• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Far would you agree with the Claim that the Primary Motive for Giving Aid is to Secure Development in the Recipient Countries?

Extracts from this document...


How Far would you agree with the Claim that the Primary Motive for Giving Aid is to Secure Development in the Recipient Countries? Foreign aid has often helped countries suffering turmoil or economic instability recover, however it has also been shown to simply increase corruption in an already troubled society. In this essay I will go on to describe why aid can be both useful and detrimental to the development of a less developed country (LDC). I will also detail how giving aid is used by countries to secure political and military alliances that underlie the intended image portrayed by the aid donation. Finally I will go on to conclude that whether or not foreign aid actually secures development in the recipient country depends on the type of aid and how it is administered. The discussions will thus proceed based on the underlying assumption that wealthy nations can materially shape development in the poor world and that their efforts to do so should primarily be motivated by the desire to aid the recipient. The essay titles claim that the primary motive for giving aid is to secure development is founded, as there have been examples and cases of successful aid being used. One such example of this is the Marshall plan, which aided the economic recovery of Western Europe in the immediate years following World War II. The United States offered up to $20 billion1 for relief, but only if the European nations could get together and draw up a rational plan on how they would use the aid. ...read more.


Aid to Africa from developed countries has increased dramatically between 1970-1995; it has reached almost $1 trillion in the last 50 years5. This huge aid investment though has not delivered the positive changes it promised and in some cases can be said to have been counter productive to the long term stability of the relevant countries. In 1995 aid dependency6 was almost 20 % in Africa and the amount of aid as a share of government expenditure was up to 50% 7. This shows a dependency on aid that is unfeasible to sustain or replace should the aid be redirected elsewhere. During the period of sustained aid growth in Africa gross domestic product (GDP) fell, and for some years even fell into negative figures. There are no concrete links between increased aid and economic growth. Foreign aid is possibly only one aspect that has to be considered when trying to stimulate growth and development in a LCD's, but it is not the overriding factor. Aid must be linked to good economic policy from the government in power for it to positively affect growth. Another reason why aid can be counter productive to the development of a country is that it is very often spent on the incumbent ruler and for his personal gain rather than that of the country. Paul Rosenstein-Rodan, a former deputy director at the World Bank Economics department when he said, supports this claim "When the World Bank thinks it is financing an electric power station, it is really financing ...read more.


If the gap between the developing and the rich continues to grow, tensions in the world will go on increasing, with adverse affects for all nations."12 This view that helping the poorer nations is done for the good of the donor as well as the recipient, I think quite succinctly demonstrates most nations approach to aid donation. In conclusion I tend to disagree with the notion that the primary objective of giving aid is to secure development in the recipient country. Most aid is given with the intention of receiving some reward in return. These are often intangible goods such as political relationships and alliances, however sometimes increased trade between the recipient and the donor can be a factor. Also I do not believe that in some cases donor nations even believe that their money will be spent on projects harbouring development and growth anyway. A lot of the time the aid will just get used or spent on the leader, on prestige items such as statues or shrines. It is because the aid doesn't seem to be helping growth in poorer countries that new solutions need to be found. Indeed, other courses of action such as giving poor nations more control over economic policy, financing new development-friendly technologies, and opening up labour markets could have more significant benefits. It is time to direct the attention of the world's wealthiest countries to other ways of helping the poorest, ways that have been for too long neglected. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human & Social Geography section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human & Social Geography essays

  1. Causes to Slow Economic Development in Less Developing Countries.

    More surprisingly, referring to the information from United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), meeting the needs of all children for adequate nutrition, it would cost only 16 billion pound a year. This is fifty times smaller than global military spending. This drives the conclusion that any shortage of food, for children

  2. disability essay

    family, community and professionals that was most challenging for many women (Audet & Home, in press). For example, mothers of children with ADHD indicated that their burden was eased when extended family accepted the child, offering emotional and tangible help.

  1. Human Development. There are many aspects to take into consideration when discussing countries ...

    Many of these institutions are government regulated purposely to ensure development in our countries, provinces and towns. A great example of this is our healthcare system in Canada which allows access to a clean hospital in which we can be cured or fixed throughout our lives without ever having to sustain severe financial coverages.

  2. Does foreign aid do more harm than good ?

    They were, in order of ranking: Norway (1.03%), Netherlands(0.91%), Sweden(0.86%), Denmark(0.80%) and France(0.78%). The United Kingdom was twelth with 0.34% of GNP devoted to development assistance of all forms, while the USA came bottom of the table with 0.24% of GNP going towards foreign aid.

  1. Ethical Issues in the Third World Development. Why do developed countries give foreign aid?

    The country that contains the corporation's headquarters is known as the home country. I personally find the most appealing approach, with regards to multinational corporations, is the mercantile approach. The mercantile approach suggests that multinational companies are examples of homogeneous actors that are structurally determined by the global distribution of power and wealth.

  2. Does the post-1989 development of post-socialist spaces in transition support the contention that the ...

    Williamson (2004) summarises some of the fundamental instruments that needed to be embodied into the WC to achieve further development: 1) It should aim at stabilizing the real economy as well as inflation. 2) It should attempt to improve the regulatory framework of the financial system, rather than assume that liberalization is the only game in town.

  1. Women at work

    presence went to over 9% of the workforce during the war (Women in). At the end of the war, women were told it was their patriotic duty to leave the work force in order to make room for men returning from military service (Women in).

  2. NEPAD has been proclaimed a "new dawn for Africa, since, for the first time ...

    eight are over 200% and two are over 300% of their GNP. (www.africarecovery.org). As a result, instead of stimulating growth and helping to advance human development, this excessive debt saps economic vitality and drains resources from social sectors. To repay such high levels of debt (so as not to default

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work