• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What arguments have been put forward to explain the relatively low crime rates of some societies?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What arguments have been put forward to explain the relatively low crime rates of some societies? This essay will critically contrast factors that contribute to producing 'low crime' societies such as Switzerland, and to compare this with Japan, which is also known to be a relatively low crime society, and explore what it is that makes some societies particularly low in crime. Necessary comparisons will be made with some 'high crime' societies in order to demonstrate and try to explain why it is that crime rates are so different. The type of crime being referred to in this essay will be mostly those 'minor' types of crimes such as graffiti, vandalism, minor assaults or muggings on the streets. The difference in cultures between different countries is probably what makes the difference in the way the people in their societies behave, and as a result, different levels and types of crimes that occur. Switzerland is well known for its low crime society. Clinard (1978) highlights some of the main factors that could explain why Switzerland has such an apparently low crime rate. Firstly, Switzerland is an economically strong country. Swiss people have a very strong work ethic and a high standard of living. Unemployment is low as a result of this strong money making ethic present in Swiss culture, and because of this, the more conventional types of crime such as theft, robbery and burglary are rare occurrences. ...read more.

Middle

This is where the theory of 'zero tolerance' stems from, which is adopted in cities such as New York, and increasingly around the UK (Croall 1998). On the other hand, 'problem orientated' policing is where the police use a variety of tactics to achieve their objectives, such as working with the local community and agencies, seeking the underlying causes of problems and trying to solve them for the longer term, rather than dealing with symptoms for a quick short term fix, as implied with a zero tolerance ethic (Dennis et al 1997). This is the style of policing most similar to that adopted by the Swiss police, therefore it could be suggested that Switzerland's low crime society could be because of this style of policing, and the way people are dealt with in the Criminal Justice system, as it is a very different method to those used in 'high crime' societies, which generally tend to adopt the zero tolerance approach. The Swiss are known to be more tolerant of certain crimes and there are always different ways of interpreting crime statistics, even with the best intentions (Clinard 1978). Because crime has not been seen as a major problem in Switzerland, there has been very little scrutiny of Swiss crime trends. This could have had a major affect on the general perception of crime in Switzerland. One explanation is that crime is actually lower than in other countries, and that Swiss society is more conformist and less inclined to criminal behaviour. ...read more.

Conclusion

Respect and confidence in the police will be lost, and there will be no way that the 'community' style of policing will be able to control crime, if the police cannot control it. Alternatives to this heavy handed approach of zero tolerance need to be found in order to prevent crime, particularly youth crime, from getting out of control. Perhaps these methods can be found in the case of Switzerland, where a more tolerant approach seems to be working. However, much more thought needs to go into a suitable crime control method to help so-called 'high crime' societies, because Japan is also low crime, but it is more oppressive than Swiss culture. Some young Japanese people have committed horrific crimes because they were ashamed about something that we in the West would see as a trivial issue. One example is a young boy who killed his mother because she would have disapproved of an argument he has had with fellow pupils earlier that day (Balasegaram 2001). This 'shame' method of keeping young people in-line seems to work until the pressure becomes too much for Japanese youth, as discussed before, they are sometimes crushed under the pressure. A balance needs to be found between these (perhaps) overly repressive cultures and other cultures, which allow young people too much freedom to do as they wish. However, it does seem that the reason both these countries have such low crime rates is because of the strict values and norms applied by family and peers alike. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Asses the arguments and evidence which suggest women commit much less crime than men

    4 star(s)

    She says that there has been a change in the nature of crime; the crime that was traditionally committed by men is now being committed by women. She looked at different statistics and her examination of the American scene concluded that the number of women committing crime and in prison was rising faster than the number of men.

  2. Crime in Japan v. Crime in North Dakota. North Dakota and Japan keep crime ...

    This prevents crime because people do not want to shame their families and themselves. In North Dakota honor is important because everyone in the town knows you and if you commit a crime then everyone will know that you did something wrong.

  1. Assess the view that ethnic differences in crime rates are the result of the ...

    However studies show that the Crown prosecution service (CPS) is more likely to drop cases against ethnic minorities. Bowling and Philips argue that this is because the evidence present to the CPS by the police is often weaker and based in stereotyping of ethnic minorities as criminals.

  2. What explanations have been suggested for occupational crime? Is it different from conventional ...

    finding new ways to make ends meet, and that means going on the fiddle. If wages are low and prices are high, it is not surprising that ends have to be met in other ways. Is the government to blame for the vast amount of fiddling?

  1. The widespread nature of crime, its very normality, makes the search for the causes ...

    You trawl in waters with the likeliest, richest harvest rather than take the rather 'pea in a pod' chance of making an arrest by proceeding on an individual by individual basis. (Young, 2001, p 32) the old invocation 'round up the usual suspects' becomes transformed into 'round up the usual categories', individual suspicion becomes categorical suspicion.

  2. The following essay will explore the question; What is the relationship between policing governance ...

    *Police Act 1997 - Placed the National Crime Intelligence Service on a statutory footing and created the National Crime Squad. Thus creating the legislative basis for a national police force. This Act also created the Police Information Technology Organisation[6]. *Crime and Disorder Act 1998 - - created the basis for

  1. Poverty and Crime rates

    of the people in the community are wearing Nike company footwear then the person whom is wearing the b*m company footwear would feel excluded from the rest of the society. This would cause the person of lower income to steal the expensive footwear just so they don't feel excluded and higher their self esteem.

  2. What is a gang?

    school, limiting their chances for higher education and a good job, they embark on a life of crime, they commit seriously felonies that lead to lengthy jail time and also they may be killed when they try to leave the gang.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work