• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Two books I have chosen to compare are "The Woman in White", by Wilkie Collins and "The Woman in Black", by Susan Hill.

Extracts from this document...


Anna Booth 11 L English Wider Reading Coursework- 2nd Draft 23.11.01 The two books I have chosen to compare are "The Woman in White", by Wilkie Collins and "The Woman in Black", by Susan Hill. The book "The Woman in White" is a story about a man who tries to deceive the Farlie family and inherit their fortune. The basic plot is this; Walter goes to work at a mansion where he falls in love with Laura who is betrothed to Sir Percival Glyde. Percival is not really a "sir" as his parents never married. Anne Catherick bears a striking resemblance to Laura but Percival has her put in an asylum as she knows the truth about his identity. Percival marries Laura against her will but he wants her out the way so he can inherit her fortune. As Anne is ill, he decides to free her from the asylum but put Laura in there instead. Anne dies and he inherits Laura's fortune as everyone believes that Anne is still in the asyum. Percival dies in a fire whilst trying to write his parent's marriage in the registry book. Walter discoves the truth and rescues Laura from the asylum. ...read more.


He obviously doesn't like the look of her as when he was saying about her hat all he said was, "A bonnet type hat covered her head" but when Walter was describing Laura's hat he said, "A little straw hat of the natural colour, plainly and sparingly trimmed with ribbon to match the gown, covers her head, and it throws its soft pearly shadow over the upper part of her face". This description is much more in depth than that of Jennet and it seems as though he is trying to portray a picture of Laura to the reader. The language used in the passage from "The Woman in Black", is fairly simple as there are no complex words and it describes her in shorter sentences and does not describe every detail of Jennet. The language used in the passage from "The Woman in White", is more complex and has longer sentences. Here is a line from "The Woman in White", "The charm-most gently and yet most distinctly expressed- which they shed over the whole face, so it covers and transforms its little natural human blemishes elsewhere, that it is difficult to estimate the relative merits and defects of the other features". ...read more.


By the description of Laura I think it is obvious Walter is very fond of her as he is very careful to describe her properly and flatter her. However in, "The Woman in Black", she is not described as fully and he does not try to flatter her so she may have a more realistic description of what she actually looks like. By not describing Jennet as fully as Laura is described, it gives her an atmosphere of mystery, as you do not really know what she is like. I personally enjoyed reading "The Woman in White" more than "The Woman in Black" as it was much more intricate and surprising whereas in "The Woman in Black", I thought it was quite predictable and had a simpler plot. "The Woman in White" had many characters that were all different and carefully described but the characters in "The Woman in Black" were not, in my opinion, as realistic or believable. I did not think that the characters in "The Woman in Black were as believable as the characters in "The Woman in White" as the characters from "The Woman in White" were intricately described and although the complex descriptions can be tedious to read, the reader does gain a more detailed view of the characters. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Glass Menagerie section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Glass Menagerie essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Discuss the extent to which language creativity can be identified in everyday interaction in ...

    4 star(s)

    It is also noticeable how much the girls are enjoying the play with both language and particularly the story as they constantly interrupt with giggling. There is also the aspect of the girls' friendship which is developing throughout the "act".

  2. Important Symbols and Themes of The Glass Menagerie

    When Amanda is heard walking up the fire escape, she quickly hides her collection. She does this to hide her secret world from the others. When Tom leaves to go to the movies in an angered rush, he accidentally breaks some of Laura's glass.

  1. The Woman In White, by Wilkie Collins, is a successfulgothic novel of the 19th ...

    At Blackwater Park, some blood is witnessed; this can be seen as a foreshadowing of events to come later on in the story. Their conversation is of criminals and murderers, another foreshadowing, pg 205: "It looks just the place for murder, doesn't it?"

  2. Relationships in The Glass Menagerie, by Tennessee Williams.

    However, it is possible to suggest such a relationship, especially through the way it is performed on stage. The last relationship I'm going to discuss is Jim's and Laura's. Jim, throughout the whole play almost, was known to us as Laura's high school crush and as the gentleman caller, especially according to Amanda.

  1. The Day My Life Stopped

    acted in the past, I know I didn't treat you properly, and it didn't really help with the thing with Natalie I mean it was kind of like rubbing it in your face. But anyway, yeah it was me, and sorry if it's lame but thought it was a good idea at the time."

  2. "Brief Encounter" dealt with the issues of sexuality and desire by using a lot ...

    The main issue that is being portrayed in "Brief Encounter" is of a woman having an affair, and the consequences of her actions. The film tries to portray having an affair when you are married as totally unacceptable and as hard to bear on your soul.

  1. How does Wilkie Collins develop Marian Halcombe compared to Count Fosco in 'The Woman ...

    "How can you expect four women to dine together alone everyday and not quarrel? We are such fools, we can't entertain each other at the table." She seems resolute in her position at Limmeridge House, and lacks ambition in any pursuit other than care and support of her half-sister, Laura Fairlie.

  2. Uncle Jemima¡¯s House

    "That's Amanda, that is. She's got some kind of wasting disease, she lives up at Shamrock Hall, see up there!" He pointed to a large Sort of church like spiral shape and I could just make out the letters, "HAMROCK ALL" on the top.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work