Pinter wrote ‘The Birthday Party’ at the young age of twenty eight. He was born in 1930 in Hackney brought up by his Jewish parents. 75 years later he won the Nobel Prize for literature. His work is thought by many to be post-modern. It is deemed this for his work is said to “underline the ability of the theatre to reflect the elusive nature of reality, and at the same time, points to the inadequacy of theatrical presentation.
In the first act of the play it does not seem that the character of Stanley is tragic in anyway. It seems the complete opposite in fact. Stanley appears to be the ‘man of the house’ as he seems to have control over the two elderly characters, Petey and Meg. For example, Meg makes him Breakfast and is a mother figure to him. However, He is Rude, patronising and quite threatening to her at times. For example. “(pushing her) Get away from me” and “Who do you think your talking to? And yet they both keep coming back to him as if it never happened. However, it is not hard to see that Petey and Meg are not the brightest of beings so the fact that he is rude and the fact that they will not seem to recognise this may have something to do with it. Despite this, there is some indication that something not quite right may be about. Stanley seems to act very strangely indeed when Meg mentions that two men may be staying at the house. It is almost as if he is paranoid that these people are coming for him.
“I’ve got to get things in for the two gentle men”.
“What two gentle men? Who are they? Didn’t he tell you their names? They wanted to come here? Why? But who are they? They won’t come. Why didn’t they come last night? I didn’t think they’d come.
This arouses some suspicions. Why would Stanley be getting so stressed up over some visitors coming to stay in a boarding house? It soon becomes all clear in Act two.
In Act two Stanley is acquainted with the two gentle, now known as Goldberg and McCann. The occupation of these two gentlemen is yet unknown as is the connection between Stanley’s worry and their arrival. But once the two men arrive, from the start of act to you can tell that the power Stanley once had now seems almost nothing compared to the new arrivals. It is almost as if Stanley fears them.
McCann: I don’t think we’ve met.
Stanley: No, we haven’t
McCann: My name is McCann
Stanley: Staying here long?
McCann: Not long. What’s your name?
Stanley: Webber
McCann: Were you going out?
Stanley: Yes
McCann: On your Birthday?
Stanley: Yes. Why not?
There are many little conversations like this, each one gradually getting more and more uncomfortable and awkward for Stanley.
Stanley: Get out.
Goldberg: Mr. Webber, sit down.
Stanley: It’s no good starting any kind of trouble.
Goldberg: Sit down.
Stanley: Why should I?
Goldberg: If you want to know the truth Webber, you’re beginning to get on my breasts.
Stanley: Really? Well, that’s-
Goldberg: Sit down.
Stanley: No.
At this time it looks as if Stanley is in for an unpleasant journey. Which he is. After having many conversations like the one above, Mr. McCann and Mr. Goldberg bombard him with questions both irrelevant and down right stupid.
Goldberg: Where is your lechery leading you?
McCann: You’ll pay for this.
Goldberg: You stuff yourself with dry toast.
McCann: What about Ireland?
Goldberg: Why do you pick your nose?
McCann: I demand justice!
Goldberg: Speak up, Webber. Why did the chicken cross the road?
Stanley: He wanted to-he wanted to-he wanted to….
McCann: He doesn’t know
Goldberg: Why did the chicken cross the road?
Stanley: He wanted to-he wanted to…..
Goldberg: Why did the chicken cross the road?
Stanley: He wanted…..
McCann: He doesn’t know. He doesn’t know which came first!
Goldberg: Which came first?
McCann: Chicken? Egg? Which came first? Which came first? Which came first?
(Stanley screams)
After this most bizarre conversation it appears that they have broken Stanley into a blithering wreck. He seems to turn into a lunatic as well for later on he turns off the lights when celebrating his birthday and Rapes Lulu. He would not have done this prior to his encounter with Goldberg and McCann. When he first met her earlier in the play, it seemed as if he didn’t want her there, as if he was uncomfortable with her being present.
This also brings up questions that need answering like why do the two gentlemen bombard Stanley with questions? What do they want with him? What has he done to make them do that to him?
In the third Act of the play we are greeted just like we were in the beginning of act one. Meg and Petey are in the kitchen but this time there are no cornflakes or fried bread for McCann and Goldberg had eaten it all. In this act you do not really see a great deal of Stanley. He is being kept upstairs by the two gentlemen, waiting for Petey to leave and go and attend his deck chairs. Unfortunately for them, Petey has some suspicions and does not want to leave for he fears they may do something to Stanley. Goldberg tries to get Stanley out of the house by saying that he needs to see a doctor for he is unwell. Again Petey doesn’t buy it, and stands up to the men. This is a complete reversal of power. Petey was the old weak man who was bossed around, now he’s standing up to the men who have broken down Stanley and are taking him somewhere other than the doctors. Some place where he probably won’t return from. Petey seems to no this and tries to defend Stanley, but a remark made by Goldberg stops Petey from Going to the same Fate.
Petey: Where are you taking him?
Goldberg: We’re taking him to Monty.
Petey: He can stay here.
Goldberg: Don’t be silly.
Petey: We can look after him here.
Goldberg: Why do you want to look after him?
Petey: He’s my guest.
Goldberg: He needs special treatment.
Petey: We’ll find someone.
Goldberg: No. Monty’s the best there is. Bring him McCann. Petey: Leave him alone!
(They stop. Goldberg studies him)
Goldberg: (insidiously) why don’t you come with us, Mr. Boles?
McCann: Yes, why don’t you come with us?
Goldberg: Come with us to Monty. There is plenty of room in the car.
(Petey makes no move. They pass him and reach the front door. McCann opens the door and picks up the suitcases)
Petey: (broken) Stan, don’t let them tell you what to do!
(They exit)
After reviewing all the evidence I have put forward, it is true to say that the character of Stanley becomes one of tragedy. He becomes a tragic character, for he falls from power, not a huge amount, but it was enough to make him more powerful than Petey and Meg. He is then forced into a total nervous breakdown as a result of Goldberg and McCann’s unrelenting continuous bombardment of ludicrous questions and statements like’ why did the chicken cross the road?’ After this ‘interrogation’ he is taken off in the gentlemen’s car and ultimately killed, tortured or have something generally unpleasant done to him, therefore resulting him becoming a tragic character.