• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent is Marxism a flawed political ideology?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent is Marxism a flawed political ideology? Ever since Marxism was established as a political ideology it has been subject to much scrutiny; as Karl Marx gave his opinions of society based on either scientific evidence or personal belief, it was only natural that some would disagree and thus criticise his convictions. The majority of Marx's ideology was based on the idea that the superstructure of society was totally dependent on the economic base (and any changes made to it), and that the capitalist society in which we currently live would create a revolutionary working class which would ultimately lead to a communist society. Essentially, Marx claimed that communism was inevitable, and this was a heavily criticised aspect of Marx's overall ideology. As this suggested that human history is not something that individuals have any control over, critics argued that Marxism was more comparable with a religion rather than a scientific theory. This was further reinforced by Karl Raimond Popper's argument that Marxism was unscientific as it could not be disproved. Defenders of Marx claimed that although Marx had publicly used the term 'inevitable' on several occasions, it was only to emphasise the importance of his ideas; in his more serious works he did not suggest that communism and other stages of history which he discussed were inevitable. For example, it is argued that one of his ideas that was often misconstrued was the idea that a capitalist society would eventually ...read more.


Critics disputed that this deterministic approach to describe the progression of human history was too simplistic, and that it does not comply with what has actually occurred throughout history. In opposition to Marx's idea that history was a progression of ever improving stages which would eventually lead to the final (and 'best') stage of communism, it was argued that critical accidents and mistakes e.g. Hitler's decision to invade Russia in 1941, which led to his downfall, played an important role in history. Others argued further that human history was not a series of ever improving stages, but cycles whereby social development could have gone backwards or forwards in improvement. Additionally, some believed that G-d has an overall plan and decides the development and fate of human history. Once again Marx was defended in the argument that his concepts had been misconstrued to be more deterministic than they seemed; Marx's theory of history was not supposed to reflect every period of human history, as he acknowledged that society could go backwards and forwards in development. Marx's concepts examined the key turning points in history, mainly the r/evolution of society charting transitions from feudalism, to liberalism, then capitalism, and eventually communism. Marx's theory of history also led to his concept of class and how society became divided between the working class (proletariat) and the ruling class (bourgeoisie). ...read more.


Marx therefore deduced that the state was only necessary in a society where class i.e. property ownership was an issue, to intervene and resolve conflict which may arise from disagreements between capitalist organisations, workers threatening to go on strike, or economic crisis. Marx therefore considered the state as part of the problem of capitalism, which could subsequently not be used to solve this problem unless the ruling class is overthrown and classes do not exist. Coinciding with Marx's theory of history, Marx maintained that a society under capitalism would ultimately lead to crisis and the eventual establishment of communism, causing the state to be unnecessary and gradually "wither away". This theory was opposed by critics who said contrarily that the state works in the interest of the people and not just the ruling class, and elections held create a neutral and democratic government which the majority can use to ensure that their wishes are carried out. Moreover, critics argued that even under communism the state would have a large role in controlling the disruptive individuals of society, which they maintained would still be present regardless of any drastic social or economic changes. Marx further disputed this by saying that the state would only "wither away" once capitalism had been replaced, and a true democratic society had been established. As Marx always argued in favour of communism, basing part of his argument on the fact that a capitalist society can never be truly democratic, critics disputed his theory saying that communism leads to dictators like Vladimir Lenin. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. How and why does Locke explain the creation, value and protection of property?

    Who regulates or decides on how much one takes? Is it instinctive to know how much to leave for others? It seems like Locke just picked this concept out of thin air and it does not hold any tested validity.

  2. Communism VS Democracy

    those groups that represents the individual&rsquos political beliefs, can be transferred to the behavior of providing money to groups that best represent his or her economic interests, and that is where the connection is made, and where democracy and capitalism intertwine with each other(Pious 12).

  1. Political Parties, Role and Ideology/Policies Qa (i) Ideology is the core fundamental beliefs ...

    the electorate feels disillusioned with UK politics and are beginning to stereotype politicians as sleazy, untrustworthy characters whose exterior motives (such as promotions) out weigh their efforts in representing their constituents. Furthermore if one refers to a July 2004 poll conducted by ICM, which surveyed 1008 adults by telephone on

  2. Analyse The Main Features of Classical Liberalism

    The late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries witnessed the development of classical economic theory in the work of political economists such as Adam Smith and David Ricardo. Liberalism began to connect the political values of choice, freedom and individualism with the perceived existence of those same values in the capitalist free market.

  1. Is political theory useful?

    All of the ideas in the philosophers' works, except for Marx, were interpretations of what they have seen, and the way they explain it. Locke hasn't invented democracy, Hobbes autocratic rule, or Rousseau the representative government, but all of them have contributed to improvement, better understanding and justification of their beliefs.

  2. Marxism - political theory

    Through this process, individuals develop their human powers and potentials. Alienation Under capitalism, the relationship between labor and human expression changes: rather than laboring to fulfill their needs or express ideas, workers do so at the demands of capitalists. Workers are alienated from their labor because it no longer belongs to the worker, but rather to the capitalist.

  1. To what extent can Conservatism be considered an ideology?

    In schools authority should be exercised by the teachers, at work the employer and in society at large by Government. Without authority and discipline society could be chaotic as there would be little direction and inspiration hence their traditional preference for a strong state.

  2. Discuss the advantages of Communism over other political theories like Capitalism.

    But later on, the Prussian government in 1845 closed down the Vorwarts. This forced Marx, along with a small group of others, among them the Russian radical Mikhail Bakunin to move to Brussels In their writings Marx and Engels tried to analyze society which they described as capitalistic.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work