In book nine, we hear of the prizes Achilles will receive from Agamemnon should he return to fight for the Greeks. Prizes seem to be described as one of the main motivations for the warriors fighting (behind glory, even though the prizes represent their glory). Agamemnon promises Achilles he can ‘choose for himself twenty of the Trojan women, who are the loveliest of all, after Helen of Argos’ in book nine for example. Homer is describing war in a positive aspect here; in effect he is saying if you are successful in war, you will be rewarded (be it with women or other materialistic possessions). Homer mentions prizes throughout the Iliad, another example is when you kill a warrior you obtain his armour.
Throughout the Iliad we see how the Gods influence the war: For example in book one, we hear Zeus agree to Thetis’s request that the Greeks should suffer in the absence of Achilles. So the gods control the war, not the men, which, although Homer doesn’t explicitly allude to, is a negative portrayal of the war, as the men are fighting, and the gods are just playing with the men like toys to get back at one another, as if the war was just a game. So the outcome of the war is at the discretion of the gods, whether men live or die. For example during the aristeia of Diomedes (book 5 of the Iliad), when Diomedes encounters Ares, Pallas Athene rides beside Diomedes on a chariot she seized from Sthenelos. Ares hurls his bronze spear towards Diomedes, but Athene interferes, catches the spear and pushes it away from the car. Then Diomedes, with the assistance of Athene drives his bronze spear deep into the belly of Ares, who is consequently saved by Zeus.
In book six, Homer describes Hector’s farewell to his wife Andromache and his child; Achilles later kills Hector. This shows the war to be negative as it brings a sense of reality back to the Iliad. It reminds you of the families these men being slaughtered are leaving behind; it is demonstrating the negative result of war upon everybody. In book two, Homer describes the backgrounds of many of the warriors, which aid Homer in making the war appear more real Some more examples of Homer describing the dark nature of war are: In book seven a truce is called so both sides can bury their dead. In book ten, Dolon, a Trojan spy is deceived by Odysseus and Diomedes and killed without mercy. Throughout the Iliad Homer mentions and describes these things to remind you of the brutalities of war, amongst all the glory you could receive. He explicitly describes the deaths of people; ‘the bronze spearpoint fixed in his forehead and drove inward through the bone; and a mist of darkness clouded both his eyes and he fell.’ (as people die darkness clouds their vision-darkness being negative) and injuries of people (Ares, book five) to achieve the same affect.
There are a lot of positive things that Homer alludes to, such as the glory of an aristeia (Diomedes and Agamemnons), defeating a prestigious opponent and the prizes for succeeding at war (be it at the discretion of the Gods). But interspersed into the glorified battle are reminders of the true horrors war brings upon people: bodies being eaten by dogs, leaving families behind when killed and the brutal nature in which people were killed. Overall I feel that Homer portrays war in both a positive and negative fashion, highlighting the glories of battle, but also presenting the morbidity of war.
Joe Dickinson L6MD
