• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Should drainage basins be managed or natural? Discuss with use of examples from both LEDCs and MEDCs.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Should Drainage Basins be managed or natural? Discuss with use of examples from both LEDCs and MEDCs. Drainage basins are areas in which water drains from higher land to lower land and eventually meets the sea or a lake. Water that flows on top of land along a certain path is said to be in a channel. The argument in this essay is whether drainage basins and river channels should be managed or left to flow naturally. If people try to control or alter the natural flow of water in a drainage basin in some way it is said to be managed. If a drainage basin is left alone and has not been changed or altered in any way it is said to be natural. People change drainage basins and river channels for many reasons; one of the earliest examples of drainage basin management was the irrigation of crops around the Nile in ancient Egypt. People change the landscape around them to make it easier for them to live in a particular area, this was thought of as a good thing by many when the UK was newly developing. ...read more.

Middle

The US army corps, in charge of flood prevention, had constructed lev�es, some of which were over 15 m high. They cut through meanders shortening the river (for over 1094 miles it flows in artificial channels). Large floodwater over-spills were built to take the excess water in times of flood. The Mississippi's three major tributaries (The Missuori, Ohio and Tennessee) had been controlled by dams. Despite all of all of these flood defences, the Mississippi still flooded. There were two main views on the cause of the flood; conservationists thought that the flood defences had exaggerated the flood and those in favour of the flood defences blamed it on exceptionally high rainfall. I think that the flood was caused by prolonged rainfall and that the flood defences turned what would have been a long minor flood into an extreme flash flood. This happened because the dams stored up the excess water until they were forced to release some, because of this the river level rose and caused some lev�es to be breached. Another fault of the US army corps engineers was the straightening of the river, this allowed the water to flow faster and gather more energy making it more likely to burst through the lev�es. ...read more.

Conclusion

When lev�es are built to "protect" crops and farmland no silt is deposited (unless lev�es are unsuccessful) and more artificial fertilisers need to be added to enrich the soil. Another reason why drainage basin management is not a good idea is the huge capital needed (although some can be retrieved through Hydroelectricity). Dams and alterations to rivers cost millions and can take years to construct. Even when they are in operation, they need constant maintenance and major repairs to dams are very difficult. It is very difficult to predict what a river is going to do and how it is going to react to changes made to it. This means that there is always a possibility that alterations made in an attempt to manage a drainage basin will not work at all or even make the problem worse. The management of drainage basins also has detrimental effects on the environment, Dams flood valleys and dry up wetland downstream e.g. in 1780 there were 41.9 million acres of wetland around the Mississippi compared to 18.1 million acres today Although I can see the need to protect settlements from flooding and the advantages of hydroelectric power, for me it is the true unpredictability and complex nature of drainage basins that makes management of them a less preferred option. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Hydrology & Fluvial Geomorphology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Hydrology & Fluvial Geomorphology essays

  1. Study the river Cray and see whether the river actually follows a natural path ...

    It tells us that at the mouth the river is less deep and less wide but as we get to the mouth it get deeper and wider. From my experiments I have found out that to my surprise the river Cray is very similar in some ways to a river

  2. Case Study: The Mississippi River Flood of 1993

    Seek assistance from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) following a flood event. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers were given directions to construct flood control structures (dams, reservoirs, levees) on the Mississippi River following flood events in the 1930's. Levees may fail because the flood water rises over the top of the structure or the levee collapses under the weight of the water.

  1. Identify and explain how human intervention in the drainage basin can increase the risk ...

    were no levees, as the water could spread across the flood plain and infiltrate into the land, depositing in sedimentation. It is also said that shortening rivers can increase flood risks as the discharge gets down stream very quickly. Although it may seem odd farmland is a major culprit of increasing the flood risk in the drainage basin.

  2. Flooding on the Mississippi

    In times of flood like the 1993 one it diverts excess water from the Mississippi along a 9km spillway, through 350 reservoirs. This spillway has dramatically reduced the flood risk at new Orleans and baton rouge. So more of these along the course of the Mississippi could be a lot of help to reduce the risk of a flood.

  1. Investigate how the velocity of rivers changes.

    Apparatus Required * Stopwatch (to time the ping-pong balls) * Waders (so that we may enter the river to carry out various tasks) * 3 ping-pong balls * 2m stick (to measure the depths of different parts of the river) * Tape measure (to measure out a stretch of the river being studied)

  2. Potential conflicts caused by the use of the Thames basin

    the tourism industry will suffer, as the Thames is a big attraction. The river is also used for many recreational activities, such as swimming. If there are large amounts of waste in the river, no-one will want to go swimming.

  1. "The 1993 Mississippi floods were caused by hard river engineering" Discuss this statement.

    When these are installed, the river, as it can no longer erode one side of the river, simply affects the other side of the channel. This method of hard engineering in fact helps to create a 'naturally' straightened river and has no contributing effect to flooding.

  2. Compare and comment on the flood management approaches in two contrasting areas of the ...

    This sort of different approach to flooding is what distinguishes the MEDC?s from their LEDC counterparts ? a lot, if not all of these defences rely on funds to build them. Without these funds LEDC?s simply cannot prevent or lessen the impacts of flooding effectively.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work