• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  • Level: GCSE
  • Subject: Maths
  • Word count: 2988

Was Plato’s View of the Nature and Capabilites of Women any More Positive than Aristotle’s?

Extracts from this document...


Was Plato's View of the Nature and Capabilites of Women any More Positive than Aristotle's? "Having dispensed with the individual family in his system of government, and not knowing any longer what to do with women, he finds himself forced to turn them into men". Plato and Aristotle, two of the most influential philosophers in the Ancient World, both had radical views on the nature and capabilities of women. Many of these views were similar, yet somehow Plato became a champion of the female cause, while Aristotle was labelled a male chauvinist. This essay will look to discover whether Plato really was an early feminist, or whether we are looking too far into his ideas. Plato, in the Republic, argues that women should be able to take on the same social roles equally with men in his ideal state. His ideas are based upon the view that women and men have the same nature in respect to acting as guardians of the state, expect that the one is weaker while the other is stronger . However, just one generation later Aristotle returns women to their traditional roles in the home, being subservant to men. There is no equality in nature for Aristotle, and in the Politics he declares: "..as regards the sexes, the male is by nature superior and the female inferior, the male ruler and the female subject. And the same must necessarily apply to all mankind." For now, however, our thoughts will concentrate on Plato and what he really thought of women and their capabilities. ...read more.


Perhaps, therefore, we need to look at his change in opinion of women from the Republic to the Laws. In the Laws Plato returns to the traditional view of women. He states the relative differences - which he had previously made out to be equal - would prevent women being in any way equal to men. He points out, for example, that women have an inferior virtue than men , and that it is necessary for women to listen to different music . Music was inspirational for men, especially in battle, yet it was more apt for women to listen to emotional music because they were emotionally inclined. He also shows how he was aware of the danger of freeing women from their confined, domestic role without giving them an alternative function. He has Socrates give the example of the Spartans to discourage any legislator from: "...letting the female sex indulge in luxury and expense and disorderly ways of life, while supervising the male sex." So why should Plato change his views? Perhaps the most obvious answer here is that the Republic is an ideal situation, predominantly unachievable, whereas the Laws has moved to a conventional and practical situation, one that is recognisable and believable. If this is the case, then perhaps Dickinson was right when he said 'the claim of male superiority should simply be understood as a remnant of masculine prejudice.' This masculine prejudice manifested itself most potently in Plato's pupil Aristotle. ...read more.


opportunities to achieve success in guardianship; yet there are also cases in later works whereby a typical male misogynistic tendency - of the time - creeps in. We cannot blame these comments on carelessness and inconsistency, for they arise out of a deep-rooted belief that women are inferior to men. By seeing this we are not rejecting Plato's views, rather we are recognising his vulnerability to prejudices of his age. His errors cause him to become somewhat less of a feminist, although his considered proposals remain revolutionary for his time. Plato recognised that women had something to offer the state, and although the scenario in the Republic was predominantly unrealistic, the very fact that he considered a new role for women implied he was prepared for change. Aristotle, on the other hand, had a typical view of women. They were little other than incubators and were certainly not capable of doing anything other than household chores. They had to be ruled by men to be kept in line, and it was their nature to be subordinate. Their souls were inextricably linked to their sex, and this in turn made them psychologically deficient. Plato's 'sexless' soul in a sexed body allowed him to persuade that essentially the nature of men and women was the same, as their souls did not in essence differ. In nearly every way Plato's view of women was by far the better of the two. Aristotle's woman was an object, Plato's woman was a human being with a capacity to be educated. She was ahead of her time. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Height and Weight of Pupils and other Mayfield High School investigations section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Height and Weight of Pupils and other Mayfield High School investigations essays

  1. the representation of women in Greek tragedies

    She also holds a certain power and influence over the male characters of the play. She exerts considerable control over the infertile Aegeus who addresses her very much as an equal. Likewise, she uses her feminine wiles to manipulate Creon to her own advantage.

  2. Guesstiamte - investigating whether men or women between the ages of 15-25 are better ...

    16 40 49 9 81 50 49 1 1 45 49 4 16 30 49 19 361 90 49 41 1681 43 49 6 36 45 49 4 16 4476 4476 � 18 = 248.66 Square root (248.66) = 15.77 Women -Angles Result� Mean Difference Diference� 40 42 2 4

  1. Discuss the trauma of transition from the Victorian female ideal to the feminist figure ...

    This is highlighted in chapter 1 where she defends Charles Tansley against the criticisms of her own children, "she could not bear incivility to her guests, to young men in particular. She had the whole of the other sex under her protection."

  2. "Medicine was a Battleground for the war between the sexes in the Greco-Roman World". ...

    Often women's words were doubted much more than a male patient's report would be doubted; it is reported, for example, that 'sometimes... the women do not recognise when they are sick' (Women I, chapter 62). As cited above, a medical examination might be carried out by the patient (who must

  1. the representation of women in the Greek tragedies

    It is this representation of Medea as an assertive woman who refuses to become yet another female victim in male dominated society that the audience relates and sympathizes with.

  2. Plato's Symposium - Aristophanes' speech as a reflection of ancient sexuality

    to escape their professional destiny and feel some non-mercenary emotions."19 Intimate relationships between females from Lesbos, at thiasoi all over Greece, and hetairai existed due to splintered female halves longing to reunite with their other female selves. Individuals who were hermaphroditic before the separation were the children of the moon, "for the moon also partakes of both"20 the male (sun)

  1. I intend to carry out research to find out if 'Men do more work ...

    Secondary Research Until the middle of the twentieth century there was a clear division of labor between men and women. The man's role was to go out to work and provide for the family, the woman's role was to be a housewife and mother, looking after home and family.

  2. Fight Club a 'devastating critique of American materialist, consumer culture', or a film about ...

    not in terms of object but as a projection of who we would like to be.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work