• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Did Athenian democracy erode popular belief in divination? If so why?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

SONJA CHEUNG DID ATHENIAN DEMOCRACY ERODE POPULAR BELIEF IN DIVINATION? IF SO WHY? Divination was a prevalent feature in Archaic Greece, as it provided objective advice, to assist people in making appropriate decisions in problematic predicaments. In certain situations its ambiguity allowed decisions to be postponed, or blame to be assigned to others. Divination was also used to explain matters that seemed unexplainable, such as crop failure or drought. This is illustrated in the Homeric epics, which depicts numerous oracle interpreters, such as Calchas, consulting oracles on domestic, as well as, military decisions. Divination was a guiding authority in ancient society. However, during the fifth and fourth century BC, the democratic establishment and the dominance of politics, overtook the importance of divination, so that decision making occurred in democratic assemblies, with the use of rhetoric. Unexplainable matters were now approached by cults, such as the Sophists, and the increase in scientific knowledge meant that divination was not so readily consulted. Democracy brought politics, rather than religion and divination, to the forefront of society. The Melian dialogue illustrates the Athenian's waning belief in divination. Firstly, it highlights the lack of divinity because of the rise of democracy. The Athenians approach the subject of justice, by suggesting that its equality is dependent on the discussion and persuasion of both of their people.1 The distinct lack of gods in this statement is significant, when compared to the literature of Archaic Greece, which assigns the gods as issuers of justice. For example, in the Iliad, Apollo justly sends down a shower of arrows onto the Greeks for taking the daughter of his priest.2 We must take into consideration that this is merely fiction, but it still highlights the important role of the gods in ancient society. ...read more.

Middle

It is also notable that Athenian democracy believed in individual thoughts and self-assertion, preferring not to obey orders from other sources. Thus, consulting oracles went against their democratic belief. In contrast, the Spartan state was based on following orders, therefore, consulting oracles provided them with guidance. The sceptic interpretation of Thucydides towards these events also relays the deteriorating belief in divination, due to democracy. For example, Thucydides places a logical explanation next to the omens that he reports. That is, he states that the stone Hermae in Athens had been disfigured, which was considered to be a bad omen for the forthcoming expedition. Thucydides insinuates that this occurred due to drunken men.17 Likewise, when he reports the omen of thunder when the Athenians have been defeated by the Syracusan side, he states that this occurs often in the season of autumn.18 Thucydides neither denies nor verifies the relevance and interpretation of divination, but assigns a logical explanation to them, highlighting his sceptical attitude. He also acknowledges that oracles can be manipulated, when he relates that an oracle concerning the Athenian plague was recalled and interpreted to fit the situation, when a word was translated to mean 'death', rather than 'dearth'. This illustrates his scepticism to the interpretation of written oracles. Furthermore, Thucydides criticises Nicias for being too inclined to divination, as Nicias was persuaded by his men to postpone their journey because of an eclipse that had been seen, Thucydides blames this as a reason for Syracusan domination over the Athenians.19 Dover20 has suggested that even though Thucydides may have been a sceptic towards divination, he was still not an atheist. ...read more.

Conclusion

Thirdly, the rise of rhetoric provided objective advice on situations, which had previously been asserted by oracles and different forms of divination. In a similar vein, generals, in the democratic era, were employed to make military decisions, therefore divination did not need to be consulted. However, divination was not completely removed from Athenian democratic society. Xenophon illustrates that in times of war, the Athenians still turned to divination for guidance33, however they retained a degree of caution towards it. It is significant that Xenophon is present at many of the sacrifices and when omens are being interpreted, so that he has an insight into the interpretations, as he was the, hegemon, head of the army. Divination was still present in Athenian democracy, despite sceptical attitudes towards it, because it was able to explain situations beyond human reasoning that had not yet been approached by the philosophers and minds of democratic Athens. Moreover, it was still a reassuring feature to everyday citizens, who still practised divination in private, Xenophon's Anabasis, illustrates its constant use in the lives of his soldiers. However, its use in the public sphere was limited because of the major mistake from the Sicilian expedition. Moreover, the use of divination was part of Greek culture, and had become part of daily lives, it is significant that sceptics, such as Thucydides, never denies any of the omens from divination or refutes the existence of the gods, but maintains that it is an important part of society. Thus, Athenian democracy did erode belief divination, but not to such a great extent that it was completely erased from Athenian society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Does democracy bring peace?

    However we should consider that while a democracy maintains a large military it does not keep it to protect themselves from fellow democracies like Spain or Australia, when it has had problems with other democracies such as in 1956

  2. How and why does Locke explain the creation, value and protection of property?

    The development, or lack therein, is a consequence of individual motivation and is manifested through labor. In keeping with the theory of one's body is one's own, a man's property can be explained in terms of the quantifying forces of his labors.

  1. Indonesia: Transition and Prospects for Democracy

    Democratic moderates in opposition In the opposition, the democratic moderates are the opposition parties and extra-parliamentary groups such as students and workers. Radical extremists were also present in the form of some parties. Democratic power lies in "extra-parliamentary movements" such as workers' strikes and student protests (Kusumah, 2001).

  2. Pat Parker & Associates

    "Copyright law provides that "work for hire" be expressly agreed on in writing as being "specifically ordered or commissioned". [1] While a contract was completed between Parker and the Democratic Party, the terms of that contract are subject to debate as to how copyright should be interpreted.

  1. Marxism Can Only Be Appreciated Retrospectively

    Marx explained that this ideology created a false consciousness for the workers fooling them into thinking that capitalism is fair and so they are reluctant to challenge against it. "Capitalist ideology reflects in thought the fractured lives of alienated people, while at the same time making it increasingly difficult for them to grasp their alienation".

  2. Can a plausible case be made for participatory democracy under modern conditions?

    Representation appears to be the obvious solution in modern society to the problem of a large-scale functioning democracy but we can ask to what extent direct participation can be accommodated under these conditions where representation appears widely necessary. If we take Rousseau's theory of a fully participatory democracy which he

  1. British Democracy - the bestpossible system of government

    This raises more issues about our excellent democratic system. We in Britain allow universal suffrage meaning that everybody over the age of 18 can vote regardless of intelligence or social status. If we again take the example of our average man on the street who has read the manifestos of

  2. Participation is the essence of democracy Discuss

    Pluralist Democracy promotes participation that allows free and fair competition in interest. In pluralist democracies there will be a very high range of competing interest such as economy and environment. Political participation is a process where citizens of a country get involved in political activities.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work