• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What conclusions does More want his 16th century readers to draw about the Christian beliefs and practices in Europe

Extracts from this document...


What conclusions does More want his sixteenth-century readers to draw about the Christian beliefs and practices in Europe? In past examinations of More's Utopia, questions have often been raised as to the aim of the presentation of religion on the island. The inhabitants of Utopia are essentially heathen, in contrast to the Christianity of Europe. However, this raises two points - firstly, that the Utopians may have been heathen, but they were virtuous heathen as opposed to the "wicked professed Christian" of sixteenth century Europe. Thus is More presenting the view that virtuous living should be chosen over the possibly corrupt nature of Christianity? Also, this suggests to that virtuous living can be achieved independently of Christianity or indeed any other religion. The second point which is raised is the question of how much of the historical context in which Utopia was written has crept into the work. Though Utopia was published before the major religious upheaval in England began, the reformation commenced really with the advent of Luther on the continent and his ninety-five theses on indulgences in 1517. Thus it would have been nigh on impossible for More to have written such a work with its many subtle attacks on the structure of society and its pointed references to religion without having been somewhat influenced by the contextual situation. ...read more.


Both Erasmus and Bude are known to have commented on this, Bude calling Utopia a "holy community" and Erasmus "a holy commonwealth". Erasmus also comments on the ways in which "Utopians surpass[ed] European Christians in several matters characteristically Christian - Utopian rejection of astrological superstition, Utopian belief in immortality, and the sanctity of the Utopian Priesthood". These comments are founded in the text itself - both in the content and indeed the language implemented. The Utopians, in comparison to the Europeans, posses virtue and faith; in fact they posses all the virtues 'More had described as Christian a decade earlier - simplicity, temperance [and] frugality'. The way in which a number of the Utopian people are converted to Christianity because it complies with their deepest beliefs, rather than because of the miracles and such, shows the penetration of their faith. However, it is faith, fundamentally, without a name. They follow in all the ways of Christianity with no knowledge of the scriptures and without actually calling themselves Christian. Can the Utopians thus be referred to as Christians? They were, perhaps, closer to being truly Christian than the baptised masses in Europe. Their community living, their ability to give without requiring anything in return and hence their charitable qualities - all are elements which ring very true of the ideal form of Christianity. ...read more.


Essentially, and at its most basic and crude, More is attacking the all talk, no action nature of Christian practices in Europe at the time. We must not forget that it is a generalisation, though it seems historically to be largely correct. Also, we must bear in mind that this is a work of fiction, in which the author presents his views through an imaginary island called "no place" (in comparison with the translated meaning of 'Europa'). He does this by presenting a non-Christian society that is far more Christian in its beliefs and practices than societies that claimed to be Christian. This challenges the beliefs of the reader, and, in the case of the sixteenth century reader, may invoke a need for them to examine their own lives. It is also an analysis of the church as a whole, and the methods it employed to religiously "govern". Hence, rather than provoking a conclusion, More incites a number of serious and important questions for consideration, in line with the Christian humanist method of thought. The answer to these questions is somewhat summarised by Erasmus: "Who is truly Christian? Not he who is baptised or anointed, or who attends church. It is rather the man who has embraced Christ in the innermost feelings of his heart, and who emulated Him by his pious deeds". That is possibly the conclusion More intended his sixteenth century readers to be lead into deducing for themselves. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Miscellaneous essays

  1. Describe several heuristics that you might use when deciding whether you should a) Study ...

    say yes just to see how things could develop, then you are likely to feel that you are in with a good chance of being accepted too. The effectiveness of this search set is also a key factor. To use a word recall example, if someone were to ask you

  2. Source and Form Criticism of the Bible. Both types of criticisms are helpful ...

    Form criticism is being used in the clause of the text where the question arises that if Moses wrote the Bible one might expect Moses to use first person, so passages such as Deut 31:9 indicate another author's presents. Form criticism aids in this argument in developing a "life setting" of the situation for the intentions of the text.

  1. Exegesis on Job 42:1-17 In the passage of Job 42:1-6 there appears to ...

    (38:1-41:34), and Job then expresses his satisfaction "with the humble knowledge that his sufferings were all part of the purposes of God... even if he could not understand those purposes with his finite mind". It is simply incredible to realise that Job was proved correct in his righteousness and assessment

  2. Describe the visit in the Quaker Meeting House and assess the relevance of visiting ...

    with us, a good example of this is taken from the visit to the Muslim centre, their new approach to science, an admittance that that there religion had stayed static, a problem which they were now addressing and trying to change.

  1. Ethics in Religion

    While growing up at the age of fourteen Nick started partying and drinking and by seventeen was expelled from high school for drinking and fighting. When asked if he thought God had any part of his young life he said: "Jordan, none that I'd call God."

  2. Religion. Dreaming influenced the Land Rights Movement as it depicts the importance of Land ...

    After the Mabo judgment, the Native Title Act came into force on 1 January 1994. The Native Title Act introduced procedures and protection for dealing with Aboriginal claims and rights. The Mabo judgment made a substantial impact towards achieving land rights justice in Australia.

  1. Jesus appointed only men to succeed him therefore women should be excluded from priesthood'.

    The rules could also be bent. If a woman wished to free herself of an intolerable marriage, she could do so while still keeping her property rights protected. There was a procedure that a woman could bring a divorce suit to court and as a result, the husband could be compelled to divorce her.

  2. Compare and contrast the human condition as it relates to Muslims and Christians. ...

    Allah also indicates punishment for not giving Zakaat as follows: "And there are those who hoard gold and silver and do not spend it in the way of Allah, announce to them a most grievous penalty (when)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work