• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Moyne Commission was a waste of time. Critically discuss the view. The Moyne Commission started August 3rd 1938 and ended on February 20th 1939 which was appointed by the British Government to investigate social and economic conditions in Barbados, th

Extracts from this document...


THE BARBADOS COMMUNITY COLLEGE DIVISION OF COMMERCE ASSOCIATE DEGREE IN ATRS GOVERNMENT AND POLITICAL STUDIES GOVT 101 SEMESTER 1 The Moyne Commission was a waste of time. Critically discuss the view. NAME: Aisha Browne ID NO: 19920706-0204-2010 DATE: 13TH OCT 2010 TUTOR'S NAME: MR BOBB In this essay one would seek to critically discuss the view that the Moyne commission was a waste of time .The Moyne Commission started August 3rd 1938 and ended on February 20th 1939 which was appointed by the British Government to investigate social and economic conditions in Barbados, the Leeward Islands, Jamaica, British Honduras, British Guiana, Trinidad and Tobago and the Windward Islands. This Commission sought to bring about change to the real cause of the two local populations that had caused the events of the 1930s. This commission came under great pressure from the region's middle class representatives for the type of constitutional reform that would satisfy their class designs for social and political mobility. The Royal Commission didn't ask for or recommended responsible government for the countries who are still under the control of their mother country. Nevertheless, while the Royal Commission recommended the extension of the franchise based on adult suffrage, this didn't fail to decrease the power of the local governors who were over the executive in the colonies and trusteeship was therefore the prevailing British attitude (Cynthia Barrow-Giles,p.79). The adult suffrage was extremely significant because even for the first time the underclass was now included in the decision making process. ...read more.


In many colonies, the movement towards a member of the class of farm labourers and small farmers made balance progress and was closely involved, both as cause and effect, with the introduction of new crops. This Commission of Walter Edwards, Baron Moyne, as chairman and nine others including Sir Walter Citrine, Secretary if the British Trade Union Congress and Professor Frank Engledow who had only recently undertaken a study of agriculture in the British West Indies. For a period of nine months, the Commission took formal evidence, oral and written, from individuals and groups including many large delegations in Britain and the West Indies. In addition to the formal evidence, the Commission created on the spot investigation of conditions in housing, agriculture, hospitals, schools, prisons, factories, clocks, lunatic and leper asylums, orphanages and land settlements. This Royal Commission as we see touched all aspects of British West Indian society. The Commission realized that the problems of the West Indies were essentially economic with harsh depression in industry showing itself in widespread unemployment in the county and countryside and in weak public finances which created government unable to take remedial action to better the conditions. The Commission attached great importance to the subject of health and begged the unification of the medical service of the colonies in order to promote efficiency and to attract able professionals. According to the economic aspects of the commission, the early settlement of the West Indies was undertaken with the object of suing them as sources of valuable tropical products, such as spices, sugar and logwood. ...read more.


sugar industry, and there was the introduction of holidays with pay and also the creation of a Wages Board which I mentioned earlier to regulate the wages of shop assistants and significant amendments to the Trade Union Act. Last but not least there was the building of roads, expanding water facilities, the building of secondary schools which I also mentioned awhile to and the grating of old pension. Over in the country of Trinidad during 1941, eight secondary schools and five primary schools were constructed. Dr. Eric Williams stated that agricultural diversification that took place was to reduce the dependence on monoculture and agrarian reform programs to supply the masses with some form of land. Conclusively, as argued by G.K. Lewis in his text The Growth of the Modern West Indies, the decade of the 1930's can be regarded as the watershed in the history of the British West Indies, and not only did the events of the 1930s and their aftermath accelerate the pace of constitutional and socio-economic development but they also signaled to the attack on the entire structure of colonial administration and society. The 1930s therefore saw the emergency of the modern West Indies. As I conclude the Moyne Commission which is also known as the Royal Commission was not a waste of time because it showed how it benefitted many caribbean countries. It includes the improvement of the trade unions, it allows the Caribbean countries to access foreign investors and it improves the political decision-making process. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1920-1949 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1920-1949 essays

  1. Why did the Labour Party win the General Election of 1945?

    Industrial disputes were not significant in wartime Britain. There were days lost a result of differences between state and industry, however, rarely did this last more than a week and it usually remained a local occurrence.62 Not only did the relationship between state and industry appear to be cordial, it was Labour ministers who oversaw production the home front.

  2. What were Mussolini's foreign policy aims between 1922 and 1939?

    During the victorious conflicts the Italian people were happier and more productive for their government. Mussolini and Ciano were convinced that such a policy would maintain support and make Italy great. This appears to be one for the reasons for entering the Spanish war.

  1. Critically Assess Jinnah's view that India was made of two nations.

    as this theory was based on religion, Muslims and Hindus were generally very different in these respects. Also, Jinnah's demand for a separate state proved to have some weighting especially in the elections of 1946 because the Jinnah and the Muslim League managed to win a majority of votes in

  2. To what extent did the Tsarist and Soviet governments control and influence music in ...

    His awareness of irony was acute, as shown in the letter reproduced in appendix two. But for a picture of the composer as a firm enemy of communism, who used his music to inspire solidarity against the r�gime and defy the evils of Marxism, there remains virtually no evidence.

  1. This report will analyse both the negative and positive impacts of the First World ...

    Finally, the conclusion and personal opinions will be given. 2. General Background The First World War broke out in 1914, ended in 1918, and it was a war which mainly occurred in Europe but also spread to the whole world (Robb, 2002).

  2. Book Review - The New Deal by Paul K. Conkin

    turn the implications and limitations of economic theories impact on social policy. Conkin's most important contribution in this area is in linking private sector growth and better social welfare. Conkin argues that the government, precluded from direct intervention in the economy, was thanks to New Deal policy, dependent on the

  1. On the ninth of November, 1938, the terror of the National Socialists against Jews ...

    A no-man's land developed near Zbaszyn in Posen, as Jews found themselves caught between two forms of anti-Semitism, forced outdoors and exposed to the elements until Polish-Jewish relief organizations provided emergency shelter. A provisional settlement was eventually reached, allowing the majority of the refugees to pass into Poland, and the rest to prepare for deportation from Germany.

  2. Within the context 1814 1939, to what extent could the Wall Street Crash ...

    economy of a country is in a tenuous position, the population will demand a change. An example of this is evident in the 1848 German Revolution; when a combination of economic crisis? including bad harvests and a decline in investments within industry led to the establishment of the Frankfurt Parliament.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work