• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing the poems "Dr Mr Lee" and "Reports".

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparing the poems "Dr Mr Lee" and "Reports". In many of U A Fanthorpe's poems, she explores the themes of education and school. In my essay I am going to focus on two of her poems, Dr Mr Lee and Reports. I will discuss the similarities and differences between the two poems. The poem Dr Mr Lee is written from the point of view of a student, writing to the author of a book "Cider with Rosie". She is apologising for failing the exam and says how much she dislikes English and how much she enjoyed the book. Fanthorpe's critical of the way English literature is taught and examined. The student shows this by writing to the author of the autobiography "Cider and Rosie" and apologising for failing the exam. ...read more.

Middle

The tone of the poem is friendly. The student's attitude towards Mr Lee is shown by words such as "Dear Laurie" and "(sorry)". He brackets the word sorry to apologise for saying his first name. The poet uses only two full stops throughout the letter and jumps from one topic to another. This shows how excited the student is about Mr Lee, and creates the impression that the student is almost out of breath. "I'd just like to be like you, not mind about being poor see everything bright and strange, the way you do, and I've got the next one out of the public library, about Spain, and I asked mum about learning how to play the fiddle, but Mr Smart says Spain isn't like that anymore." ...read more.

Conclusion

"Born at the Sound Beginning, We mover from Satisfactory to fair, then find the subject difficult, Learning at last we could have done better." The tone in Reports is confident, assertive authoritative. In both of these poems, Fanthorpe is critical of the schools system. "Dr Mr Lee is criticising the way literature is taught by showing that the student never enjoyed English before and that exams spoil the enjoyment of English literature, for students like the one who writes this letter. Reports is criticizing the way teachers use their comments in the reports. Really they don't think about the students themselves. They write what come straight into their minds, or comments that won't lead to much discussion or get the teacher into trouble. The difference between the two poems is that "Dr Mr Lee" is written from a student's point of view and "Reports" is written from a teacher's point of view. Qasim Shaikh 11.C ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE U A Fanthorpe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE U A Fanthorpe essays

  1. Half Past Two and Dear Mr.Lee

    This could very well be Fanthorpe's experience of writing reports, which has been reflected on this passage. She has written these clich�s in italics, as this is the gimmick to the poem. The poem commences with the most common clich� of all, "has made a sound beginning", which "strikes the right note", but is "dull".

  2. By Reference to three poems in the 'Tracks' anthology, discuss how Fanthorpe explores the ...

    is in actuality, the characterisations that are placed on them by authority are still always prioritised when people are judging the person, causing their individuality to be lost. The next character Fanthorpe chooses to explore is that of the stereotypically 'helpless' character, the maiden.

  1. Using the poems 'Dear Mr. Lee' and 'Report' both written by U A Fanthorpe, ...

    "I didn't want to write a character-sketch of your mother under headings, it seemed wrong somehow when you'd made her so lovely" The child feels that these questions ruin the book, and

  2. How does U.A Fanthorpe express her attitude to our Education system in her poems ...

    and "timetogohomenowtime." He'd never even heard of 'half past two.' What was that?! The teacher was very forgetful: "Being cross, she'd forgotten she hadn't taught him time" and "My goodness, she said, I forgot all about you." Also the little boy was too scared to ask her about 'half past

  1. Look again at the poems "Half-past Two", "Reports" and "Dear Mr. Lee". How does ...

    As a pupil at the time he hadn't done anything serious as it had not played a significant part in his life. The use of vocabulary such as "Grantime" indicates to the reader it's a small child. Due to the fact the little boy's illiterate the spoken words sound like a single unit: "Gettinguptime, timeyouwereofftime."

  2. Comparing Communication of Facts, Emotion and Purpose between The Reports of Fergal Keane and ...

    Fergal Keane is more open with his writing unlike Primo Levi's. Primo Levi's skill of writing shows off his way of letting the reader feel and understand what it is like for him. Both stories tell what it was like, their experience(s)

  1. I will attempt to analyse and compare two different poems which are called 'dear ...

    you, not mind about being poor' this shows that s/he doesn't mind about the little things in life like money s/he wants to be just like his/her idol (Mr lee). Both poets use similar techniques to show how the student is feeling for e.g.

  2. "Telephone conversation" by Wole Soyinka and "You will be hearing from us shortly" by ...

    For example, "Might they perhaps, find your appearance disturbing?" This suggests that the interviewer is being prejudiced against the interviewee's appearance. The question asked also shows that the interviewer is selfish because he or she does not care about the interviewee's feeling. It would also make the interviewee feel useless and powerless.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work