• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explore Kingston's presentation of the relationship between gender, community stories and identity in Woman Warrior.

Extracts from this document...


Kingston reads herself into existence through the stories her culture tells her about women' Explore Kingston's presentation of the relationship between gender, community stories and identity in Woman Warrior. The focus of Maxine Hong Kingston's autobiography The Woman Warrior is the talk-stories of females who have affected her life and identity in some way. A rich amalgam of Chinese heritage, legends and folktales, the text follows the reality of a woman's struggle for self identity in migrant America. Kingston finds stifling the stories she was told as a girl; they were responsible for her fear and insecurities. However, they also serve as inspiration for her own story telling as a creative writer. Thus a critical reading raises the question of what these narratives actually intended to teach, and how they worked to influence identity. The stories of 'No Name' aunt, Fa Mulan, and Brave Orchid accentuate how women are constructed in male dominated societies. The gender orientated reading promoted by the narrator encourages the view that the power of tradition is responsible for women's oppression, rather than the male gender. Kingston's female characters submit to the patriarchy; even her narrator confesses to colluding with their silencing. Kingston's American context, however, with the supreme value it places on individual choice, has allowed her to interrogate how these Chinese stories dictate female identity. ...read more.


Kingston reminisces, that 'as I grew up, I had learned the chant of Fa Mulan, the girl who had taken her father's place in battle,'(25). Brave Orchid tells her daughter stories that can be empowering as they are necessary. The paradox of Fa Mulan is that her 'disguise as a male warrior when in battle is meant to illustrate the potential power'1 that Chinese women can exert. The narrator 'learned that we failed if we grew up but wives or slaves,'(25). But it was not enough to demonstrate warrior powress, Fa Mulan's ultimate responsibility rested with her family, so 'the villagers would make a legend about my perfect filiality,'(47). It is derived from traditional Chinese Confucianism, wherein sacrifice is seen to justify the Chinese woman's secondary position in society. Kingston encourages readers to see that this legend has played a extremely influential role in shaping her perceptions of gender in society. Indeed it is a gender orientated retelling of the myth, so that our attention is directed towards the sacrifice and responsibility that females must endure. Although the narrator has gained success in school, the ' Chinese executed women who disguised themselves as soldiers or students, no matter how bravely they fought or how high they scored,' (42). She cannot fight to avenge her village, and her powress of education is not recognised.. ...read more.


The initial separation she had to endure from her family to gain this understanding resulted in a denial of her own rich culture. 'I had to leave home to see the world logically...I learned to think that mysteries are for explanation. I enjoy the simplicity.' (182) The Woman Warrior presents the relationship between gender, community stories and identity as variable, one is not dependent on the other. The narrator forms her identity through her context, time and heritage, and she shows this independence by reading herself into existence of the stories upon which she grew. Her interpretation of these talk- stories can be described as gender orientated, presenting obvious links with her own attitudes. Hence, Kingston 'reads herself into existence', by finally imparting her own values into a story, rather than by way of analysing them afterward, and trying to figure out the traditions embedded within may fit into her own life. Her cultural identity as a Chinese American has been strongly influenced by these talk stories she grew up with. By making these stories central to the construction of her memoirs, she makes the point that they are not her identity, her American context has allowed her to interrogate them, so that they are new. 1 'The Woman warrior as a Search for Ghosts',Gayle, K. Fujita Sato in Shirley Geok Lim (ed), (1991), Approaches to teaching Kingston's The Woman Warrior, MLA. 2 Feng, Pin, (1980), 'Maxine Hong Kingston', National Chiao-Tung University, Taiwan ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Gender Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Gender Studies essays

  1. Examine the Factors that Influence Gender Identity.

    This 'boy' took on the gender role of a 'girl', but during puberty the 'girl' was having problems with 'her' sexuality. Studied again later 'she' was now living very happily and comfortably as a 'man' (Diamond and Sigmundson, 1997). This person had not only changed their perceived gender role, but

  2. The Development of Gender in the Individual.

    Gender identity is fixed before children are aware of genital differences. Chodorow argues that the breaking process - Freud's Oedipal transition - occurs in a different way for boys and girls. Girls remain closer to the mother -able, for example to continue hugging and kissing her, and imitating what she does.

  1. Is feminist Christology fit for purpose?

    trap and thus becomes part of the "oppositional framework of patriarchal symbolic and thus involves herself in a major contradiction"18 by Eriksson. This unfortunate and overly combative as Fiorenza's less militantly feminist viewpoint has much to offer this debate. Eriksson's primary complaint is that "At the same time that gender

  2. Examine the ways in which gender has an impact upon developing a sense of ...

    James sees that the pattern of intensive one- to- one relationship, involving considerable emotions and commitments are the characteristics of girls' friendships. A god example of this sort of friendship is of two 13 year old girls Minna and Elizabeth who come from middle class homes in Chittagong, Bangladesh.

  1. The Figure of the Mannish Lesbian in Nineteenth-Century Sexology

    the figure of the mannish lesbian but also how they explained her existence. At a time when heterosexuality was conceived of as the only "normal" means of sexual expression, all forms of non-heterosexual or non-conjugal love and intimacy were foreign and therefore deemed worthy of study by sexologists.

  2. How might the relationship between depression and gender have been exaggerated?

    On top of all of this, it is known that women are more emotional than men so they are bound to feel lower than a man would in the same situation. However, in the argument of the menopause as a cause of depression, research suggests that there is no 'real'

  1. Free essay

    Critically examine an aspect of gender in a personal, community, social, economic and/or political ...

    The Classical and Modern View of Gender The concept of gender and gender studies is a recent phenomenon influenced by modernity and its associated and concomitant circumstances, including the institutionalisation of patriarchal social system, the women movement, and also the media, social class, ethnicity and socio-politics, cultures and historical influences.

  2. Discuss the influence of gender on identity in contemporary Western Society.

    It does not recognize the emphasis on the penis as the mother is the principal attachment in he early years this must be broken for the child to achieve a sense of a separate self. Chodorows has suggested that this breaking process is different for both boys and girls, girls

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work