• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What similarities exist between "The Poor Relation's Story" by Charles Dickens and "The Life of Ma Parker" by Katherine Mansfield? What conclusions can be drawn from these similarities about the literature of social reform?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

J.Hart What similarities exist between "The Poor Relation's Story" by Charles Dickens and "The Life of Ma Parker" by Katherine Mansfield? What conclusions can be drawn from these similarities about the literature of social reform? The literature of social reform is a very different to other areas of literature in that it concentrates on one particular message ignoring all others, whilst other literature is generally aimed at providing a topic which can be interpreted in many ways. The message dispensed by the literature of social reform is one of social improvement. Its aim is to make people stop and think about the bigger picture for a change instead of their own personal affairs. Once that has been achieved, perhaps they will be motivated enough to take action and so raise society's moral level. This idea of public motivation is achieved by a number of methods. Both of the stories are told using a narrative platform of just a few hours. It is no coincidence that the same technique has been deployed in both stories. Both Katherine Mansfield and Charles Dickens are trying to make a point. If someone can tell you of their routine day in, day out, and so describe their whole lives in just a few hours, then their lives are seriously lacking in variety. ...read more.

Middle

"A rich man, the dirt from whose carriage wheels is often, in these changed times, thrown upon me as she rides by. No, no. She married me. (PRS pp120 - 121) Where the italics show the events of the real world and the underlined words switch to the dream world. "Gran! Gran!, her little grandson stood on her lap in his button boots." (LMP p1 column 1 paragraph 6) Both characters use their thought world as a form of escapism, as people might use novels nowadays, from the harsh realities of their daily routine. They clutch at their dream world because that is the only thing that means anything to them. So empty are their lives that perhaps it is the only thing keeping them going. This is also another way of attaining the reader's sympathy for the characters and so for the poverty that exists in society. So we can see that the literature of social reform plays on people's sense of right and wrong and the stories show poverty as a wrong that must be corrected by the educated, wealthy people in the community, i.e. the people who would be reading the stories. Both stories make use of generic terms to amplify their purpose. The Poor Relation story uses the term "poor relation" and the Life of Ma Parker uses the term "literary gentleman". ...read more.

Conclusion

History has a habit of repeating itself and it seems he will make the same mistakes as Michael and eventually end up in the same predicament. Perhaps he too will have a young cousin to befriend and who will eventually succeed Little Frank. The cycle of poverty will continue. The same situation occurs in LMP. We are told that the baker died of a disease of the lungs and similarly, Lennie too died of a disease of the lungs. Without the money to do something about this disease it will continue throughout the family and perhaps another generation down the line it will kill another family member. The only way to attain this money is to acquire an education but to do that would require money so it is a vicious circle and because of this the cycle of poverty and disease will continue. This is what Charles Dickens and Katherine Mansfield are trying to illustrate with their literature of social reform. At the end of the day, authors such as Charles Dickens and Katherine Mansfield could only do so much. They wrote these stories in the hope that action would result from words. In these stories, they endeavoured to show us, the readers, how things could change, but they could only take the first steps. The people at the time, sitting at home reading these stories must have taken the action necessary to bring about change. They only showed us the door; we had to walk through it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE A Tale of Two Cities section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE A Tale of Two Cities essays

  1. Compare and contrast the ways in which Shaw and Dickens present irony through their ...

    apparent, neither would the various' brothers' stupidity and blind faith, nor would the emphasised 'Britishness' of the soldiers with their faith in the system of gentlemanly conduct. Similarly without the exaggerated characteristics of the peripheral characters the realism of the emotions of Judith, Anderson and Richard and to a certain extent Essie would be damaged.

  2. How do the "Poor Relation" and "Fireflies" help us to understand how stories help ...

    The setting for this story is around a Christmas fire together with his family. In the Victorian times Christmas was an important religious and family festival and taken more seriously than it would have been in the Fireflies period. The narrator is Charles Dickens but he allows Michael to tell his own story.

  1. In the stories that we have read, the writers present, main characters whom either ...

    It appears that at the start we are informed of his sad life, but in the middle he starts telling us of how his life suddenly turns exceedingly good! Everything appears to go up and he gets married, has kids, grandkids and appears to be happier then ever....

  2. A Tale of Two Cities (1859) Charles Dickens (1812-1870) Dickens' purposes in using 'recalled ...

    Studied carefully, we could say that the Evremondes recalled Dr Manette to his actions. He paid a heavy price for his responsible and just behaviour! In his document, which is presented in court as evidence against Charles Darnay, Manette

  1. Compare ‘The Black veil’ by Charles Dickens with the first chapter of ‘Talking in ...

    through his books, to slap them in the face and make them wake-up, like the surgeon, from their dream-world and show them that it exists right under their noses. Similarly James Watson was motivated by suffering in the community, but alternative to 19th century London when the suffering is due

  2. Scaredy cat ...

    I blocked out my surroundings and all my senses like I was in a dream world with no one to communicate or interact with. It was then that it was obvious that there was a problem. People around were watching as they walked by.

  1. Referring closely to the use of language, show how Charles Dickens examines the ...

    What little speech Dickens has used suggests the tension in chapter twenty-one and the way that he feels about the effects of the peasants approach to the Revolution.

  2. From the stories in the section -

    This mystery leaves us questioning whether he really did find religion or if in fact he was mad. If he was mad, it was a pity, however if he had religion the conclusion was even sadder as no one listened to him.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work