• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using the poems 'Dear Mr. Lee' and 'Report' both written by U A Fanthorpe, I will write an assay discussing the way the poet presents schools in both poems.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Tahamtan Pishghgaravol English GCSE coursework Using the poems `Dear Mr. Lee' and `Report' both written by U A Fanthorpe, I will write an assay discussing the way the poet presents schools in both poems. Both poems are generally concerning school; the obvious difference is that each poem tackles a different topic of schooling. The characters in each poem are different, which is why the poems have a dissimilar tone and view. The direct voice from `Dear Mr. Lee' is the school girl and the voice from `Reports' is the teacher. The poem "Dear Mr Lee" exemplifies the faults of the school system through one little girl. It shows the system's inability to cater for the individual, whose opinions differ from that of the examiners and the teachers on how people should be educated. `Reports' is essentially about what some teachers think of the students and how they portray them in the reports. It seems that in the poem we have two teachers although we only hear the voice one teacher; one seems to be a more experienced teacher than the other. ...read more.

Middle

she feels that the book should be read for pleasure, and not just to study, "I didn't much like those questions about social welfare in the rural community and the seasons as perceived by an adolescent, I didn't think you'd want your book read that way..." She is criticising the examination methods explaining that, at this point in time they do not work for her at least. Mr. Smart is also critical, but unlike the pupil, not of the education system he upholds. He disagrees with the child's sentiment towards the book `Cider with Rosie'. In the letter, the child is always saying how "Mr Smart says..." when the girl has one idea in her head, he always tells her things, which completely conflict with her prior beliefs. "...But Mr Smart says Spain isn't like that all Timeshare villas and Torremolinos" He implicitly undermines her faith, destroying her self-esteem. This is a terrible relationship, certainly not one that any child should have with their teacher. They should be stimulated and encouraged, not put down. ...read more.

Conclusion

It is not really a clich�, since it does not mean that something which is satisfactory should satisfy but that parents should be satisfied to read that their child has been judged satisfactory, so the parents should be satisfied with the report, because the report writer is satisfied with their child. But at no point do we learn what it is that has satisfied the teacher, nor what might be a standard for being "satisfactory". As we read `Reports' we find the tone of the poem is negative because it indicates how some teachers judge students. The poem does link to my thesis and we find out that the teacher is a bitter man, which may've become lazy from years of teaching, and is trying to pass on his distress to a new and hopeful teacher. However `Dear Mr. Lee' has a positive tone in spite of criticism of the teachings and examining of English. It's showing that students can still enjoy a subject even if the teacher uses discouraging methods of teaching the student. Therefore both poems present school from different perspectives showing what some teachers and students think of the education system. Fanthorpe opinion seems to be that children may still succeed despite some teaching scheme. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE U A Fanthorpe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE U A Fanthorpe essays

  1. Half Past Two and Dear Mr.Lee

    This is exactly the case. This poem is structured around an interview. This is the gimmick. There is only one voice to this interview, which is from the person conducting it. This person has a very pessimistic and cynical tone.

  2. How does U.A. Fanthorpe create different personalities within the poems 'Not My Best side' ...

    how today the maiden is no longer considered beautiful, thus showing the change of perceptions, especially of the dragon. While changing the stereotypes set by the myth, the poem challenges them at the same time. In the poem the knight is vain and ladish, 'You can't / Do better than

  1. Is Fanthorpe an Effective Poet?

    She causes the reader to dislike the arrogant personnel officer, and to feel sympathetic towards the man whom is being interrogated. Fanthorpe likes to open poems with a sentence that gets the reader's attention immediately, and causes an interest in the character.

  2. W far do you agree with the view that Fanthorpe "offers us new perspectives ...

    "We found contemplatives, with green umbrellas, Making symbolic gestures at the stream." This stanza is quite amusing as for a person who doesn't recognize the water god would believe the poet was strange and the poet is selecting the most ordinary of things in a human beings life to pick out where they are contemplating towards the water.

  1. UA Fanthorpe is a poet who dislikes modern life. Consider this, using examples from ...

    'Last House' is a poem about an old cinema closing down. It is a nostalgic look at old-fashioned cinemas and the destruction of one in particular, 'The Regal'. In the opening line, Fanthorpe chooses to write about 'the beat of destruction'.

  2. By Reference to three poems in the 'Tracks' anthology, discuss how Fanthorpe explores the ...

    Despite conventionally bein portrayed as a brilliant individual, and the patron saint of England, in the final stanza of this poem, St George appears far from a saintly figure. Fanthorpe has chosen to make St George arrogant and inconsiderate. In doing this, Fanthorpe reveals her own critical voice, and emerges as a highly feminist character.

  1. “Fanthorpe is a master in speaking in the voice of another” - Discuss.

    The poem 'Reports' does not only count for another example of Fanthorpe's competence in using voices, but is also a wonderful display of her effectiveness as a poet.

  2. Comparing the poems "Dr Mr Lee" and "Reports".

    Larkin they are both poets that spoil the enjoyment of English. "Mr Smart is roughly my least favourite person, and for Shakespeare (we're doing him to). I think he's a spelling disaster, with all those jokes". "T. Hughe and P.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work