It is not only the heros character that feeds into the construction of a tragedy; external events also play a part. Does either one of these components have, in your opinion, an overriding influence on Macbeth, or do they make an equal contr

Authors Avatar

It is not only the hero’s character that feeds into the construction of a tragedy; external events also play a part. Does either one of these components have, in your opinion, an overriding influence on Macbeth, or do they make an equal contribution to his downfall?

Tragic plays, according to the rules laid down by Aristotle, should involve several key components; amongst them the idea of ‘the catastrophe’, a calamitous outcome, which evokes an emotional response in the audience; ‘the three unities’, i.e. that the action of the play, the location of the play, and the time period during which the play takes place, should all be synchronised; and the idea that the play should be centred on the protagonist of the play, and that an error in the judgement of the protagonist should result in the previously mentioned ‘catastrophe’. Aristotle called this fatal error ‘Hamartia’, which was often brought about due to the ‘hubris’ of the protagonist, or his excessive pride. Shakespeare, however, having never read Aristotle nor heard of his ‘rules’, carves his own form of tragedy, wherein the lines between the ‘divine punishment’ given to people, and the punishment they bring upon themselves, are blurred. Also blurred are the lines between what is truly ‘good’ or ‘evil’, and if we can truly take any comfort in either of these terms.

 From the outset of Macbeth, we are told of the power of the eponym on the battlefield, and of the way he ‘unseams’ enemy soldiers, which immediately signifies his aggression, and hints at the possibility of an ‘unseam’d’ mind; indeed, Shakespeare uses just that same graphic vocabulary to describe the violence of the act – “unseam'd him from the knave to th'chops” – giving an impression of extreme violence, beyond that which is necessary. The deep-rooted ambition within Macbeth is also hinted at from the beginning of the play, one moment in particular being in Act 1 Scene 3, when Macbeth is told by the witches that he is destined to become “king hereafter”. He is described as becoming ‘rapt’ at this idea, and is aware instantly of how his desires are “deep and dark”, with the word ‘dark’ being of particular interest – not only is true to say that Macbeth’s thoughts themselves, those of regicide, are dark, but also the fact that the desires are hidden and secret, even from the eponym himself to an extent. Indeed, Macbeth’s transformation into a heartless tyrant, is not a fast one – In 1:3, Macbeth was repulsed by the thought of committing regicide, and I am of the opinion that, were it not for the control that Lady Macbeth exerted over him, he would not have been able to bring himself to kill King Duncan, and would instead have continued to struggle against his desires, regardless of what the inference of his tragic flaw would lead one to believe about his destruction being self-inflicted.

Join now!

The idea that Macbeth’s ambition and desire is tied into every aspect of his life is exemplified by the fact that his wife, Lady Macbeth, is also shown in her first appearance in 1:5, to be filled with ambition upon her reading of Macbeth’s letter. This ambition is made explicit to the audience when the Lady tells us that she asks for spirits, for evil powers, to ‘unsex’ her, to remove the ‘weakness’ perceived in women, in that they lack the brutality and violence that men do, so that she may do whatever is necessary to obtain the throne from ...

This is a preview of the whole essay

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

A generally well-structured essay which tackles the question effectively and guides the reader through the argument. The writer shows the ability to comment perceptively on the play as a whole, and on the effects of individual words and phrases. Some of the comments require clearer expression or more careful consideration. Sometimes reading an essay aloud will help the writer to pick up on and clarify dubious points. ****