• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Disraeli's second ministry deserves the title a great reforming ministry Discuss how far you agree with this view in relation to Gladstone first Ministry.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Disraeli's second ministry deserves the title a great reforming ministry" Discuss how far you agree with this view in relation to Gladstone first Ministry. A great reforming ministry is a government which manages to radically alter the political and social scene, aiming to deal with the most pressing problems and creating a long term legacy whereby later ministries aim to protect and improve what has been achieved instead of trying to alter radically. This is why it becomes clear that Gladstone ministry and not Disraeli's should be considered a great reforming ministry. The aims of both ministries were radically different. Gladstone's aims for his ministry when he came into power in 1867 were to try and create a more efficient and meritocratic society which removed privileges and advocated individualistic self-reliance. This ideology of beliefs were formed due to Gladstone long held religious beliefs which drove him and in the liberal ideas of equality of opportunity, tolerance and individualism he saw the best system to try and create a society based on Christian morals. Throughout all his legislation Gladstone aimed for the fair and just decision explaining his desire to try and pacify Ireland. This is in contrast to Disraeli's aims as Prime Minister from 1874. Disraeli had managed to finally get the conservatives elected after being out of power for over ten years, and he achieved ...read more.

Middle

This was particularity important for a working class which aimed to be free individuals who wanted the vote and an equal footing. Whilst Disraeli's legislation although Important was hampered due to Disraeli's desire to minimise the impact of reform and to only focus on non-controversial areas. The 1875 Artisans dwelling act is a clear example of weak legislation, the act meant that councils could compel owners of slums to sell their property and allow the council to knock-down the slums and then sell the land to private building firms. However the legislation was permissive so the council didn't have to ensure slums were removed and it required councils to give compensation to the landowners and so by the end of Disraeli's term the act had only been used in 10 councils making its impact very mild. Whilst other acts such as the 1875 Agriculture holdings act show Disraeli is unable to make truly effective legislation because he wishes to protect the power base of the upper class. The act should of ensured that tenants that improve their land receive compensation but Disraeli made the act permissive and stated that if there was a condition in contract which stated the landowner didn't have to pay compensation then the landowner didn't have too. ...read more.

Conclusion

Also Gladstone failed in one of his key aims which was to pacify Ireland but he was the one of the few politicians who was truly trying to find a workable solution instead of coercion. Whilst Disraeli was voted out not because he had made a massive impact but because he was Prime Minister whilst the economy entered recession, this meant that his mild measure had even less impact and his expensive imperialistic aims were highly controversial. So due to the recession Disraeli failed to alleviate the condition of the people and his other aims meant his government appeared to stall resulting in his popularity dropping. Overall although his legislation was occasionally flawed the overall improvement and effect that Gladstone's ministry had on the country reflect a great reforming ministry. Gladstone's Liberal beliefs in meritocratic and individual society have become corner stones of British society reflecting the ministries long term impact and legislation such as the licensing act although unpopular at the time has only been amended never removed by later governments as they see the positive impacts of the restriction of alcohol. This reflected against Disraeli's achievement of mildly modify Gladstone's legislation and avoiding awkward decision domestically or trying to alter the status quo shows that his ministry cannot be considered a great reforming ministry. As such I disagree with the view that Disraeli's government was a great reforming government instead arguing that it was his predecessor Gladstone that was clearly the great reforming ministry. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level British History: Monarchy & Politics essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How liberal were Gladstone's domestic reforms during his first ministry?

    5 star(s)

    In addition it encouraged more people to enter the army, as the service was not only longer but now it was possible to enlist without having an aristocratic background.

  2. Peer reviewed

    Assess how far the success of Gladstones first ministry was due to ...

    3 star(s)

    health of society which he tried to improve with the start of a national health system. He, as a result of this, set up the licensing act which although quite permissive, hindered the liquor trade in a multitude of ways, without completely stopping it.

  1. Does Alexander II deserve the title of 'Tsar liberator'?

    As such, it is clear that the zemstva reforms were not introduced to further liberate the peasants, but were used to satisfy their hunger for a vote. Instead of empowering the newly liberated peasants, Alexander tried to retain as much control as possible for himself and the nobility and shaped

  2. TO WHAT EXTENT DID GLADSTONE AND DISRAELI PURSUE DIFFERENT POLICIES IN THE YEARS 1874-1886?

    Even as countries like USA and Russia began to increase duties and import tariffs, making British exports less competitive, Disraeli and Gladstone doggedly persisted with laissez-faire economics in their respective ministries. Another way in which Gladstone and Disraeli were similar was their approach to domestic social reform.

  1. How far did Gladstone achieve his stated aim of pacifying Ireland

    Loans were insufficient and many tenants lacked the capital to raise the deposit. Less than 1,000 tenants availed of this act. One way in which Gladstone attempted to pacify Ireland was through reforming the Church. He strived to do this through the Irish Church Act of 1869, this was key

  2. Why was the Great Contract of great significance

    have been a bit too much to handle because as in his early years as James VI king of Scotland was that in the hierarchy of finance, England and Scotland were a long distance apart and Scotland compared to England was poverty stricken if you will.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work