2. Watsons Bottled Water Company of Hong Kong. During the report, we attempt to explore ...

    Being socially responsible enterprises, Watsons Water should not only responsible to shareholders, public, etc, but also to employees. Watsons Water should satisfy the physiological needs. Actually, the Watsons Water is a largest retailer of pure distilled water and monopolizes 70% of the market shares in Hong Kong.

  1. An Evaluation of F.W.Taylor and D.McGregor's management theories

    Taylor uses a Decision making approach whereas McGregor uses the motivation approach. The Decision theory approach is based on the belief that 'because it is a major task of managers to make decisions' (Kontz, H, 1980) it is vital to concentration on decision-making.

  2. Motivation. The purpose of this brief paper is to explore the main variables affecting ...

    interviews at the beginning of the study, which were useful and helped me in developing the questionnaire itself. The questionnaire included questions that are related to the variables in the study, and some other questions were added to give us possibility to some descriptive analysis in the end.

  1. Context of Employee Relations and Industrial Conflict

    "Strikes" a general note * ERA 1996 s.235 is entitled "Other definitions" * TULRCA 1992, s.226 is entitled "Requirement of Ballot before action by trade union> * TULRCA 1992, s.246 is entitled "Minor definitions". * Employment Relations Act 1999 sch.3 is entitled "Ballots and notices".

  2. Motivation Theories

    Prior to his study psychologist assumed that satisfaction and dissatisfaction are just opposite to each other and dissatisfaction factor should not be presented in the organization. But he overcome the traditional view and said that both factors can co-exist. LIMITATIONS OF HERZBERG'S TWO - FACTOR THEORY - CRITICISM "Criticism of Herzberg's motivation-hygiene factor theory revolves around: (1)

  1. What are the critical differences between content and process theories in motivation

    The first task is to understand the content theories, which include 4 components theories: Maslow's hierarchy of needs model, Alderfer's modified need hierarchy model, Herzberg's two-factor theories, and McClelland's achievement motivation theory. In Maslow's view, people's needs can be divided to five different stages: Physiological Needs (which include homeostasis such

  2. A person's performance in an organization is influenced by several individual factors(Personality, attitudes and ...

    He thought if the hygiene factors were poor, the motivating factors would not work. The hygiene features contain mainly of good working conditions and a sufficient break. The motivating factors include responsibility and career advancement for those who deserved it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work