A Yankee's Argument of post-Civil War Reconstruction

The biggest, and longest lasting scars that came out of the civil war in the south were Social, Economic, and Physical. The most obvious and apparent thing that could be noticed in the aftermath was the physical environment in the south. It truly took a beating, and is a reminder that war always comes with many consequences to the land. Bridges and ferries that where vital to trade and transport were now burned to the ground leaving only ash. Travel in the south then became rather difficult because of having to now manage to get across rivers that were deep with swiftly running water. Trees and farms laid in ruins, and really altered the landscape into a desert like atmosphere in many places. Truly worthy of the names “war zone/battle field”. But even though things sounded really bad, many places and industry were able to be rebuilt. The civil war didn’t make the south absolutely uninhabitable, but rather just a huge disaster that people could rebuild upon. The economics of the south really was one of the hardest hit areas. Before the war (and before 1860), the south had the strongest banking system. The five cotton states of South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, and Louisiana outranked all the other regions of the United States in all of the important economic areas such as invested capital, notes (dollar bills if you will), and the average level of deposits per bank. However, because of the south leaving the union, having to support itself, and many other factors, by about 1865 banking came almost to a complete halt. The Bank of Charleston in South Carolina for example, which was the second largest financial institution, forced it way to stay open, but in less than three years had to be closed. Many of the loans that were made by the banks were based on a chain of credit that was mostly based on the amount of land and slaves someone had. When the slaves got emancipated, all value of land the average plantation owner had was about one-fourth of it’s antebellum value. In 1865 the Banking Act was put into effect, which made it almost impossible for banks to be established in the south because of it’s minimum requirements for paid-in capital and restrictions on making mortgage lending. The banks that were established were difficult to keep open, and by 1869, four of them closed mostly because of a rate that was six times the national average. The social/economic problem that the south created for itself was that of not advancing with technology and industry. The south based its system on slave labor, while in the north, industry took root and technology made work easier for the fewer men that were able to work. If the south abandoned slavery, they probably won’t of been as crippled after the war than if they had industry to rely more on. Once slavery was gone, it was time for the south to have a total makeover in their system. I believe that the south created most of it’s own problems. There were not ready to take the burden of being on their own when they left the union. In the end, they were faced with the harsh reality of this. At least the bad times didn’t last forever for them, but they did have to struggled to rebuild, which wasn’t easy.