• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'As the only directly elected European Institution is the European Parliament, the European Union cannot be described as democratic.' Discuss

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

TMA 03 Dan Whittle U5236871 DD200 P.1 'As the only directly elected European Institution is the European Parliament, the European Union cannot be described as democratic.' Discuss Democracy is a political system where the sovereign power is in the hands of the people. Albert Weale gives a more functional definition: 'important public decisions on questions of law and policy depend, directly or indirectly, upon public opinion formally expressed by citizens of the community, the vast bulk of whom have equal political rights.'1 To ensure this is realised "public control and political equality...authorisation, representation and accountability are the key principles."2 This essay tests the institutions of the EU under these criteria and concludes on their democratic legitimacy. The 'democratic deficit' a term often used by journalists refers to an increasing gap between the power of the EU institutions and the perceived power of the people to influence EU decisions. In direct democracy (e.g referenda) decisions are taken directly by the people. Directly elected government are those chosen by the electorate to take the day to day decisions. For practical reasons there need to be unelected public servants to work with the elected government. ...read more.

Middle

The parliament also has the power to scrutinise the executive (council of ministers) and the commission. It has the power to censure the commission, the threat of which led to its resignation in recent times. The EP has a dialogue with the European Central bank as specified by the TEU. It receives nominations for the executive board, holds a three-monthly meeting with the president and can summon the ECB to scrutinise decisions. The European court of Justice enforces EU legislation. Judges are appointed by a common accord of the governments of the members states. The powers in bullet form: Parliament - Approves Budget - Share of decision making power in the co-decision procedure - Power to improve proposed legislation by amendment within the co-operation procedure. - Supervision of executive - representatives of the council of ministers. TMA 03 Dan Whittle U5236871 DD200 P.3 Council - Set EU objectives - Co-ordinate national policies - Legislate Court - settle disputes between the union's different institutions and member states. - has passed laws in such fields as employment, the environment, consumer protection and the free movement of goods and services. ...read more.

Conclusion

Where are the areas seen as central to the 'democratic deficit' problem? Council of Ministers If as stated by John Major, the EU gets its legitimacy through national Parliaments, then the attrition of national powers by the undemocratic EU institutions is undermining this idea. Romano Prodi said: "As long as the veto exists, the EU will be like a soldier trying to march with a ball and chain around one leg. The unanimity requirement means either complete paralysis or reducing everything to the lowest common denominator."3 Meanwhile the legitimacy the EU gets from National parliaments is further diminished. Commentators have noted that decisions of the parliament and Council which go against the will of the less democratic commission have been undermined anyway. In June 2001 Ireland voted against the Nice Treaty by referendum. But the joint statement issued by EU president Goran Persson and Commission president Romano Prodi was: 'The member states and the commission will pursue the enlargement negotiations with undeminished vigour and determination, in line with our firm commitment given to the applicant countries.' It's not surprising people feel disconnected from the EU elites when their feelings on the EU masterplan seem to have no effect. TMA 03 Dan Whittle U5236871 DD200 P. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level European Union section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level European Union essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    ‘The main democratic deficit in the European Union is psychological, not institutional.’ Discuss.

    4 star(s)

    The European Union was brought about by the Treaty of Paris (1951) as a 'democratic ideal to moderate inter-state relations in Europe' (Brigid Laffin 1999). Amongst its aims were peace, prosperity and curbing nationalism in the wake of World War II.

  2. To What Extent Does the EU Display a 'Democratic Deficit'?

    Finally, constituencies may have many MEPs representing them (e.g. in the South East constituency there are 10 MEPs) but the constituency size is huge (the South East region covers 6 million eligible voters) meaning that each MEP represents over half a million voters (in contrast with MPs who typically represent just 70,000 voters).

  1. The Institution of the European Union and Theories.

    In return results in production increases, benefit to the country, and could also benefit from economies of scale. The single European market dose not implement the following trade barriers and by doing so trade is encouraged between member's states: (treaty of Rome)

  2. What Are The Functions Of The Four EU Institutions? How Are European Laws Made?

    The ECJ is staffed by Judges-Rapporteurs and Advocates-General who assist them by providing reasoned opinions. There is one judge for every member state, and there are eight Advocates-General. The judges are selected from high-level judges from the member states, but they must all be impartial and must all swear on an oath.

  1. Types of European Law

    An example of a case whereby a member state failed to comply with a directive would be Marshall V Southampton Health Authority [1986]. Mrs. Marshall was forced to retire at the age of 62 from her employment with the NHS. This was a breach of the Equal Treatment Directive 1976.

  2. Describe the functions of the Council of Ministers, European Commission, the European Parliament and ...

    Each Commissioner heads a department with special responsibility for one area of Union policy, such as economic affairs, agriculture and the environment. The Commission has several functions.

  1. Supremacy of the European Union has, to all intents and purposes, crippled the domestic ...

    (R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex parte International Traders Ferry Ltd (1997) 2 All ER 65) Until Maastricht, the EC could remain an economic association of sovereign States, since (1992) Maastricht, and even more so since (1997) Amsterdam, there can be no argument that we are heading toward a

  2. The Foreign Policy of Great Britain in relationship to the European Union.

    And a new population threshold at 62 per cent of the EU is also introduced.13 So the three biggest countries will continue, even as the EU enlarges, will be able to block together. We can compare British votes in Council with three states to find out the increased voting power it got in Nice.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work