Appearances Can Be Deceiving
ENG 4U Student #: 7076
Period 4 October 22, 2002
M. Lafleur
In 1808, Sir Walter Scott penned, "O, what a tangled web we weave/When first we practise to deceive!" (Marmion 6.17) In life, people often lie and use people in order to preserve an ideal self-image or to get what they want. However, there are often serious repercussions for those who lie and for those around them. In F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby, this theme that deception and self-centeredness has consequences is clearly illustrated. Through the eyes of the narrator, Nick Carraway, the reader saw that the wealthy characters in this novel lived in a superficial society surrounded by their own lies and deception. Many of the residents of East and West Egg used one another in order to get what they wanted, with little care as to how it would affect the people around them, and perhaps, even themselves. To others, their lives seemed perfect; they had everything that money could buy. This image, however, was proven to be no more than a façade. Deceit almost always leads to unhappiness as Daisy, Tom and Gatsby himself illustrated in the course of the novel; they deceived one another and used those around them in order to get what they wanted. But this had grave consequences for each of them.
Daisy Buchanan was portrayed as being sophisticated and refined, but in the course of the novel, she was revealed to be anything but someone possessing these admirable qualities. Nick revealed that Daisy did not need her husband, Tom, in the same way that he needed her. She needed Tom not for love, but for his family history of old money. This dependency helped Daisy remain emotionally stable. As Daisy and Gatsby's history unfolded, it became clear that they, at one point, loved each other very deeply. Gatsby, however, had to leave Daisy to go off to war and when he returned, Daisy had already married Tom. Daisy had always hidden her undying love for Gatsby from Tom, as well as from all the others that were around her at the time of the marriage. She felt as if she needed to prove to society and to herself that she and Tom had a perfect marriage. When Gatsby returned from the war to confess his love for her, Daisy was unable to deal with the situation. Secretly, she began to see Gatsby, without Tom's consent, although she never thought about abandoning Tom and running off with Gatsby. It was Jordan Baker, Nick's girlfriend, who revealed to Nick that on the night before Tom and Daisy had gotten married, that Daisy had drunkenly wept in the bathtub, for she knew that she would not marry Gatsby. Five years later, Daisy confessed to both Tom and Gatsby that she loved Gatsby but that she had loved Tom at the time of their wedding: "Even alone I can't say that I never loved Tom" (Fitzgerald 133). Daisy had to express to Tom that she had loved him in the past in order to retain some hope that Tom would not leave her for someone else. As well as deceiving Tom, Daisy was in fact lying to herself. Daisy knew of Tom's unfaithfulness yet chose not to acknowledge the fact that he was being deceitful. Being brought up in a wealthy family, she was unable to realize that had she left Tom for Gatsby, she probably could have had a more fulfilling life. By constantly deceiving herself, Daisy was unable to attain happiness with either Tom or Gatsby and was, therefore, doomed to lead a wretched life.
ENG 4U Student #: 7076
Period 4 October 22, 2002
M. Lafleur
In 1808, Sir Walter Scott penned, "O, what a tangled web we weave/When first we practise to deceive!" (Marmion 6.17) In life, people often lie and use people in order to preserve an ideal self-image or to get what they want. However, there are often serious repercussions for those who lie and for those around them. In F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby, this theme that deception and self-centeredness has consequences is clearly illustrated. Through the eyes of the narrator, Nick Carraway, the reader saw that the wealthy characters in this novel lived in a superficial society surrounded by their own lies and deception. Many of the residents of East and West Egg used one another in order to get what they wanted, with little care as to how it would affect the people around them, and perhaps, even themselves. To others, their lives seemed perfect; they had everything that money could buy. This image, however, was proven to be no more than a façade. Deceit almost always leads to unhappiness as Daisy, Tom and Gatsby himself illustrated in the course of the novel; they deceived one another and used those around them in order to get what they wanted. But this had grave consequences for each of them.
Daisy Buchanan was portrayed as being sophisticated and refined, but in the course of the novel, she was revealed to be anything but someone possessing these admirable qualities. Nick revealed that Daisy did not need her husband, Tom, in the same way that he needed her. She needed Tom not for love, but for his family history of old money. This dependency helped Daisy remain emotionally stable. As Daisy and Gatsby's history unfolded, it became clear that they, at one point, loved each other very deeply. Gatsby, however, had to leave Daisy to go off to war and when he returned, Daisy had already married Tom. Daisy had always hidden her undying love for Gatsby from Tom, as well as from all the others that were around her at the time of the marriage. She felt as if she needed to prove to society and to herself that she and Tom had a perfect marriage. When Gatsby returned from the war to confess his love for her, Daisy was unable to deal with the situation. Secretly, she began to see Gatsby, without Tom's consent, although she never thought about abandoning Tom and running off with Gatsby. It was Jordan Baker, Nick's girlfriend, who revealed to Nick that on the night before Tom and Daisy had gotten married, that Daisy had drunkenly wept in the bathtub, for she knew that she would not marry Gatsby. Five years later, Daisy confessed to both Tom and Gatsby that she loved Gatsby but that she had loved Tom at the time of their wedding: "Even alone I can't say that I never loved Tom" (Fitzgerald 133). Daisy had to express to Tom that she had loved him in the past in order to retain some hope that Tom would not leave her for someone else. As well as deceiving Tom, Daisy was in fact lying to herself. Daisy knew of Tom's unfaithfulness yet chose not to acknowledge the fact that he was being deceitful. Being brought up in a wealthy family, she was unable to realize that had she left Tom for Gatsby, she probably could have had a more fulfilling life. By constantly deceiving herself, Daisy was unable to attain happiness with either Tom or Gatsby and was, therefore, doomed to lead a wretched life.