‘Labours ability to form government at all in 1924 and 1929 was more surprising than the fact both governments were short-lived’. Assess the validity of the statement.
Since the start of the of the 20th century the Labour Party had grown from being an electoral ally of the Liberal Party to the second largest party in the British political system during the interwar period. During this time the party formed two governments under the leadership of Ramsay MacDonald but the formation of each is often questioned by historians due to the circumstances which led to the election. However this is not the only issue debated by historians, each government was short-lived which has led to queries about which, out of the elections or the premature falls of the Labour governments, was more suprising.
The formation of the Labour Government in 1924 had looked a distant possibility at the start of the year but a number of factors contributed to their formation and many believe this was suprising. In 1924 Baldwin had recently taken over the leadership of the Conservative Party after fighting off competition from Lord Curzon, following the retirement of Bonar Law due to his deteriorating health. After taking over the leadership of the Conservative Party he sought to gain a mandate to continue from the newly extended electorate who Baldwin believed needed to be able to trust their leaders. The issue on which to call the election on however was tariff reform, one of the most contentious issues in British political history and had been a contributing factor to the conservative decline at the turn of the century. The results of the election subsequently allowed Labour the chance to form a government, the conservatives lost seats and the liberals, despite being united in defence of free trade, were not the party they had been before the outbreak of war. The outcome was a ‘Hung Parliament’ with Labour taking on a minority administration. This formation of the government in 1924, has often been looked upon as suprising by historians, due to the rash actions of Baldwin in calling an election over such a divisive and controversial issue. This seemingly unnecessary action however, may not have come about had Lord Curzon beaten Baldwin in the leadership race. It is therefore a great surprise that Labour gained the opportunity to form a government in 1924, as the Conservatives seemed to be heading a stable administration and it may be said that Baldwin sacrificed the party’s dominance to achieve a mandate to continue in power.