Augustine's philosophy. In Augustines thinking all moral and natural (evil) comes from moral choices.

Authors Avatar

George Lucas

Augustine’s Theodicy

St Augustine (ad 354-430) was a committed Christian and monk, inspired by the preaching of Ambrose of Milan. His main arguments concerning evil were both originally based on the bible. Augustine himself had many beliefs, one of his main beliefs was that god had made the world and when making the world he had made it free from flaws. He believed very strongly that god is ‘good, omnipotent and omniscience’. For this reason he was also greatly influenced by the creation stories found in Genesis 1-3.

Although Augustine believed in this thesis things he had a problem which was, ‘if god is good and omnipotent and it was god that created the world why is there evil in the world?’  So if God made the Universe and continues to keep it in existence for ever, then if people commit acts of evil, God is keeping alive those very people while they do those acts. He solved this problem by saying that god is responsible for the evil in the world by defining evil as ‘privation.’ This means that something is lacking a particular thing that is should have. Augustine gave the example of ‘blindness’. He called this a privation, because if you are blind it means that you are unable to see – in other words, you lack the attribute of ‘sight’ or if you cannot walk – ‘you lack the health you should have.’ This is a privation in Augustine’s thinking.  

Join now!

Augustine also influenced a philosopher called, Herbert McCabe. McCabe argued a similar argument to Augustine’s, which was that badness and evil are about not living up to expectations – something lacks a quality it should have been. However Augustine had to reject the idea that power opposed God as that would go against the traditional Christian view of god being ‘omnipotent’ (God would have a rival).

Augustine theodicy was largely based on that people are not doing wrong when they torture someone as an example, however they are failing at what they should be doing as humans, and ...

This is a preview of the whole essay