Religion was a Hindrance to the Development of Medicine in the Middle Ages

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

Religion was a Hindrance to the Development of Medicine in the Middle Ages I partially agree with this statement because religion both hindered and help the development of medicine in the Middle Ages. Christianity and Islam belief both played a part during this time. There were many factors in which Religion helped the development of medicine. Christians and Islam's both believe that there is only one God and unlike the Greeks and the Romans who worshiped many gods and icons, they only worship one God. This was also the belief of Galen so both religions picked up his ideas and helped the development of medicine. Within both religions, medical books of Hippocrates and Galen were translated. Christians translated the work into Latin and the clergy read in Latin so they were able to understand the writings and keep alive the ideas of Galen in particular.

Middle

Christians used charms for good luck and believed in herbs in the same way the Islam faith did. The Islam's developed herbal drugs such as laudanum, senna, musk, benzoin and Camphor. Both religions were able to do this because of the churches influence in opening universities and libraries with many medical books where people could study. This was the first in Christianity had people been able to start studying medicine since the fall of the Roman Empire. The Islam's even had to have certain qualifications before they could become doctors so that they new what they were doing. Religion was able to help the development of medicine. The Christian church did not have a total ban on human dissection but it was limited. But this did mean that people studying medicine in the church backed universities were able to study the human anatomy in a more detailed way than Galen and where religion had stopped Galen from the dissection religion was now able to help the development.

Conclusion

The Islam's were unable to perform dissections due to religion, which couldn't enhance anatomy study, and the Islam's could find proof to prove Galen wrong. They also believed in the one God like the Christians and Galen. Here religion was no help to the development of medicine. Up until 1200AD, the Christian church had very little to do with the development and certainly did not push it forward. Until then there was very little education and doctors to treat the sick. This shows that Religion hindered the development of Medicine. So as you can see there are many factors of religion that both helped and hindered the development of medicine. I think that the statement is correct in that Religion was a hindrance to the development of medicine during the Middle Ages but it is wrong in that Religion also helped the developments. ?? ?? ?? ?? Sara Moore 11GKY 01/05/2007

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

Related University Degree Behavioural Science

  1. How does attachment influence the social and emotional development of the child? In your ...

    In order for the child to develop, they need to receive love and attention from the caregiver. Rene Spitz, an American psychoanalyst did a study on children raised in a poor orphanage in South America. The orphanage was understaffed and the staff were overworked.

  2. "Describe the developments of Medicine Through Time"

    look at the world around them and rather than simply explaining it all in religious or spiritual terms, as had previously been done, they looked for logical explanations for things. These new ideas existed alongside religious beliefs - but they did not replace them.

  1. Critically discuss the theoretical explanations put forward to explain alcohol dependence and discuss the ...

    However brief intervention programmes undertaken within the community seem to have the most effective outcomes. (Brady and Sonne, 1999). Brief intervention strategies often involve motivational interviewing techniques. Motivational interviewing techniques use open ended questions allowing the individual to come to conclusions, enhancing self-awareness and promoting responsibility for the self.

  2. Case Study 3: Strategic Action Plan to Encourage the Positive Behaviour of Ruby.

    "Systems theory proposes that there will be instabilities as the various domains interact in new ways (Rvachew & Bernhardt, 2010, p.37)". What Rvachew and Bernhardt are expressing is that this change in interaction will not yield positive results immediately and that any kind of stability will be sacrificed temporarily for the cause.

  1. The Renaissance was a time of good medical progress but very few practical advantages

    1460-1524). England was cut off from many developments in the progression of medicine on the Continent. Linacre was one of the few English doctors to travel abroad. Linacre studied to be a doctor at Padua in Italy. When he returned to England he became one of Henry VIII's physicians.

  2. History and development of Western medicine.

    From the 2nd and the 4th centuries A.D. Roman territories declined and finally the Roman Empire failed altogether, and we entered the Dark or Middle Ages. During this time hunger, pestilence and war were prevalent, and the Church of Rome took control of medical education. It was in monasteries that the 'scholars of medicine' could go and feel safe.

  1. Intervention for ADHD should not involve medication behavioural intervention is sufficient.

    These might not work for all children with this disorder thus need to be closely monitored. The most commonly used is aromoxetine, a selective non-repinephrine reuptake-inhibitor. While atomoxetine rarely normalizes behaviour, symptom improvement is often reflected in social and behavioural function (English et al., 2009).

  2. Why do people drink alcohol

    Alcohol consumption patterns do not differ greatly by social class. Some people do not drink alcohol because they do not like it or they feel that it has nothing but a negative effect on them.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.