• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine The Arguments For Governments Providing A Free Healthcare System - What Role Might A Price System Play In Overcoming The Disadvantages Of A Public (NHS) System?

Extracts from this document...


Examine The Arguments For Governments Providing A Free Healthcare System. What Role Might A Price System Play In Overcoming The Disadvantages Of A Public (NHS) System? The question above challenges the ability of the free market to provide an efficient allocation of resources with regards to social and economic efficiency within the healthcare sector. Economic efficiency is defined as allocative (P=MC), productive (MPPl / Pl = MPPk / Pk) and x-efficiency (operating on the lowest possible AC and MC curves under monopoly); social efficiency results from the aforementioned three measures to create Pareto Optimality. Such a question is posed in response to the weakness of a publicly funded healthcare system despite the advantages that accrue from such a system. The rationale behind free healthcare is twofold; firstly, healthcare is considered by society to be universally desirable and to ration it through the price mechanism is seen as inequitable. This is taken from the moral standpoint of democratic governance and underpinned by welfare economics. Social indicators such as the public quality of life index (PQLI) illustrate the increase in societal well-being through the allocation of healthcare on the basis of need and not simply income or wealth. Secondly, healthcare, as a merit good, confers considerable positive benefits to society as a whole beyond those which the individual considers privately; the ...read more.


training more doctors & nurses, building hospitals, providing more equipment etc) then in due course the supply curve will shift to the right to equate supply with demand when price equals zero. However, the suggestion that a significant increase in supply will eliminate the waiting list assumes that the demand curve is static, which experience has indicated to the contrary in that demand for healthcare increases over time behaving in a somewhat counter-intuitive way. Says Law, as it is sometimes referred to, provides a rare example in economics of supply 'creating its own demand'. One of the most fascinating aspects of the market for healthcare is the view frequently put forward that the success of the NHS in providing universal healthcare free at the point of access has led to increasing social awareness about health and rising expectations among the population of better health, as well as rising real incomes, an ageing population, increased expectations and the availability of new medical technology. Increased supply of healthcare is constrained by the likely need for still further increases in resources to satisfy further rises in demand. The provision of public health system, such as the NHS however is argued to be significantly more productively efficient with regards to economies of scale in comparison to the private healthcare systems of continental Europe and the USA. ...read more.


The foreseeable problem with a healthcare system wholly dominated by a price-mechanism would be social unfairness with regards to providing healthcare to poorer people and the fear of under-consumption of healthcare due to its merit and public good properties; notwithstanding over consideration of the profit motive to 'cut corners' within healthcare, for example, the NHS repeats the AIDs test three times whilst private health companies in the UK carries out the test only once on the same blood sample. Perhaps a 'private-public partnership' would provide greater social efficiency whereby only certain elements of healthcare were co-ordinated through the price mechanism and the majority publicly provided. One idea, adopted in Sweden, is to charge patients for appointments. As well as providing an additional source of income for the NHS, it would also decrease the number of time wasters in GP waiting rooms. This charge would also encourage patients to make more use of services provided by pharmacies and NHS Direct thereby reducing the workload of GPs. To ensure that the poor and elderly aren't discouraged from seeking treatment, exemptions could be made based on income or age. 1 An indication of the poor morale is shown in the recent General Practitioner Committee's ballot in which 56% of all GPs voted to hand in their resignations next year if a new contract with the Government is not reached. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Microeconomics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Microeconomics essays

  1. Activity Based Costing & The NHS

    create demand for activities' (Drury, C, 1999: 713). A link is made between activities and products by assigning costs of activities to products based on an individual product's consumption or demand for each activity. ABC systems simply recognise that businesses must understand the factors that drive each major activity, the cost of activities and how activities relate to products.

  2. Using supply and demand analysis explain and illustrate how the major factors determining supply ...

    Zinc-carbon batteries are also one of the certain segments seen as inferior because despite the recession, they introduced 'cheaper own-label zinc carbon ranges' which was more of a low-quality product. Also, cheap stores such as the pound stores had introduced 'mega value packs of 24-packs of AA zinc carbon' which

  1. An Empirical Study into the Determinants of an Individuals Supply of Labour

    Specification Test (Model 2) Ramsey RESET Test: F-statistic 19.62460 Prob. F(3,2369) 0.0000 Log likelihood ratio 58.52237 Prob. Chi-Square(3) 0.0000 To check for misspecification in the model I used the Ramsey Reset test which runs a regression with the dependent variable included in the model at incremental powers.

  2. Competitive markets, free from government intervention are the best means of allocating society(TM)s scarce ...

    customer's are heard as their discussions determine what product or service is in demand. In a free, self-perpetuating market, if there is a need for a good there is always a supplier to provide that good, given the availability of resources.

  1. Walmart, Monopoly.

    price will induce the supplier to supply at below the competitive market price, while still supplying at the same quantity as if the market were competitive. This makes the last unit of the monopsonized good still equal to the marginal cost of production.

  2. Microsoft Monopoly

    Microsoft is creating the standards for the rest of the computer industry. They are able to build them much faster than an outside organization. Other companies are able to create their applications much better and faster. The customer receives a much better product" (Antitrust).

  1. The price of oil has recently reached new highs and Britain now has some ...

    Clearly, all these factors contribute to the impact on buyer demand for motoring. To illustrate further, motoring and oil tend to be closely related with each other are theoretically described by Lipsey & Chrystal (2004:P44) as complements. Hence, a sudden rise in the price of either will reduce the demand for both since complements tend to be captivated together.

  2. Game Theory Nash Equilibrium

    There is first mover disadvantage as they can?t find themselves in a Nash Equilibrium. Both firms are rational so if the first firm tries to collude and don?t advertise the second firm will seek to maximise profits and betray the first firm.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work