• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Importance of Belonging in 'Silas Marner'

Extracts from this document...


The Importance of the Theme of Belonging in Silas Marner The theme of belonging is featured frequently, throughout the book, sometimes in more tenuous ways than others. There are many different things in Silas Marner that someone or something can belong to: both abstract and concrete. For example Godfrey belongs to the Cass family which, in turn, belongs to the community of the village. However before one can begin to answer the question of how important belonging is in such situations, it is important to examine how a character or thing can belong to the novel and the outcome of certain belongings along with statements made in the narrative voice by Elliot expressing her opinion on it. Under this topic, the three most relevant sub-topics are belonging to a community and place (these are both heavily linked so can be examined together), belonging to a family or close relationship and also the belonging of possessions. The most blatant example of belonging affecting a character is Silas's changes of attitude to life when he is part of Lantern Yard and Raveloe in different ways. Elliot makes it quite clear when Silas truly belongs to a place and when he doesn't. She shows that Silas is truly part of Lantern Yard by the fact he has close friends (including a girl-friend and William Dane), grew up there, has trust from the other villagers and is part of what makes the village as it is so far as tradition, superstition, religion and rituals. ...read more.


2 Out of all the new relationships that he starts, his paternal relationship with Eppie, after he takes her in, is by far the strongest and has the largest impact on his personality and attitude to life and God. It is not surprising that Silas defends his right to provide for Eppie when Godfrey claims that is would be better for her if him and Nancy took care of her. This question of who she belongs to is very important in the novel as it determines the future of not only Eppie but Godfrey and Nancy, and Silas (who all claim her), and indirectly affects others such as Squire Cass who might, for example, suspect Godfrey's old secret marriage through his taking in Eppie. In chapter 19 of the book this issue comes to a conclusion when Godfrey and Silas debate on who has the right to look after Eppie and who would make her life happier. On reading this Elliot makes it clear that belonging to a family consists of far more than of being the same flesh and blood; it is being part of the same habits, lifestyle, religious practice and social class as well as having love for and from them and history with them. Eppie's decision also plays a large part in this as what one does belong to is largely decided by what one wants to belong to and fortunately for Silas, she takes Elliot's viewpoint on the situation. ...read more.


This is almost undeniable as in every case where someone gains riches or maintains them it does not directly ameliorate any aspect of their situation and in many scenarios it even makes things worse for them. For example, Silas's obsession with collecting gold turns out to be ultimately meaningless as he has no necessity or inclination to spend it and it gives him no true sense of fulfilment or happiness. Another proof of this is Eppie's indifference to Godfrey's property and fortune in terms of who she 3 chooses to look after her. In all the examples I have covered, with the significant exception of the belonging of material possessions, it seems that belonging has a great bearing on the outcome of many situations, which is often made clear through changes of belonging and their effects such as Silas's depression and rejection of religion after he is refused the right to belong to Lantern Yard any longer. One can also make hypothetical situations based on the book where things don't belong to what they should do and in most cases the outcomes will be drastically changed. For example, had Eppie chosen to live with Godfrey and Nancy, Godfrey would be punished for his secret marriage to Molly, Silas would have been devastated and Eppie's character and habits would change. Because almost every aspect of belonging affects the novel and in some cases in great magnitude, I come to a sure conclusion that the theme in general is of very high importance although not quite absolutely essential. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level George Eliot section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level George Eliot essays

  1. George Eliots Middlemarch is a novel embroidered by social relations, marriages, gender roles and ...

    in Antigone, Middlemarch, Howards End and Women in Love, states: By comparing Dorothea's feelings and error, her faith and illusion with those of Saint Theresa, and by pointing to the gap between their ages, Eliot weaves the pattern of a continuous, emotive history against a social background which makes imperfections less heroic.

  2. What is Your Response to the Suggestion that Raveloe is the Main Character Of ...

    villagers, who can only judge him on their own experiences, centred round farming and agriculture. Due to this unfamiliarity, they see even pitiful attributes as sinister. His bad eyesight is thought of as a 'stare'. This reaction of the village acts just as a reaction of a human character.

  1. Introduces her four major concerns illustrated in Silas Marner - namely village life

    The villagers find it difficult to associate the concepts of knowledge or power and goodness with one another. Another thing these country folk are distrustful of are things outside their realm of knowledge, which is fairly small. Anything which they do not comprehend or have not experienced, such as the weavers and their trade, is at once dangerous and suspicious.

  2. Examine Eliot's Presentation of Parenthood in Silas Marner

    His son Dunstan is very dislikeable. He drinks and gambles, the villagers consider him to be "a spiteful jeering fellow" (P33) and "people shook their heads at [Dunstan's] courses"(P32). Ironically Squire Cass considers himself to have been "too good a father" (P88).

  1. 'How successfully does George Elliot balance sympathy and criticism in Godfrey Cass?'

    This is well used and is balanced well so that different readers have different opinion about what kind of person Godfrey really is.

  2. 'How does George Elliot account for the changes that occur over the course of ...

    Thus he is overjoyed even though it is not his gold. This money and hair comparison also helps tie in the last change because although we can see plainly that Silas is very happy now he has Eppie we know that he still would love to have his gold back,

  1. "Silas Marner is nothing more than a fairy story." Do you think this is ...

    She is perfect in many ways, but she is not real. She symbolises an ideal and beautiful character that in reality does not exist. She is entirely fairy tale and she does not have any realistic aspects at all. Aaron is another fairytale character, but we do not know much about him.

  2. Discuss the recurring theme of sympathy, forgiveness and compassion in The Mill on the ...

    Maggie to be content with life, instead of ?numbing? herself for society. Also, Philips forgiveness is portrayed to the audience when he forgives Maggie for running away with Stephen as seen by the phrase ?I am unchangeable yours,? written in Philip?s letter to Maggie.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work