Discuss the dramatic effects achieved and show how far and in what ways the extract expresses the play's characteristic concerns.

Authors Avatar

Naomi Burrell

April 03

Discuss the dramatic effects achieved and show how far and in what ways the extract expresses the play’s characteristic concerns.

Through the various interviews in Top Girls, many dramatic effects are achieved on the audience, through different methods.  The choices of language, pace, and contrasting characters, are just some of the many techniques chosen to achieve these effects.  Through these methods, the themes of the play also continually reoccur in the various scenes, and indeed in the interviews allowing a continuity, which holds the play together as a unit.  However, each interview raises only particular themes and it is interesting to see how this is done and to what extent.

Chosen Interview:

Act II, Scene I, Marlene and Jeanine.

The dramatic effects achieved in this scene are sometimes different to what has come before, as it is the first scene with only modern characters so the language and decorum between Marlene and Jeanine, are different to that between the characters of Act I due to the mixture of backgrounds.  This would most likely be a refreshing change for the audience as Act I is very hectic and rapid most of the time and this would now be a more realistic situation.  Also, now being an interview, the ‘one-on-one’ style is naturally very contrasting to the larger number of characters, creating more focus on the two characters and introducing the audience to the new character Jeanine whilst developing the character of Marlene.  

In this scene, the continuation of the overlapping speech method has both similar and different effects to that which it had in Act I.  Similarly to Act I, it maintains the pace, which keeps the audience interested whilst also maintaining a degree of tension.  However, although both Jeanine and Marlene both start speaking while the other is still speaking, one gains sympathy for Jeanine as opposed to Act I where one is distanced from all the characters.  Whenever Jeanine makes an attempt to elaborate on what she wants to say, Marlene simply takes over, often changing the subject and asks the next question;

Join now!

Jeanine. …and she’s been there forever, and Mrs Bradford / is-

Marlene.  So you want a job with better prospects?

As well as creating sympathy for Jeanine, this reveals to the audience that Marlene is perhaps impatient and slightly rude, but also that she is perhaps focused on obtaining as much of the required information about Jeanine in terms of the job, as quickly as possible.  

When Jeanine talks over Marlene’s speech, she is merely defending herself, creating yet more sympathy in the audience for her.  Marlene gives Jeanine the tip not to mention marriage in interviews, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay