• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How is happiness conveyed in Jane Austen's Emma and Charlotte Bronte's Villette?

Extracts from this document...


"Some real lives do - for some certain days or years - actually anticipate happiness of heaven" - Lucy Snowe How is happiness conveyed in Jane Austen's Emma and Charlotte Bronte's Villette? The nineteenth century was an era of great discovery, invention and social change as a result of political unrest in the previous years. The American Revolution which culminated in the United States Declaration of Independence, lead to a change in political thought, bringing ideas of 'Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness' (1776: line4), though how much this extended to women is debateable. Published thirty-seven years apart, Emma and Villette tell the stories of two girls trying to find happiness in difficult societies. The two lead characters are very different; Emma is a respected, wealthy and attractive young woman yet rather spoilt, whereas Lucy Snowe is passive and secretive, with no significant amount of money or family connections. Living in the same century, therefore, it would seem safe to assume that the girls would find happiness in the same things; good company, money and a happy marriage. As Philip Davis argues, Victorian novels (though Emma predates Victoria's reign by approximately twenty years) were concerned only with 'Humanity, Duty, Vocation, Work, Marriage [and] Family' (2002:2). However, this is not the case for either of the girls. Lucy finds comfort in solitude and some of the passages in Bronte's novel where she is most at ease are those in which she is alone. If not alone, Lucy prefers the company of just one or two trusted friends, but even this is problematical, as she often hides her feelings from the reader. ...read more.


Because she demands a kind of variety and excitement life cannot supply, Emma allows her fancy and imagination to shape and distort her perception of reality [....] What Emma constantly desires and frequently demands is not simply that her world admire her; it must also be as rich and vital and beautiful as she feels herself potentially to be [....] The crux of the matter, then, is the peculiar way in which Emma's life depends upon and is dedicated to richness and beauty in human experience. (Minter 1966 : 51) Minter argues that Emma relies on this constant application of herself to try and adapt her surroundings to suit her. In doing this, Emma is attempting to create an environment in which she is truly comfortable; not a trait one would associate with a young lady of 'happy disposition' (Emma p.1), but more with slightly nervous and compulsive behaviour. It is as if Emma must have control of the events around her to feel content. This shows a certain extent of self-consciousness and dissatisfaction, reflected most clearly in her thoughts of Jane Fairfax: Why she did not like Jane Fairfax might be a difficult question to answer; Mr Knightly had once told her it was because she saw in her the really accomplished young woman, which she wanted to be thought herself. (Emma p.125) 'View in this manner, Emma becomes, in essence, a structured action in which Jane Austen renders both the nobility and the dangers, the significance and the consequences of Emma's endeavour to force an aesthetic ideal upon her world' (Minter 1966 : 51). ...read more.


It could be argued that Lucy Snowe finds an inner peace with herself, after enjoying three happy years, despite not having M. Paul with her. Perhaps knowing she is loved is enough, and so with this and the solitary life which has given her comfort throughout the novel, Lucy can be settled. With her flourishing school as financial security, Lucy does not require anything more; she has stability and security, that which she has lacked from a young age. Though the storm imagery, if consistent with the rest of Bronte's novel, indicates further change, we are not given any clues as to how this will transpire. With so many novels of this era, both Emma and Villette look at the difficulty of a woman finding true happiness in such a patriarchal society. Kate Millett argued that Villette was 'too subversive to be popular' (1977:140), accurate considering the conformity of many novels of the time. Emma, for example, still allows a happy ending and a marriage, despite the main character's actions throughout. In creating this alternative style, Charlotte Bronte shows happiness through a perhaps more realistic perspective, rather than Austen's romanticised, 'happily-ever-after' story. Austen, J., 1994 (1816). Emma. Croydon : Penguin Popular Classics Bronte, C., 1988 (1853). Villette. London : Everyman's Library Davis, P., 2002. The Oxford English Literary History, Volume 8 : 1830-1880. The Victorians. New York : Oxford University Press Kulcich, J., 1985. 'Passionate Reserve and Reserved Passion' in ELH (52,4) pp. 913-937 Millett, K., 1977. Sexual Politics. London : Virago Press Minter, D.L., 1966. 'Aesthetic Vision and the World of Emma' in Nineteeth-Century Fiction (21,1) pp.49-59 U.S National Archives and Records Administration, 2001. 'Declaration of Independence' [Online]. Accessed 13/01/2008. Available: http://www.archives.gov/national-archives-experience/charters/declaration_transcript.html 1 Source unknown ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Charlotte Bronte section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Charlotte Bronte essays

  1. The function of landscape or the environment in Jane Eyre.

    Much of the action happens at night, when the house is in shadow and every sound is amplified by Jane's imagination, indeed the house and grounds at Thornfield provide Jane with many bad omens. The episode with the candle prophesising the fire, the ghostly vision of Bertha with the veil and the emphatic image of the split Chestnut tree.

  2. In Sons and Lovers how does Lawrence challenge conventional attitudes towards social and sexual ...

    first, great love...My mother has been passionately fond of me, and fiercely jealous. She hated J [essie]-and would have risen from the grave to prevent me marrying her (Boulton 1979: 195-7) This jealousy and intense bond between mother and son determines the relationship between Paul and Miriam, just like Mr

  1. Enacting of modern themes and literary devices in To the Lighthouse by Virginia Woolf.

    house remains unoccupied, the third portion occupying a morning at the end of these ten years. The Ramsays are a middle-aged couple, when the book opens, with eight children, who have with them at their summer place about half a dozen friends.

  2. Free essay

    Jane Eyre, its film and sequels whatever their differences- always return to the ...

    This passage explicitly states that the Victorian wife suffers from being metaphorically "locked up" as we later see Bertha in this way. Jane eventually marries Rochester, and he gains his sight to see his baby boy, which then puts male dominance back to the Victorian standard regarding Jane.

  1. Essay on the key theme of alienation in the first two parts of the ...

    if she has once and for all decided that [she] was useless to her". Furthermore, we are witnesses of how Antoinette is falling out of safety, and is therefore afraid. This is communicated by the lively image of the garden "large and beautiful as that garden in the Bible", for "it has gone wild".

  2. This essay attempts to examine and analyze the autobiographical links in Kafka's fiction Metamorphosis ...

    as a hint of redemption - of resurrection, in the acceptance of his father's verdict. This seems a biblical allusion as it brings to mind the sacrifice of the life of Jesus Christ, executing the will of His Father. In his writing of The Judgment, Kafka employs another noteworthy technique, that of the epistolary.

  1. Pygmalion's title harkened from its predecessor, Ovid's Pygmalion which accounted a woman-hating sculptor falling ...

    In Rhys's opinion, the Creoles were misunderstood and maligned both by the blacks of the islands and by the wealthier white Europeans who came to settle in the West Indies after slavery was abolished. Rhys was especially haunted by the plight of mad Creole heiresses, exploited for wealth to English husbands.

  2. How does Charlotte Bronte build up tension? Using chapter 23 to illustrate.

    Finally, she returns to her master to find out that he has been maimed and blinded when his first wife burned down Thornfield and killed her self. The novel ends with Rochester's marriage to Jane and a description of the happy life ahead of them.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work