Preliminary experiment 1:
Preliminary results:
In my second preliminary test I changed the temperature instead of the size of chip. I tested this by heating equal lengths of potato and equal quantities of H2O2 together to different temperatures.
Preliminary experiment 2:
Preliminary results 2:
Main:
Enzymes are effected buy various different things, temperature, pH and the concentration of both the enzyme and the substrates. These factors all alter the rate at which the enzymes work.
Temperature:
Enzymes are affected a great deal by temperature, this graph from my 2nd preliminary experiment shows the amount temperature affects the rate of reaction between enzymes and substrates. It shows that the enzymes work best at 40 degrees and that past that, the rate of reaction decreases. This is because the enzymes become denatured and there fore their active sites cannot break down the H2O2:
We are not using this as our changing factor as temperature also affects the H2O2 substrate. Therefore we are controlling this at room temperature.
PH:
Enzymes are affected by changes in pH. The most favourable pH value - the point where the enzyme is most active - is known as the optimum pH. This is graphically illustrated in the diagram below.
Extremely high or low pH values generally result in complete loss of activity for most enzymes. PH is also a factor in the stability of enzymes. As with activity, for each enzyme there is also a region of pH optimal stability.
The optimum pH value will vary greatly from one enzyme to another, as the table shows:
pH for Optimum Activity
In addition to temperature and pH there are other factors, such as ionic strength, which can affect the enzymatic reaction. Each of these physical and chemical parameters must be considered and optimised in order for an enzymatic reaction to be accurate and reproducible.
We are keeping this factor at pH 7.0, which is ironically the optimum pH for catalase.
Substrate concentration:
It has been shown experimentally that if the amount of the enzyme is kept constant and the substrate concentration is then gradually increased, the reaction velocity will increase until it reaches a maximum. After this point, increases in substrate concentration will not increase the velocity. We are controlling this by using 10cm of 20 volume H2O2 in each test tube.
Enzyme surface area:
This experiment tests the effect of different sized potato chips (and therefore more surface area of catalase) reacting with H2O2. Therefore we are controlling this factor by changing the length of the chip and recording the amount of gas given off (shown in the “main” diagram), this will then be recorded. The range of results will be from 1cm to 5cm sized potato chips in hydrogen peroxide recorded every 30 seconds over a period of 5 minutes, the measurement is of the amount of gas given off.
To work out the total surface area you must add each of the side surface areas together. For example Chip A is 5x1x1, to get the total surface area 5x1x4 = 20 (you times it by 4 because of the 4 sides, and don’t forget the top and bottom sides) 1x1x2 = 2 + 20 = 22cm2. For 4x1x1 the total surface area would be 18cm2, for 3x1x1 it would be 14cm2, 2x1x1 would be 10cm2, and finally 1x1x1 would give you 6cm2
Prediction:
I predict that the larger the surface area of the chip the more gas will be given off quicker than a smaller sized chip. This is because my 1st preliminary experiment behaved in a similar way and it is obvious that the rate will increase with surface area I predict that the rate will increase proportional to the surface area.
Fair test:
To keep the experiment a fair test we shall keep the potato chips submerged in water until they are required for testing this is to keep them fresh as if it was not done then the chips may oxidise on the surface reducing the area that reacts with the H2O2. Also take great care in measuring so that the results are accurate. Make sure that the measuring cylinder is refilled with water after each test so that the previous gas given off is not added to the next ruining results.
We shall measure and keep the temperature constant (27O C room temperature) throughout the experiment to prevent this factor from changing the results. We shall also measure and maintain a level pH of 7.0. The substrate concentration I have realised would be used up in the experiment so would decrease as the experiment is carried out. We can however improve this by increasing the volume of hydrogen peroxide at the start, which would lower the concentration change of the substrate. We are of course changing the enzyme surface area and we are going to measure the chip sizes very carefully and accurately, using a ruler.
Safety:
Always wear goggles in case any unpredicted accidents occur, wear gloves and take great care when handling the hydrogen peroxide, if under the age of 14 get an adult to supervise the experiment and make sure you can get to a tap to clean your hands after testing. Get an adult to use the knife if you aren’t already one and cut up the potato chips carefully and accurately using a ruler.
Equipment:
Test tube rack, measuring cylinder, stop clock, container filled with water, test tubes, stand, clamps, plug with tube, potato chips in water (1x1 in breadth and depth), knife, tile, ruler, gloves, Hydrogen peroxide (20 volume), goggles, universal indicator and thermometer.
Diagram:
Method:
- Set up equipment as shown.
- Fill the container and measuring cylinder with water.
- Pull the water filled measuring cylinder upside down out of the water without letting any air in, (make sure there isn’t any air trapped in there otherwise it will obscure the end evidence).
- Put the end of the tube inside the measuring cylinder with the plug end kept above the other so it doesn’t let any water out.
- Extreme Caution: Measure out 20 ml of hydrogen peroxide in a measuring cylinder VERY CAREFULLY, then pour it into a test tube. H2O2 Burns the skin and can blind if it gets into the eyes and if not washed out immediately, wear gloves and goggles whilst doing this.
- Cut a fresh potato chip to 1cm length on a tile to prevent damage to the surface you are working on. (Use the ruler very carefully and accurately to insure reliable results, and remember to cut both ends to make it a fair test and to allow an equal area of fresh potato to come in contact with the H2O2, take care whilst using the knife.)
- Drop the potato chip into the H2O2 in the test tube, put the plug in the test tube (without forcing any air into the measuring cylinder), and start the stop clock. All at preferably the same time, so get someone to help you do this as quickly at accurately as possible.
- Record the amount of gas given off (oxygen) every 30 seconds for 5 minutes and measure and maintain the unchanging factors using the thermometer and universal indicator.
- Repeat stages 3 to 8 for 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 cm length chips, doing each
size 3 times to increase the overall accuracy of the experiment.
Results 1:
Results 2:
Results 3:
Average results: (to 2 decimal places)
Analysis
These graphs compliment my prediction, though I did not predict the reduction of rate later on in the experiment, now that I have seen the results it is obvious that the H2O2 concentration reduces through the experiment because of the enzyme converting it to Oxygen and water. This would mean that the rate of reaction is slower towards the end of the experiments. We could fix this by adding more substrate (H2O2) to the enzymes in the beginning, so instead of 20 ml have 30 or 40. Other than that our experiment ran very well. We observed and recorded as accurate a measurement as possible and there were no major anomalies, bar the one I have marked on the results table 2, though the average results have reduced the anomaly so our experiment worked overall very well. Our results were measured accurately and correctly, the only way to improve the accuracy would be to computerise the readings.
On the average results graph we can see the rate increases with larger surface area. This results table shows the gradient of the rate of reaction from 0-30 seconds, 120-150 seconds, and 270-300 seconds.
Conclusion:
I conclude that the more area of Catalase Enzyme in contact with the H2O2 (and therefore more active sites) the greater the rate of reaction. We can clearly see on the average graph that the gradient of a 5cm-length chip is greater than that of a 1cm-length chip. From the gradient results table we can see that the rate of reaction is much faster from chip E than A.
Evaluation:
To improve the experiment I would instigate more tests to increase reliability. There was also a reduction of rate later on in the experiment, now that I have seen the results it is obvious that the H2O2 concentration reduces through the experiment because of the enzyme converting it to Oxygen and water. This would mean that the rate of reaction is slower towards the end of the experiments. We could fix this by adding more substrate (H2O2) to the enzymes in the beginning, so instead of 20 ml have 30 or 40. Then to improve accuracy and reliability I could keep the mass the same whilst increasing the surface area. This would reduce the chance for anomalous results. I would do this by weighing out chips of the same mass then dissecting them into 1/2s, 1/4s, 1/6s etc. this would give me the total surface area I would need without any unnecessary change in mass.
To validate the results of this experiment we could easily carry out another investigation to see if the results compliment each other. For example, I could improve on this experiment and instead of taking different sized chips, I could take 1 size of chip (which would remove the problem and possibility of a mass factor) and dissect it into 1/2s 1/4s and 1/6ths.
Method 2:
- Place three boiling tubes in a boiling tube rack, and fill them with 20ml of hydrogen peroxide by using a measuring cylinder. Also, ensure that the temperature is at the enzymes optimum.
- Cut the potato into required size. First I shall test a whole chip with the surface area of 226.2mm, then two half chips with a surface area of 317.2mm then four quarter chips with a surface area of 385.3mm and finally six, 6ths of a chip with a surface area of 430.5mm.
- Measure the amount of gas produced every 30 seconds. Repeat every surface area three times and take an average.
- The experiment will be kept fair, as I will only change the one variable at a time.
- I will be wearing goggles to prevent damage to my eyes if any hydrogen peroxide is accidentally spilt.
Predicted results graph:
I predict that the new experiment would give off similar results to our original one, i.e. the greater the surface area, the more contact between the catalaze enzyme and the hydrogen peroxide, and therefore more gas is given off quicker, thus altogether giving large evidence for the collision theory and proving that surface area has as a great positive correlation affect to the rate of a reaction, weather it be for enzymes or chemicals.