• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Relationship Between Man and Nature in the poems of Robert Frost and R.S. Thomas

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The Relationship Between Man and Nature. English Coursework. In this piece of coursework, I'm going to discover the relation ship between man and nature, using two poets' works. The poets I am studying are Robert Frost and R. S. Thomas. The works I have chosen by Robert Frost are Mending Wall, Two Look At Two, After Apple-Picking, and Mowing. I will study Mowing and Mending Wall in more detail. The works I have chosen to study by R. S. Thomas are Lore, Farm Child, The Evacuee, and Cynddlan On A Tractor. I will be studying Lore and The Evacuee in more detail. Mowing - Robert Frost. This poem is, as the title suggests, about mowing. It's one man out in the fields mowing with his scythe and his imagination running away with him, making him think that his scythe was whispering. "What was it it whispered? I know not my self. ...The silence, which was why it whispered and did not speak." It's silent in the fields, only a bird or two, maybe, to keep him company. It's so silent, his mind makes him think that there is something else there; he's basically going mad from the silence. He personifies the scythe, saying that it 'whispered'. You and I both know that that scythe, that any scythe, is an inanimate object, it can't talk. ...read more.

Middle

sees it as unproductive, and un-needed. The two neighbours disagree, but they don't voice their sides of the argument. They both feel that it is best not to start a fight, as there were probably no other people around for miles. "He is all apple, and I am all pine." The same person who wrote this could not have written After Apple Picking, as the person in that poem owns a whole orchard of apple trees, thereby making both poems contradict. Anyway. I'm going off on a tangent. Mr. Frost is saying that there is no point in having the wall, as they had two different types of wall. They are not going to encroach on each other's land. "Something there is that doesn't love a wall." He is saying that as the wall gets knocked down, there is no point in rebuilding it. He is a pessimist at heart too. "What's the point? It'll only fall again." The language is slightly less formal than 'Mowing', but still more formal than you would hear in everyday speech. It's still quite Shakespearean, which makes me think again that Mr. Frost got a lot of his ideas for his language from Shakespeare. The ideas are less fanciful, but still more fanciful than I am prepared to accept. "Something there is that doesn't love a wall." ...read more.

Conclusion

A new child suddenly appearing on your stairs when you had been used to just the people who were sitting in your kitchen as your company? Kind of disconcerting, isn't it? Gradually, under the supervision of the farm hands, she grows up, and takes over a couple of jobs on the farm. She did probably not want to go home after this, the city is nothing compared to the peace and tranquillity of the countryside. I know I wouldn't. I like this poem, as it is very historically accurate, as Mr. Thomas lived through the war. And the feelings of the girl at the beginning were very accurate too. Wartime is not a very pleasant thing to write about, but Mr. Thomas makes it positive. There is not much of this fanciful-ness that you get with one of Mr. Frost's poems, but it is still told through the eyes of a child. The language is quite formal, being set in wartime, and again, cannot really be compared to any other poet. Conclusion. I think that Mr. Frost depicts nature better, but that Mr. Thomas writes more believable poems. Overall, I prefer Shakespeare to either of the poets, but Mr. Thomas is a much better poet. And I also feel that the relationship between man and nature is something that will always be written about. What is true now, or what I've written here may not be what the next generation writes about, or may not be what is true in the years to come. Josephine Buckley 10K ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Robert Frost section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Robert Frost essays

  1. Commentarty: Mending Wall by Robert Frost

    "The work of hunters is another thing" implies that it is not a human action that has broken the wall. This supports the idea mentioned earlier that the 'something' in the first line is a natural something. The line "To please the yelping dogs.

  2. Commentary: 'Out Out' by Robert Frost

    Little- less-nothing! - and that ended it.' As readers, it is almost impossible to believe that the boy died from the incident, and the fact that the word 'death' is not mentioned makes us want to believe that the boy is not dead but has survived.

  1. Compare the poems "Hard Frost" and "winter the Huntsman". Decide which poem paints the ...

    Using daggers another way do describe icicles gives the effect of a shape material, also daggers are reflective so that reinforces the idea of sharp cold weapon. Use of language in both poems is quite similar except for some types which tend to be different in a few ways.

  2. Dead Poets Society

    "Words and ideas can change the world." Throughout the entire film, Mr. Keating induces the boys and motivates them to follow their dreams and live a fulfilled life. An example of making the most of one's life in the film is when Neil takes his chance to become an actor and ends up being very successful.

  1. Free essay

    Fros's peorty is more about people than nature. Discuss

    'Mending Wall' also looks at the theme of barriers. Here, Frost uses the physical barrier of the wall to question whether boundaries are necessary. Frost creates two distinct characters; both have different ideas about what makes a person a good neighbour.

  2. After Apple Picking by Robert Frost

    The poem opens with a kind of regretful tension - "My long two-pointed ladder's sticking through a tree toward heaven still" could perhaps portray the persona standing on the earth but looking upward, suspended between the real and the dream world.

  1. Closely analyse the poems 'Sacifice' by Taufiq Rafat and 'Out, Out' by Robert Frost. ...

    When Rafat says 'a white-bearded man chants something holly' it is coming back to the idea that their community is a religious community. At the end of the sentence we can tell that this sacrifice is recent by the words 'the cameras click' it also suggests that to some this

  2. Emotional Barriers in Robert Frost's Mending wall and Home burial".

    and it's come to this a man can't speak of his own child that's dead". She then says that he is unable to speak of his own child as he does not know how to do so.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work