• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In September 2003, schoolteacher Paul Ellis was jailed for manslaughter after the death of a ten-year-old boy on a school trip. The types of newspaper, which the articles I will be analysing are in, will be the "Daily Express" and the "Sunday Times".

Extracts from this document...


Karen foreman GCSE English Media Assignment In September 2003, schoolteacher Paul Ellis was jailed for manslaughter after the death of a ten-year-old boy on a school trip. The types of newspaper, which the articles I will be analysing are in, will be the "Daily Express" and the "Sunday Times". One is a tabloid and one is broadsheet but both contain the same story printed in them. In the "Daily Express" the Journalist's viewpoint and line of argument emerges as the teacher being careless and irresponsible. The writer then suggests that the boy followed his teacher's lead. The following point he makes is of the boy's horrific death. We then see that the teacher wanted to avoid the trip being wasted because of weather. Next letting us see as a result that the teacher made an unwise judgement and ignored the level of danger. Later we are told of the Paul Ellis's helplessness in saving Max whilst being forced to give up because of extreme conditions and exhaustion. Next we are told in great detail how Mrs Palmer tried to save her son but was too weak. The writer then tells us how terrified Max was. Nearing the end of the points we are told of another student saving the mother when her strength faded. Then we read of Paul Ellis's devastated reaction when hearing news of death. Then we see the blame shifted this time so we see the school being partly to blame. ...read more.


The headline for this article is very powerful, it immediately turns the reader against the teacher by using Max's dying words as the headline "Please" increases sense of fear and desperation again increasing criticism against Paul Ellis and "mummy" suggests that Max is a very young child. The quote from Max also creates empathy. "Please don't let Me die, mummy" The writer then explains and repeats the heading in the opening paragraph this helps to deepen the impact of the headline. "Teacher jailed as court hears tragic plea of 10-year-old who drowned on school trip" Here we can see emotive vocabulary used in the strap line, which immediately creates pity. There are three pictures placed in the article, a small picture of Paul Ellis showing only his head and shoulders. In this picture he looks awkward and uncomfortable. He is dressed in casual clothes rather than a suit; this reduces respect and trust for Paul Ellis. The next is the main picture set in the centre with Mrs Palmer and Max, this increases the reader's empathy and as they are situated in front of home showing the reader of their home life which has now been taken away. Last there is a picture of Red Tarn Beck where max drowned, this is added with the word "treacherous" adding to the feeling of danger and Ellis's foolishness. There is also a down page story to reinforce the key idea that trips need to be "properly planned". ...read more.


"Tragedy of a foolish teacher and our futile desire to jail" So as we can see this article is based on centralising the argument that runs through it. There are two pictures placed in the article, one a small picture of John Humphrys a well-known journalist this helps the reader immediately build trust and empathise with him. The next is a picture of Max Palmer and his mother superimposed against the scene where the "tragedy" took place. With a caption saying: " Death on a school trip: Max Palmer with his mother " There we see no suggestion made of blame. There are a few similarities and differences between the two articles. Firstly is the "The Sunday Times" is a news review rather than an article reporting events were as in "The Daily Express" it is reporting on the event. This is also show, when the opinions of the writer are more clearly voiced in "The Sunday Times" compared to in "The Daily Express" where the opinions are more hidden. Yet they both have the same picture of Max Palmer with his mother but on different backgrounds. In my personal opinion I would say that the "The Daily Express" is more informative, where as "The Sunday Times" is more successful in convincing the reader to share the line of argument as it is shown more clearly in the writing. Both articles are cleverly put together to give the reader a good insight into the line of argument it wishes to put across. By Karen Foreman 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. Compare and contrast the three newspaper articles, explaining carefully what you like and dislike ...

    It goes on to give an explanation why his chin lacks strength, 'he lacked experience of pacing a fight and of developing stamina'. The articles all have different impressions of Tim Witherspoon. The Star article doesn't seem to care about him at all.

  2. Comment On The Similarities and Differences Between Two Newspaper Articles, On Princess Diana's Visit ...

    The headline reads; 'The shirt was Lauren, the jeans were by Armani ... and the tears flowed right on cue' the headline shows that the article will be expressing a negative tone towards the Princess. The headline names out very famous designer brands, which she was wearing to her trip to Bosnia, which is a country in poverty.

  1. The two articles we have looked at for analysis have a common theme - ...

    Both anecdotes impart the addiction to sunbeds. In the interview with Jane Horwood, the writer wants to illustrate the full effect of using sunbeds; however Victoria Williams' account to demonstrate some people's unacquaintance with health hazards posed by regular sessions on the sunbeds.

  2. 'Disaster in the Alps' - comparing and analysing how the Times, Mirror and American ...

    Such as from a fireman at the incident, saying the occupants "stood no chance." This kind of quote is only integrated to evoke feelings of damnation towards America and the pilots, which isn't ascribable in the other two articles. The tabloid is also fixated with human-interest stories, shying away from

  1. Journalist Stuart Wavell wrote an article for the Sunday Times about a pre-battle speech ...

    This is also an emotive quote. John uses the word 'we' to make the readers feel involved and agree with what John is saying to help in the convincing that Collins is a good orator. Towards the end of the article, Wavell compares other pre-battle speeches to that of Collins.

  2. Analyze 3 different newspaper articles - the articles are taken from 'The Mirror,' 'The ...

    Even the sub-headline says that 'Europe questions America's character'. This all starts to confuse the reader and so does not give an accurate picture of the incident. The words used also try to disagree with the facts of the incident.

  1. As a part of my Media Studies coursework this year I have decided to ...

    The main photographs on broadsheets are linked with the main story; the tabloid photograph usually has a picture of a celebrity and then indicates the page number for more about the story. I decided to design the front pages of a tabloid newspaper because they appealed more to me.

  2. Comparison of Newspaper Articles

    they may be more bias to one side of the story). Two different English newspapers and an American magazine have covered the event that I have studied. The newspapers are the tabloid The Mirror and the broadsheet The Times, the magazine is Newsweek.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work