The Bell Jar depicted the life of Esther Greenwood and her rite of passage from girl to woman. This novel was one of the few that fearlessly chronicled the life of an intelligent woman who struggled in the world to discover the function of existence (Martin 2). The story began with Esther as an intern at a fashion magazine, quite parallel to Plath’s internship at Mademoiselle. As the story progressed, Esther decided that she needed to live life on her own and was drastically devastated when she came home to Boston and learned that she had not been accepted to a writing program at Harvard. She eventually became morbidly depressed and tried to kill herself with sleeping pills just as Plath
Vieira 3
had attempted her first time. Esther was quickly admitted into a private facility where she met Joan Gilling. At the facility Esther once again went under shock treatment very afraid that it would be just like the time before her suicide attempt. Joan finally left the institution but soon returned after having to take Esther to the hospital due a severe hemorrhage that occurred after having sex. Not much long after, Joan was declared missing and was soon found dead as she had hanged herself. Before long, Esther was prepared to leave, but quite scared to face the world ahead. However, with an optimistic outlook she left the hospital “patched, retreated, and approved for the road (Plath 275).”
Plath’s ability to express her hostility in her writings and the fact that she refused to follow the standard that women should never be angry, deviated her from the traditional norms (Martin 3). There are many other examples in The Bell Jar that explain the character and the true feelings of Sylvia Plath. It is more difficult to reveal what is not true from the factual details of her life. Instead of viewing Plath as a wonderful independent writer, some critics only distinguish her agitated and morbid side. Failing to understand how traumatizing the death of Plath’s father was to her, critics condemn her fascination with hurt and damage and implied how sadistic and self indulgent it was to publish The Bell Jar (Hardwick 1). The writing of this novel might have been an attempt for Plath to relieve herself from her manic depression. However, it is sadly obvious that it did not heal her, but left her more depressive than before (Ames 7).
Vieira 4
While Plath’s descriptive poem “Mirror,” leaves the reader perplexed with a question of what is exactly being described, it still reveals the speaker’s identity. It can be concluded that Plath purposely gave the poem an ambiguous purpose, which was to literally describe a mirror while metaphorically describing poetry itself (Johnson 1). The first line “I am silver and exact/I have no preconceptions,” reveals how Plath has used personification to give a stronger feeling to an inanimate object. She gives the mirror the capacity to “meditate” and to be non-judgmental, which also differentiates it from a human. Her poem, which is divided into two stanzas, has a metaphor within another. The mirror, which describes the reflection of a human being or poetry itself, is also figuratively being described as a lake. The way the poem looked written also appears that the two stanzas are mirror images of one another, reflecting the same size and the “four cornered” shape (Johnson 4). The poet can also imply that instead of looking in too deeply for another meaning, the poem also has the obvious meaning. Such as, the woman who looks constantly at the mirror and views herself over the years trying to discover whether or not the image she sees is really what she thinks it might be.
In order to criticize or praise Sylvia Plath’s works, I believe it is imperative to understand the hardships she went through. The Bell Jar was a wonderful book that truly moved me. Instead of carping at the morbid details that Plath chose to use, I admired how she had the courage to write about the personal occurrences in the book. It is very important to me that there are few women that
Vieira 5
dare to be different and they are the ones that open doors to all of the scared women in this world. Whether or not people choose to see Plath or her work as a failure, I perceive it as the fact that she ended her life at her most creative peak. “Mirror” was actually a very pleasant poem compared to other melancholic ones like “Daddy” and “Lady Lazarus” which were posthumously published in her volume Ariel. Even though it is very hard to perceive it as a metaphor for poetry itself, I agree that in “Mirror” Plath purposely indicated that it had deeper meaning other than just reflect a person’s image. As one of my personal favorites, I see myself as that woman and believe that all human beings can relate to that poem.
To judge a poet, is not only a difficult task, but a very controversial one. It is evident that it is always a matter of personal opinion. However, it can be concluded that regardless of a unpleasant or respectable critic, Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar and “Mirror” continue to affect readers and critics of modern day, while illustrating the writer’s search for freedom and individualism.
Vieira 6
Works Cited
“The Bell Jar.” Characters in Twentieth Century Literature. 1990: 1-2. Gale
Literary Databases. Literature Resource Center. 11 May 2003.
<http://galenet.galegroup.com/>.
“The Bell Jar.” Characters in Young Adult Literature. 1997: 7-16. Gale
Literary Databases. Literature Resource Center. 11 May 2003.
<http://galenet.galegroup.com/>.
Churchwell, Sarah. "Ted Hughes and the Corpus of Sylvia Plath." Criticism
Winter 1998. 13 May 2003 <http://findarticles.com>.
Johnson, Jeannine. "An overview of 'Mirror'." Poetry for Students 1997: 1-4. Gale
Group Databases. 13 May 2003. <http://galenet.galegroup.com/>.
Martin, Wendy. “Sylvia Plath, Her Prose and Poetry.” Women’s Studies 1973: 1-
5. Gale Literary Databases. 13 May 2003. <http://www.infomatik.uni-
leipzig.de/>.
Plath, Sylvia. The Bell Jar. London: Harpers & Row, Publishers, 1961.
Plath, Sylvia. “Mirror.” Elements of Literature. Ed. Richard Sime. Austin, TX:
Harcourt Brace & Company, 2000. 1148-49.
Steinberg, Peter K. The Bell Jar. 2003. A Celebration, This Is. 13 May 2003.
<http://www.sylviaplath.info/belljar.html>.
Wagner-Martin, Linda. Sylvia Plath. 27 Apr. 2003.
<http://college.hmco.com/english/heath/syllabuild/iguide/plath.html>.