How effective are the checks and balances of the Constitution today?

Authors Avatar

Greg McIlwraith

How effective are the checks and balances of the Constitution today?

Baron de Montesquieu, who had been influenced by John Locke, wrote about the need for separation of powers within the Government; legislative, executive, and judicial. He said that the best way to avoid tyranny is to make sure that nobody belonged to more than one branch of Government. No one branch of Government would be more powerful than another, and all of the three branches would depend on one another. The constitution will outline the powers of each of the branches of Government, and the branches will be able to check the use of the powers of the other branches of Government, this is known as checks and balances.

The three branches of Government; the executive, the legislature (Congress), and the Judiciary, can all carry out checks and balances on each other as outlined in the constitution.

The President of the USA has the power to veto bills passed in Congress, this power is an example of how the executive chamber carries out checks and balances on Congress. This is probably one of the greatest checks that can be attained, Clinton vetoed thirty-six bills in his two terms, a President can stop any bill from becoming law by using a ‘Presidential veto’, although there is a system put in place to stop the executive overusing this power (kind of like a check and balance of a check and balance) which is that if the President does veto a bill, that bill, with the Presidents suggestions, gets passed back to Congress where a two thirds vote is needed to override the Presidents veto. This check can cause dispute between the two branches, but the President has an informal power known as a ‘pocket veto’, this comes about because a bill has ten days to be approved or vetoed by the President, if this ten days comes to an end while Congress is adjourned, the bill seizes to exist, this is usually used as a tactic by the President so that he does not loose face. Because of the way that bills are passed through Congress, the President can ‘arrange’ if you like for the bill to be held up until a time when he can use his pocket veto.

Join now!

The President can also end a Congressional session, although there are some limitations on when he is allowed to do this, i.e. he cannot say that Congress is to be adjourned on the next day, and in cases of emergency this can be of great use. In opposition to this the President can also call Congress into session in case of an emergency.

The executive also carry out checks and balances on themselves, members of the cabinet and the Vice President have the power to dismiss the President if they feel that the President is not fit to discharge his ...

This is a preview of the whole essay