"Calvin's success in Geneva was due to the organisation and disciplineOf the movement rather than to his theology" how far do you agree with this Statement?

Authors Avatar

“Calvin’s success in Geneva was due to the organisation and discipline

Of the movement rather than to his theology” how far do you agree with this

Statement?

During the Reformation, Calvin was very successful in changing religious practices and getting his ideas across. Geneva had been under the rule of the House of Savoy, but the Genevans successfully overthrew the Savoys and the local bishop-prince of Geneva in the waning years of the 1520's. The Genevans, however, unlike the citizens of Zurich, Bern, Basel, and other cities that became Protestant in the 1520's, were not German-speakers but primarily French-speakers. As such, they did not have close cultural ties with the reformed churches in Germany and Switzerland. The Protestant canton of Bern, however, was determined to see Protestantism spread throughout Switzerland. In 1533, Bern sent Protestant reformers to convert Geneva into a Protestant city; after considerable conflict, Geneva officially became Protestant in 1535.  

  His most important work involved the organisation of church governance and the social organisation of the church and the city. He was, in fact, the first major political thinker to model social organisation entirely on biblical principles. At first his reforms did not go over well. He addressed the issue of church governance by creating leaders within the new church; he himself developed a catechism designed to impose doctrine on all the members of the church. He and Guillaume Farel (1489-1565) imposed a strict moral code on the citizens of Geneva; this moral code was derived from a literal reading of Christian scriptures. Naturally, the people of Geneva believed that they had thrown away one church only to see it replaced by an identical twin; in particular, they saw Calvin's reforms as imposing a new form of papacy on the people, only with different names and different people.  His most important innovation was the incorporation of the church into city government; he immediately helped to restructure municipal government so that clergy would be involved in municipal decisions, particularly in disciplining the populace. He imposed a hierarchy on the Genevan church and began a series of statute reforms to impose a strict and uncompromising moral code on the city.  By the mid-1550's, Geneva was thoroughly Calvinist in thought and structure. It became the most important Protestant centre of Europe in the sixteenth century, for Protestants driven out of their native countries of France, England, Scotland, and the Netherlands all came to Geneva to take refuge. By the middle of the sixteenth century, between one-third and one-half of the city was made up of these foreign Protestants. In Geneva, these foreign reformers adopted the more radical Calvinist doctrines; most of them had arrived as moderate Reformers and left as thoroughgoing Calvinists. It is probably for this reason that Calvin's brand of reform eventually became the dominant branch of Protestantism from the seventeenth century onwards.  Calvinism combined flexible organisation locally with coherent organisation at a regional and national level, giving it great political strength.  

Join now!

  Calvin’s theology was also very important as he created principal ideas that were originally set out in six chapters in a famous book called institutes of the Christian religion’ which was published in 1536. . His theology, therefore, is biblical rather than scholastic, and has all the freshness of enthusiastic devotion to the truths of God’s Word. He was greatly influenced by Erasmus, Luther and Bucer but not Zwingli, for whom he had little respect.  Calvin did not have an original mind, but he knew how to avoid the theological confusion and complexities, which surrounded the first generation of ...

This is a preview of the whole essay