• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Psychological research on identity has used both an 'insider viewpoint' and an 'outsider viewpoint'. Illustrate this statement by giving an account of two theories of identity together with the research studies that support them.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Psychological research on identity has used both an 'insider viewpoint' and an 'outsider viewpoint'. Illustrate this statement by giving an account of two theories of identity together with the research studies that support them. Introduction The topic of Identity has been a hot topic in psychological researches. By extending the question like "who I am", psychologists try to produce a psychological theory of identity by asking questions like "How individuals identify themselves", "How human identity is constructed", "To what extend it can be developed" or "How important is the development of identity". In order to examine the diversified question, diversified research methodology is used and different types of data is collected and analyzed. The theories are then built up in different point of view, which can be classified into "insider viewpoint" and "outsider viewpoint". Later on, we will examine how researches are conducted in the two named viewpoint, then illustrate them with Social Constructivist and Social Identity Theory. Insider Viewpoint Encountering different types of question, psychologists use different viewpoint. When psychologists have a goal to study individual differences, or an individual's account for a specific issue, they usually use insider viewpoint or a "seen-from-inside" perspective to explore a psychological topic. Hence, the aim of the research under such topic is to perform an in-depth and personalized study, with questions related to individual's personal experience. ...read more.

Middle

Whether psychologists choose to use "insider viewpoint" or "outsider viewpoint" much rely on how they see the formation of identity and how identity affects the behavior of human. In other words, their basic assumptions on identity affect their viewpoint on identity, and therefore their topic and aim of research, the research question, their hypothesis, data collection, research method, and hence the theory. One example of research using "insider viewpoint" is Social Constructionism. Social constructionists, as its name suggests, see the identity of a person is socially constructed. It follows that identity is constructed in everyday life through interaction with others, hence it is different from people to people, culture to culture, and the study is an individualized one which seek for differences across people. Base on the assumptions, the research goal is to study the characteristics of individual's identity with respect to social and personal interaction. One good example for researching identity using insider viewpoint is Kenneth Gergen's theory that "We actively construct identities through everyday social relations" (Gergen, K, 1999). Constructing his own theory, Gergen used insider viewpoint in all three aspects. Gergen was using his own autobiography as the input for his research, in which he described how he had actively reconstructed his own identity with the aid of computer. ...read more.

Conclusion

Hence, data is outsider viewpoint. Moreover, experimental method is used to collect the data. There is no interaction between the researcher and the experiment, and the preference and the assumption does not affect the result of the measurement. Therefore, the method is quantitative and in outsider viewpoint. The analysis again stands in the outsider viewpoint, as the point allocated to ingroup and outgroup members are numbers, the comparison of points are done objectively. Conclusion Psychologists use both "Insider Viewpoint" and "Outsider Viewpoint" to conduct research on Identity. Whether they choose "Insider Viewpoint" or "Outsider Viewpoint" much relies on their initial preference: specific or universal, individual or human as a whole, differences across people or commons among people. Sometimes psychologists may choose to use "Insider Viewpoint" or "Outsider Viewpoint" for the data, the method and the analysis for the whole research; sometimes they may use both viewpoint at the same time. Marcia's Semi-structured interview, for example, collects insider data but use outsider analysis. Therefore, the use of viewpoint is very dynamic and subject to different research theme and aim. Gergen, K. (1999) An invitation to Social Construction, London: Sage Turner, J. and Brown, R. (1978) 'Social status, cognitive alternatives and intergroup relations', in Tajfel, H. (ed.). Tajfel, H., Billing, M., Bundy, R.P. and Flament, C. (1971) 'Social categorization and intergroup behavior', European Journal of social Psychology, vol.1, pp.149-77 DSE212 Exploring Psychology TMA01 Wong Ho Yin 03502017 Page 1 of 3 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Social Theory section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Theory essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Outline some of the main differences between quantitative and qualitative ...

    3 star(s)

    Not all methods are suitable to every study, and therefore by selecting the mode, which is most appropriate to the area of study, a more valid and objective conclusion can be drawn. It cannot be said from a mutual position whether one method is better than the other, as despite

  2. Personal Statement

    of Tower Hamlets I gained immense experience in delivering services to a diverse community as I often had to assess and link people within the borough to services which supported their needs. Furthermore, I have graduated in 2007 from the University of Kent with a 2.1 honours degree.

  1. Sociology A Perspective on Identity

    In the first instance we are all born into a society that is marked by its own set of unique identifiers and in the second instance... as individuals... we make a variety of choices and decisions that can unwittingly make us active participants in determining 'who we are'.

  2. Do you agree or disagree with the following statement: 'McDonald's stands for American cultural ...

    In a survey of school children it was found that 96% of the students could identify Ronald McDonalds in name recognition which is second to Santa Claus (Greenhouse, 1986). Because of its phenomenal success, there are restaurants throughout the world which copy McDonalds such as the fast food croissanteries in

  1. Issues in Research Design and An overview of Qualitative and Quantitative Research Methods

    Let us say car crime. Do I start from a theory or do I start by observing the problem, gathering data etc.? Where do I start in designing my research. Leads on to INDUCTION vs DEDUCTION. INDUCTION assumes science/social science starts from observation. The starting point is observation from which we make connections or correlations.

  2. Critically examine whether media coverage of immigration and national identity creates political and ideological ...

    Such arguments were by no means limited to Powell, his thoughts were given respectability by the increasingly influential New Right, who adopted race as a political discourse (Carter, 1987). New Right The meaning of 'Britishness' has constantly changed, 'Britishness' had to be made and remade throughout history (Colls and Dodds, 1986).

  1. Learning Disability Research and Evaluation: Exploring Participatory and Emancipatory research in Learning Disabilities studies.

    Reflecting back to my studies in BA learning disabilities studies I've had insight into medical models approach to research which saw people with learning difficulties as someone who needed to be "fixed", during the stand of medical model most research focused on eugenics and medical investigations often these research where done by medical professionals.

  2. Social Aspects of Intergroup Conflict between Muslims and Hindus in India

    Haslam, (2006) suggests that this, in part, can be explained by the process of dehumanisation and Kelman, (1973) further argues that dehumanisation also has a role in sanctioned mass violence. Dehumanisation is when one group perceives another out-group as having less than human qualities and can be likened to that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work