• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent did the idea of a separate sphere(TM) of life for women become eroded in the period 1870-1914?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent did the idea of a 'separate sphere' of life for women become eroded in the period 1870-1914? In her review of six different historical texts on 'separate spheres', Judith Lewis astutely remarked: 'one gets a healthy sense...that historians have been far more bamboozled by Victorian propaganda than the Victorians were.'1 Indeed, 'proponents of...[the]...feminine ideal...for instance, Tennyson's "The Princess"...[and]...Coventry Patmore's 'Angel in the House'2 were certainly part of - and also inspired - the contemporary prescriptive literature. As a result, the stereotype of the domestically imprisoned woman prevails, and 'separate sphere' has become an orthodox term in the study of female history.3 It is important to examine how far these ideals were followed. As K.D. Reynolds pointed out, 'this...version of femininity...ascrib[ed] to the least desirable qualities of the gender - frivolity, lack of application, corruptibility, frailty...and sexual weakness'4 thus making it seemingly impractical, not only for the poorer middle and lower classes whom most likely could not afford such an inefficient member of the family, but in (theoretically) the introduction of women into the public sphere (another concept to be later examined). What must be remembered, however, is that 'separate spheres' is a historical rather than a contemporary term. In other words, it is an instrument invented by historians for historians for the specific purpose of attempting to understand this complex and controversial strand of history, thus we must focus not so much on the actual term but what the term covers. ...read more.


In theory, this was most definitely an erosion of the 'separate spheres' not only in the woman entering the man's world of office work (the contemporary feminist Ethen Snowden sneered that "only well paid jobs [were] ever designated as 'unfeminine'."17) but in the fact that an uneducated women could potentially support herself without a husband. What does not erode the 'separate spheres' idea was the fact while women became accepted to be better typists than men, they also became pigeon-holed into the concept they were only worthy of working as a man's servant, hence it was still as though they were inferior. Another source that denounces the idea that it erodes the 'separate spheres' is John Galsworthy's play 'The Fugitive'. In the play a wife runs away to live with a penniless lover in the belief that she could succeed as a typist. Due to the lack of free-lance work available she cannot support herself and is forced to prostitute herself18. In other words, although the potential for a woman to support herself without a husband was made available with the invention of the typewriter, it did not necessarily mean that success in independence was guaranteed. Indeed, in 1901, an employment census was taken and found that compared to 1871 where 36 percent of women worked, only 31.6 percent were in employment.19 Although the decreased figures could be to do with the way the census was conducted (prostitutes and part time workers ...read more.


However, there were most certainly developments between 1870-1914 in terms of women's power and improvement of status. In the end, the mentality of women being inferior (although improved) beings was still rife, hence one must not exaggerate the impact of what were theoretically great advancements. 1 J.S. Lewis, Separate Spheres: Threat or Promise? (The Journal of British Studies, Vol. 30, No.1) pp. 108 2 K.D. Reynolds, Aristocratic Women and Political Society in Victorian Britain (1998) p.20 3 See A.Vickery, Golden age to Separate Spheres (The Historic Journal, Vol. 36, No.2) pp.389 4 Reynolds, Aristocratic Women, p.20 5 R. Adam, A Woman's Place 1910-1975 (1975) p.9 6 Ibid., p.9 7 J.Harris, Private Lives, Public Spirit: Britain 1870-1914 (1994) p.76 8 Ibid., p.27 9 Ibid., p.24 10 K.D. Reynolds, Aristocratic Women and Political Society in Victorian Britain (1998) p.7 11 Ibid., p.7 12 A.Vickery, Golden age to Separate Spheres (The Historic Journal, Vol. 36, No.2) pp.391 13 See R. Adam, A Woman's Place 1910-1975 (1975) p.20 14 Ibid., p.21 15 W.D.Rubinstein, Britain's Century (1998) p.320 16 See R. Adam, A Woman's Place 1910-1975 (1975) p.20 17 Ibid., p.21 18 Ibid., p.20 19 See W.D.Rubinstein, Britain's Century (1998) p.320 20 M.L.Shanley, Feminism, Marriage and the Law in Victorian England 1850-1895 (1989) p.54 21 Ibid., p.184 22 Ibid., p.185 23 R. Adam, A Woman's Place 1910-1975 (1975) p.16 24 R.C.K. Ensor, England 1870-1914 (1952) p.338 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1800-1899 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

This essay is well written and well structured, and explores several interesting themes well. The student is clearly familiar with the historiography on the topic and uses it well, although a wider range of references would be helpful in places. It would also be useful to consider whether the experience of separate spheres varied by class, region or occupation.
4 stars.

Marked by teacher Rachel Smith 24/12/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1800-1899 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    One of the most controversial issues of British Economic History is the living standards ...

    4 star(s)

    In addition,something else that moderated more the conclusions of optimists, were the new points of view about the cost of living during the industrial revolution. In this context,the new consumer price index created by Feinstein,5used more accurate rent series and contained data on candles,coal and clothing, which moderated more the fall of prices after the Napoleonic Wars.

  2. To what extent can Napoleon be seen as "heir to the revolution" in his ...

    Although Napoleon was himself agnostic he believed religion was a social band, so therefore if people were brought together through the church then government power would be cemented- 'The people must have a religion and that religion must be in the hands of the government'.

  1. Book Review The Scramble For Africa, M.E Chamberlain.

    Other works by the pair include their famous 1953 article 'Imperialism of Free Trade' and the 1962 article 'The Partition of Africa', in which they argue that the partition was a 'remarkable freak'.2 Also, Professors Cain and Hopkins, who revived the idea that the financial sector played a key role.

  2. Benin art - what can it tell us about cross-cultural encounters?

    We need to be aware of who this text was written for and by whom. The Encyclopaedia Britannica was written by educated professionals aimed for the more educated reader. Joyce makes no attempt to state the different series of theories about the Benin people and provides no verification to back up his statement.

  1. What was the significance of the Paris Commune of 1871?

    In August 1870, the armies of Napoleon III marched against Bismarck. The war ended, he claimed, would bring territorial gains, weaken France's rivals, and put an end to the crisis in finance and industry. It often happens that war leads to revolution.

  2. To what extent napoleons reforms benefit the majority of French people

    The education of the workers was deemed totally unnecessary just as it had been before the revolution; all they were provided with was a very basic church education. There was no question of educating girls, Napoleon quoted "Marriage is there destiny" and that woman should "Get on with there knitting",

  1. Open University. What evidence is there in the extract above of the three explanations ...

    big towns and industrial areas where radical roots were well established with an effective political organization. Factory workers played a far more active role in Chartism as the agricultural workers in rural areas which explained that support in agricultural areas was weak almost non-existing (Briggs, The Open University Resource booklet 1, 2013, pg50).

  2. In this essay I shall consider how all three explanations contributed to Chartisms support ...

    of Chartism, and therefore we cannot be sure of its reliability[d]. The motive exists to exaggerate the audiences?[e] size and enthusiasm, numbers of ?between 5,000 and 12,000? (Background) and comments such as ?loud cheering? (L.12) could have been fabricated[f]. The report was published in Chartism?s early years, a time of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work