• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Ethnographic Film as a Visual Aid to Understanding a Culture alongside a Text

Extracts from this document...


Olga Mir Professor Stein ANTH 3391-Visual Anthropology December 4, 2008 The Ethnographic Film as a Visual Aid to Understanding a Culture alongside a Text A student's imagination can only go so far when creating images and sequences of events based on descriptions from an anthropological text. An ethnographic writing may be able to adequately convey the essence of a culture through detailed descriptions, but a film, or any sort of visual representation, depicting the same culture adds another perspective to the understanding that is being fostered by the student. By reading a text and subsequently watching an ethnographic film, viewing photographs, or any other sort of visual aid on that culture or a specific event in it, the students gains a new layer of knowledge of the customs and mannerisms imbedded within the society. Implicit in this statement is the idea that a complete, or as close to complete as possible, understanding of a culture is not possible until a visual representation has been presented. The ethnographic novel Yanomamo by Napoleon A. Chagnon and the film The Ax Fight by Chagnon in collaboration with Timothy Asch combine to create an example of this effect. The Ax Fight, though only one out of several, is one of the most well-known films in the Yanomamo film series that Asch and Chagnon teamed up to create. ...read more.


However, if the viewer of the film reads the anthropological text before watching the film, he or she may very well be able to decipher the actions of the natives without aid from an instructor. The footage of the fight allows the student to see the full extent of the chaos involved in the "ax fights" the Yanomamo take up to settle disputes. The emotional intensity cannot be captured by words on paper, regardless of how eloquent the anthropologist may write. A film is necessary to convey the emotions and reactions of the natives as they would be in a real situation. From the raw footage, though, there arises a problem. The chaos of fieldwork that is represented in the 11 minute first section of The Ax Fight brings to the forefront the problem of anthropological interpretation, which the other two sections of the film address (Biella, n.d.). Depending on the goals and personal beliefs of the anthropologist, the outbreak of fighting may be interpreted in multiple ways. Chagnon conducted follow-up interviews and researched the village's history and marriage ties to come to his interpretation of the day's events. Thus while his interpretation is well-backed and highly likely to be what "truly" occurred, another anthropologist may see it quite differently. The third section demonstrates how raw film footage, appropriately trimmed, slowed down, and expanded, can provide "empirical evidence needed to make a credible interpretation" (Biella, n.d.). ...read more.


Indeed, the first 11 minutes of The Ax Fight are described in 380 paragraphs of text in Gary Seaman's "Blow-by-Blow Descriptions" (Biella, Chagnon, & Seaman, 1997). Clearly a visual representation adds valuable meaning to a written account of a culture. The example of The Ax Fight is a fine example of the importance of a visual representation alongside the study of an anthropological text, and this argument can be easily extended to all ethnographic work through common sense. Regardless of whether a student is a visual learner, auditory learner, etc., having a variety of ways to learn about a culture is the best way to arrive at a complete understanding of the nuances of that society as well one's own decisions on how he or she feels about certain aspects of any given culture. A film adds another perspective to the information that is obtained from a text. Detailed descriptions are seen in reality rather than imagination and what may have previously not been understood, is now understood. In my own case I did not fully understand the cultural custom of the ax fight until I viewed the film depicting an actual occurrence of such an event. The anger on the faces I saw and passion in the women's cries could not be conveyed through the text. This applies to almost all anthropological texts, and the visual representation proves to be essential in the understanding of a culture. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Anthropology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Anthropology essays

  1. Article Review. This essay is reviewing a text The original affluent society in Sahlins ...

    People existing in such societies feel and are confident to feel obliged towards desiring unlimited things provided by the market, and force themselves in to a "sentence of life at hard labour", that he argues is exclusive. He explains that we, from the standpoint of having so much ability to

  2. Consumer culture case study

    Therefore, the market society fears the possibility that needs might be satisfied. To counter these fears, society develops demand management strategies and advertising, marketing and promotion. A cultural contradiction arises and that is economic modernization underpinned by regime of rational planning and discipline and a work ethic, yet it depends upon fostering irrational desires and passions and a hedonistic ethic.

  1. In what ways have Anthropologists shown that kinship is not about genetic relatedness?

    cited in Holy, 1996). In this extreme case the mother and father who will raise the child have no shared genetic relation to it but act as its socially and legally recognized parents.

  2. Durkheim on religion. In his text Elementary Forms of Religious Life Durkheim begins his ...

    it is a truism that is not really informative. Editing your work, and being critical of your own writing, will help remove these unneeded preliminary statements. If you want a catchy opening sentence - penetrate into an insight about Durkheim and open with your understanding of his work. [DP2]Again, this is trite.

  1. Free essay

    Dark Tourism: manipulating tourists interpretation

    2003). Reaching this point the author will focus on the case studies of Auschwitz's concentration camps and Fort Siloso, Singapore. According to Slayton, S. L. (2006): ''Auschwitz, in the suburbs of Oswiecim, Poland, was a complex of three concentration camps, Auschwitz I for death (rebuilt in 1979 into a

  2. To what extent can anthropology be seen as the study of indigenous classifications?

    Conklin's study of Hanunoo color categories was perhaps paradigmatic in this sense, and subsequent works of Brenda Beck, Brent Berlin, and others. The principle questions of interest were related to the evolution of classificatory schemes and the determination of their underlying foundations.

  1. How has the West represented the non-West, and what are the political implications of ...

    the part of the West to maintain control in order to retain access to the natural resources the area hold. (Mandaville 2003, p. 214) The ideas that arose are perpetuated today by media portrayal - Muslims continue to be marginalized in Western media, with the little projection provided demonstrating degrading

  2. How have ethnographic analogies have been used in the interpretation of Prehistoric exchange systems?

    Ethnography is usually conducted over a prolonged period of time, but hardly ever spans generations, making it seem as though societies do not change over time. An ethnography that does cover the subject of changes within society is Yunxian Yan?s work on Chinese rural villagers, in which he explores the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work