• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluating two poems by Simon Armitage, 'I've made out a will' and 'my father thought it b****y q***r.'

Extracts from this document...


Comparison of two poems I will be evaluating two poems by Simon Armitage. The first will be 'I've made out a will' and the second 'my father thought it b****y q***r.' I chose these as they have a similar structure. Also I favour these over other Armitage poems. In the first line of this poem the poet states that he has made a will and is going to donate his body to the National Health Service. As the poem has no title, the poet has set his subject of writing, straight from the start. He describes which parts of his body he will leave before clearly announcing that he does not want to donate his heart. The poem is 14 lines long, and has just two sentences; the first is divided into an octet and the second sentence is divided in sestet which has been split into four lines and a couplet to finish. There is some irregular rhyme; however this is effective as most of the words are just one syllable 'the face, the case, the cogs.' ...read more.


The second poem I have chosen is 'my father thought it b****y q***r. The poem starts with a course and direct first line, "b****y q***r," This sounds like something a father would say to a son. The boy seems pleased with his new earring "I rolled home..." the word rolled suggests that the boy is pleased and confident with his new accessory. The boy wants to prove that he is tough and independent. With no indication of an effort to cover up the ear piece, the poet gives the impression that he is expecting an amused almost proud reaction from his father. The father's response was in total contrast to his son's expectation; "You've lost your head" The dad is insulting and sarcastic and seems unforgiving. The father mockingly says, 'you should've had it through your nose instead" Farm animals such as cows often have there noses pierced. Perhaps the father is associating the boy's earring with the ugliness of the cows'. The dad knows the youngster will regret it. ...read more.


The boy faces a dilemma; by taking out the ear piece is an admission of his mistake in putting it in; however by leaving it in, the son is disobeying his father which could cause more confrontation in the future. The poems have many similarities. Both of the poems are sonnets, the first is more traditional and has 14 and the second has 15 which is a adaptation on this idea. In both of the poems the poet is putting a strong message across. In the first, I feel that he is declaring the importance of love and passion and how they should never be forgot or left behind due to circumstance. In the second he is stating that you may disagree with someone's decision initially, however once the tables are turned and you look at the situation from the opposite perspective, and you should appreciate and understand the other point of view. Both the poems are easy to read as the rhythm of the poems are steady. Both of the poems have a light hearted feel. In the first, the poet describes his body in abnormal ways, in the second the regular rhyme lifts the poem and helps the poem to flow. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Simon Armitage section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Simon Armitage essays

  1. Explore Armitage`s presentation of his relationship with his parents in the poems: "Mother, any ...

    In the stanza "doors and floors" are rhyming couplets. "You at the zero end, me with the spool of tape", the 2 phrases establish the positions of the mother and the son both are the physical and metaphorical positions. "Zero end" is describing the start, in the case the start of his life (giving birth to him)

  2. Comparative essay on poems from the 'Book of matches'.

    his heart by the amount of times that he says that he does not want it to be used. This poem has a vivid series of metaphors, which are in lists. The metaphors portray different things. Some of the images have medical overtones, 'tubes', 'stitches' and 'wounds'.

  1. Simon Armitage - Comparison of Two Poems

    The use of language points towards how humans experience depression and even suicide. In this poem, each item is described precisely. Armitage begins the list with a normal �5.50 in the mans pocket, "exactly". He mentions "a library card on its date of expiry".

  2. Simon Armitage - poetry

    He writes about his own experiences: "Black Moss is a very lonely place, on the border between Yorkshire and Lancashire. It's on top of a hill and all you can see is the sky and the water. The boy at the day centre was part of my work.

  1. Analysis of "You may turn over and begin" by Simon Armitage.

    An example of this is line 20 "One jot of consolation" which seems an unlikely sentence to actually think, though it does serve to create a division in the speaker's thoughts on l*****g after girls from the story about the "...spindly girl riding pillion".

  2. How does the poetry by Simon Armitage make the ordinary seem extraordinary?

    garden just like a blind person would be doing when trying to find something. 'Cataract operation' is about a washing line becoming a "pantomime"; this is very economical as in just one word it illustrates how lively, colourful and entertaining the washing line is.

  1. Kid - The poem is a dramatic monologue by Robin the Boy Wonder, the ...

    we are imprisoned; or a cathedral, reminding us of the spiritual aspect of life (as in the biblical phrase 'Your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost')? Sound * There is some rhyme in the poem, but it does not follow a regular pattern (use / glues; bone / alone).

  2. A Critical Appreciation of 'Cataract Operation', a Poem by Simon Armitage.

    of a ra ra skirt, the monkey business of a shirt' and 'the cheerio of a handkerchief'. 'in the breeze' a towel, a skirt, a shirt and a handkerchief, all inanimate objects, are, in the poets eyes, transformed. All these descriptions are extremely vivid and imaginative, and all the more

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work