• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Elaine Showalter argues that Ophelias tragedy is subordinated in the play. Through comparison of Hamlet and Ophelia, how far do you agree?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Elaine Showalter argues that Ophelia's tragedy "is subordinated in the play". Through comparison of Hamlet and Ophelia, how far do you agree? In her article "Representing Ophelia: Women, Madness and the Responsibilities of Feminist Criticism", Elaine Showalter states that Ophelia's tragedy "is subordinated in the play". Hamlet is an Elizabethan play written by William Shakespeare - named after the protagonist. Hamlet, feels responsible to take revenge on his father's murderer, Claudius, and during this conflict he slays Ophelia's father and rejects Ophelia, whom he had previously courted. Whilst Hamlet is clearly the play's central character, Shakespeare allows his audience to see how the deaths of both Hamlet's and Ophelia's fathers lead to their madness, causing the audience to compare Hamlet's and Ophelia's tragedies and enabling us to examine whether Ophelia's tragedy in the play is subordinated to Hamlet's. Hamlet is an Elizabethan play and the audience would be aware that it is a play set in a patriarchal society. This is emphasised through Ophelia, who throughout the play is dependent on men and relies on her father and brother, Laertes. This is evident when she gives in to Polonius's scheme to spy on Hamlet with no indication that she might resist and only replies ...read more.

Middle

O God, God! How weary, stale, flat and unprofitable Seem to me all the uses of this world" Here is Hamlet's first soliloquy, where he starts to contemplate suicide and explains how it is desirable for someone whose life has become so pointless. Shakespeare, through these soliloquies, allows us to sympathise with Hamlet and we can relate to his emotions and therefore relate to his tragedy more. In this way Shakespeare prioritises Hamlet's tragedy over that of Ophelia, who has far less to say. However, we also learn that Hamlet is extremely philosophical and contemplative. Here, he contemplates suicide ("self-slaughter") but his thoughts are balanced by the fact that he realises it is forbidden by the Christian God ("the Everlasting"). Similarly, in the soliloquy in Act Three Scene One, Hamlet says, "To be or not to be"; again weighing the moral factors of suicide. Even the structure of this phrase, which has the infinitive verb 'to be' on either side, suggests the balanced nature of his mind. Hamlet represents a Renaissance, noble man; therefore to an Elizabethan audience the tragic end of a respected and educated man would create more impact as opposed to a "frail", dependent Ophelia. ...read more.

Conclusion

Therefore, her subordinate character could heighten her tragedy to a modern audience. However, we could argue that whilst Hamlet considers moral choices and alternatives, Ophelia takes action by committing suicide without procrastinating - something which Hamlet wants to be able to do. Therefore, it could be considered that despite her character being subordinate, her tragedy is of major relevance because it shows her as an active figure in her own fate, by drowning herself in her sorrows; she has a role in her own tragic end. An Elizabethan audience would be familiar with seeing women presented as weak and therefore Ophelia's presentation as 'frail' in the play allows her tragedy to be subordinated because it was expected, Ophelia herself seems to contribute to these expectations. Hamlet, by contrast, represents an Elizabethan Renaissance man with the ability to reason, think logically and therefore withstand his suicide, making his eventual death at the hands of Laertes and Claudius seem the greater loss and the dominant tragedy of the play. However, to a modern audience Ophelia's dependence on men, her absence from most of the play (and, by implication, society) and her unheard female voice could create more disbelief and sympathy towards Ophelia, allowing her subordinated character to be the foremost tragedy of the play. Anika Chauhan - Hamlet Coursework ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    Hana tells Caravaggio all she has learned about death in her work as a nurse. She tells him that, after a while, she refused to have anything to do with the soldiers on a personal level. She withdrew emotionally and threw herself into her work.

  2. Hamlet: The Controversy of Ophelia

    Laertes says, "Perhaps he loves you now and now no soil nor cautel doth besmirch the virtue of his will: but you must fear, his greatness weighed, his will is not his own....," (I,III 14-17.) Laertes harshly tells Ophelia to not have high expectations for Hamlet because his love will

  1. The Savagery in this play excludes laughter. Explore this argument in relation to Hamlet ...

    Claudius' confusion is definitely amusing to the audience and it is finally ended when he asks bluntly: "Where is Polonius?" We can also look closely at the beginning of act three in RT where Ambitioso and Supervacuo set off to the prison to order the execution of the Duke's son.

  2. Lord of the flies comparison

    outlaws who use children to commit petty crimes on their behalf; "the Board" and Mr. Bumble fail to hold Oliver's best interests at heart as they put him in positions where he is abused, mistreated and left uncared for. The representation of adults is not completely negative in Oliver Twist,

  1. How far can a feminist reading be applied to The Yellow Wallpaper?

    The subordinated wife experiences short lived liberation from male domination, ironically before dying from shock upon realising that her presumably dead husband is alive. Misinformed, the wife looks out of the window seeing ?the tops of trees? all aquiver with new spring life? evoking her mistaken response of ?self-assertion?, ?Free!

  2. How is Madness presented through the protagonist in The Yellow Wallpaper compared to The ...

    As a narrator, Esther is very self critical, which contrasts with the other characters in the book who seem very complacent; none of the other characters talk about politics and seem to just wipe the bad things in the world away from sight, for example the reader notices how Doreen

  1. Examine Shakespeares presentation of women in Hamlet. Show how far your appreciation and understanding ...

    act 3 scene iv of the play evidence of the strain this has put on her conscience comes to light during her conversation with Hamlet, as she says ?Take this infectious spot out of my soul?. A feminist reading of the negative presentation of the female characters in the two

  2. Female characters in "The Kite Runner", "Hamlet" and the short story "A Lot to ...

    Gertrude is seen as unequal to the the almost all-male cast. Gertrude is a female character from Shakespeare?s famous play Hamlet. The play is set in Denmark, early 14th century, and tells the story of a young prince, Hamlet, who gets a visit from his dead father?s ghost, and realizes that not all is right in the state of Denmark.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work