Use economic theory to explain how supermarkets in my local area compete for custom.

Authors Avatar
Introduction

In this coursework I intend to use economic theory to explain how supermarkets in my local area compete for custom. Supermarkets compete against each other in order get more customers and increase their profits and market shares. This is how these businesses become dominant, and this is known as Competition theory. The supermarkets that I will compare are the four main supermarkets in the United Kingdom. These supermarkets are ASDA, Safeway, Sainsbury's and Tesco.

These supermarkets dominate small shops and markets because they have so much more to offer and are much more convenient. The reason why they are more convenient is that now you can buy food, drink, clothing, electrical goods, medicines, and music and other things all under one roof. This saves time and money because you do not now need to travel from one shop to another to get different types of goods. These supermarkets are very bad news for small shops and markets. This is because people prefer to go to more convenient supermarkets. So these small shops and markets are finding that they need to be closed down because not enough money is being made by them.

The main question that I will answer during this coursework is "Do supermarkets compete on price? If they do not what other methods of competition do they use?"

This question and others will be answered in good detail throughout my coursework. They will be answered by using my own research and research that has already been done. There are nine sections to my coursework and they are the following:

. Introduction.

2. Research Plan.

3. Questionnaire and presentation of results found from it.

4. Theory of the Firm.

5. Price Comparison.

6. Non-price Comparison.

7. Evaluation of Data.

8. Conclusion.

9. Bibliography.

0. Appendix.

Research Plan

Aim of Research

To gather information to explain how supermarkets compete for customers using Economic theory. Research will be conducted on the four main supermarkets, Asda, Sainsbury's, Tesco and Safeway. I will use primary and secondary research in order to explain how the four main supermarkets compete for customers. The research that I gather will then be analysed in great detail and will be objective.

Primary Research

Primary research is also known as field research. It is information that no one has yet collected. Primary research can include information gathered by questionnaires, surveys or interviews. I will be using Primary research so I can get the newest and most up to date information that is relevant to my coursework. The main primary research that I will be using is a questionnaire. I have decided to use a questionnaire because I feel that if I ask the right questions, and ask the right number of people, I will be able to find out a lot about how supermarkets compete. The type of sample that I would like to use is a 'Quota Sample.' This is where the population is split into typical segments of age, occupation, income etc. Then a tightly controlled number of people are asked in each segment to reflect the make up of the population. This method is quite good because it is quite accurate, as lots of different people of the population are asked. I do not want to use 'Random Sampling' because I feel that this is just too inaccurate and wouldn't give me good results. I also do not want to use a 'Targeted Sample' because I feel that this is not suited to my questionnaire; I don't feel it would be successful. I may also decide to do interviews with people within the supermarket business.

Secondary Research

Secondary research is also known desk research. It is information that is already available or gathered. Secondary research can include accounts and sales records, government statistics, newspaper articles, data from the Internet, data from teachers, friends or parents, data from supermarkets and data from books. I will be using Secondary research so I can gain information on Economic theory that I don't already know. Another reason why I will be using Secondary research is because this will enable me to get the latest and most up to date information on supermarkets, so I will be able to analyse the data most efficiently. Getting this research will be relatively easy, and I will obtain it in great quantities so I will be able to compare how supermarkets compete in good detail.

Economics Questionnaire on Supermarkets

My name is Nabeel Tariq, and I am studying GCSE Economics at Beauchamp College. As part of my Economics Coursework on Supermarkets, I have been asked to make a questionnaire for the public to complete to discover how supermarkets compete. I would be very grateful if you could complete this questionnaire to help me complete my Economics coursework.

. What gender are you? (Please tick relevant box)

Male

Female

2. What age group are you in? (Please tick relevant box)

0-12 42-59

3-25 60+

26-42

3. How many people are there in your household? (Please tick relevant box)

4

2 5

3 6+

4. What supermarket do you shop at? (Please tick relevant box)

Asda Sainsbury's

Tesco Other Please specify here ........................................

Safeway

5. Why do you shop at the supermarket you chose in the last question? (Please tick up to three boxes and put them in order of preference, using numbers 1,2 and 3)

Quality of service Cheaper Prices

Short waiting times Reward Cards

Convenience Location

Quality of products Other Please specify here ........................................

Please turn to the next page to continue with the questionnaire

6. How often do you shop at the supermarket? If you do not shop please tell how often the person that does shop in your family shops. (Please tick relevant box)

Not at all Once a month

Once a week Twice a month

Twice a week Other Please specify here ........................................

7. How often do you shop online? (Please tick relevant box)

Not at all Once a month

Once a week Twice a month

Twice a week Other Please specify here ........................................

8. On average, how much do you spend when you shop? (Please tick relevant box)

£0 - £10 £31 - £40

£11 - £20 £41 - £50

£21 - £30 £50+

9. Do promotions attract you to use your chosen supermarket? (Please tick relevant box)

Yes

No

Not sure

0. Do you know the price of a pack of six free range eggs at your chosen supermarket (Please tick relevant box)

Yes Please specify price here ........................................

No

Thank you for helping me by completing my questionnaire, your help is greatly appreciated.

How I got my questionnaires answered

To get results for my questionnaires I decided to use the Shires shopping centre in Leicester City Centre. I asked people whether they would answer my questionnaire. I tended to go for older people (15 or over) as I felt they would be able to answer my questionnaire efficiently. I asked them for their answers and ticked the boxes that were appropriate to them. I went on two separate occasions and managed overall to get fifty people to answer my questionnaires. I chose fifty because I felt this was a sample that I would be able to do, and I felt it would give me okay results for what I was trying to find out. Obviously this sample is no way near the sample needed to get a good representation of the population, this number would be a 1,000 if not more. I do not have the resources as a GCSE student to do a proper sample like this; I tried to do the sample as big as I could manage.

In my research plan I said that I intended to use a 'Quota Sample,' but in the end I did not have the resources to do this as a GCSE student. Instead I did more of a random sample, except it wasn't completely random because I intentionally gave most of my questionnaires to older people. Like I have said before, this was so that my questionnaires were answered well and efficiently. This has made the results found from doing my questionnaire slightly biased. More will be explained in my analysis of my questionnaire.

Presentation of results from Questionnaire

Question 1

What gender are you?

The first question from my questionnaire asked what gender the individual was. The above graph shows that slightly more males (27) answered my questionnaire than females (23). This was not meant intentionally, I just asked people and it ended up that more males were asked. The numbers are quite close though, which shows that I was not biased.

Question 2

What age group are you in?

The second question from my questionnaire asked the individual what age group they fitted into out of the choices given. The bottom graph on the last page shows that most people that I asked my questionnaire were in the age range of 26-42 years of age. This age group is represented by the yellow slice in the pie chart, as you can see it is the biggest. This graph could be slightly misleading because I did intentionally ask mostly older people as I felt that could answer my questionnaire better than younger people.

Question 3

How many people are there in your household?

The third question from my questionnaire asked the individual how many people were present in their household. The above graph shows that most people (17) had a household that consisted of four people. I can tell most people chose this choice because it is the tallest 'tower.' The next popular household number was five because 10 people said that their household consisted of five people. This shows that in most cases people who go to supermarkets usually have a household with a couple of people in it. Maybe people who are by themselves do not see the need to go the supermarkets because they only need a little bit of food. This is not always the case though, as some people with small households still go to supermarkets.

Question 4

What supermarket do you shop at?

The fourth question from my questionnaire asked the individual what supermarket they shopped at. The above graph shows that most people shop at ASDA (20). The next most popular supermarket is Tesco (13), then Sanisbury's (12) and then Safeway (5). After ASDA, Tesco and Sainbury's trail quite far behind, so according to my results ASDA is easily the most popular supermarket. A result also worth noting is that out of the fifty people I asked no one went to any other supermarket or shop. This shows how dominant these four supermarkets are in their business.

Question 5

Why do you shop at the supermarket you chose in the last question?

The fifth question that I asked the individual on my questionnaire was why do you shop at the supermarket you shop at? The above graph interestingly shows that most people shop at their chosen supermarket because of convenience. Before I did this coursework I would have thought that most people would have went to their chosen supermarket because of cheaper prices. Although cheaper prices are still a popular choice as 11 out of 50 people chose it. Another interesting point is that people really care about quality of service because 10 out of 50 people chose this reason. This shows again that everything is not about price, but is also about other factors that keep shoppers happy. The results show that supermarkets compete on services because people are quite fond of them, so the stores must have its services to a good standard.

Question 6

How often do you shop at the supermarket? If you do not shop please tell me how often the person that does shop in your family shops.

The sixth question from my questionnaire asked the individual how many times they shopped at their chosen supermarket. The above graph shows as I expected that most shoppers shop once a week. This was a large proportion of the shoppers as 24 out of 50 shoppers chose this choice. The next most popular choice was twice a week with 16 shoppers choosing this choice. Then came twice a month (every 2 weeks) with 7, then 2 people chose once a month. The single person that chose other said they shopped 3 times a week.

Question 7

How often do you shop online?

The seventh question from my questionnaire asked the individual how many times they shopped online. The bottom graph on the last page shows that 45 out the 50 people that I asked never shop online, I thought beforehand that it wouldn't be a popular practice but I was surprised that such a large amount of the people asked didn't shop online at all. The next popular choice was shopping online once a week with 4 people choosing this choice, and finally 1 person chose that they shopped online twice a week. All the other choices I gave were never chosen.

Question 8

On average, how much do you spend when you shop?

The eighth question from my questionnaire that was asked to the individual was how much they spend when they shopped. The above graph shows that most of the 50 people (27) spend between £31-£40 each time that they shop. The next popular choice was £41-£50 as 11 people chose this option. The results are interesting because they show that people generally spend quite a lot of money when they shop. It means that the supermarkets are doing really well and competing against each other because they are attracting customers who are willing to spend a lot, which means more profits for the supermarkets.

Question 9

Do promotions attract you to use your chosen supermarket?

The ninth question from my questionnaire that was asked to the individual was whether promotions attracted shoppers to their chosen supermarket. The above graph shows that 48% of the people asked say that promotions do attract them to their chosen supermarket. A similar amount of people (42%) say that promotions don't attract them. This shows that people generally care about saving money, and getting items at better values. Finally 10% of the sample asked said they were not sure whether promotions attracted them or not. The results show that supermarkets compete on promotions because a lot of people are well aware of the promotions being made.

Question 10

Do you know the price of a pack of six free range eggs at your chosen supermarket?

The final and tenth question from my questionnaire that was asked to the individual was whether they knew the price of a six pack free range eggs at their chosen supermarket. The above graph interestingly shows that only 9 out of 50 people knew the price of the free range 6 pack eggs. This is a very common product yet only a few people knew the price of what they buy a lot. Out of the 50 people most people (41) said they didn't know the price of the eggs. More interestingly the 9 people that said they do know the price all stated a price of 88p. This shows that supermarkets keep the common product prices the same. This shows that supermarkets do compete on price a bit because they all try to keep their prices the same, especially on the common products. For example, if one store put the prices lower, the rest of the stores would follow and vice versa.

Analysis of Questionnaire

I felt that my questionnaire was overall quite successful. This was because it was easy to understand and answer. Also most of the questions that I asked gave me the information that I wanted which will help in answering the basic question of this coursework.

The first question was simple and not that useful. This was because it only told me how many males and females answered my questionnaire, it did not really tell me anything that would help me in answering the question of how supermarkets competed.

The second question told me that middle aged people (26-42 year olds) answered my questionnaire the most. This was not that useful because I intentionally asked older people because I felt that they would be able to give me better answers to my questions than younger people.

The third question was useful because it told me that households of 3 or more tended to go to supermarkets more than households of 2 or less. This was probably due to the fact that these people needed more food than people by themselves or in a couple.

The fourth question told me that ASDA is the most popular supermarket by quite a way, being followed by Tesco and Sainsbury's who are basically equally as popular as each other. As I thought Safeway was the least popular choice out of the big four supermarkets. This tells me that ASDA must be doing something that the other supermarkets are not, maybe lower prices? We'll find out later in this coursework.

The fifth question interestingly showed me that people care more about convenience and services rather than cheaper prices. This was interesting because I thought that people went to their supermarket because of cheap prices before I did this questionnaire. The results showed me that supermarkets do compete on services because people are quite fond of them, so the stores must have its services to a good standard.

The sixth question was not that useful because it gave me results that I basically expected, most people shopped once a week. I could have instead used a more useful question in place of this one, to find out more information about supermarket competition.
Join now!


The seventh question showed me that most people (45 out of 50) don't ever shop online. You could say this was an unsuccessful question because most people just said they didn't shop online at all. Again this question could have been replaced with a more useful question.

The eighth question told me that shoppers generally spent around £31-£40 each time they shopped (27 out of 50 people). This was followed by the next popular choice chosen by 11 people of £41-£50. The results of this question were quite good because they showed me that people spend quite ...

This is a preview of the whole essay