Comparison of extracts from I love to hear the crows go by by John Clare and Sons and lovers by D. H. Lawrence.

Authors Avatar

Daniel Murphy SS122962

Assignment 3

In this essay, I will be comparing two extracts (‘Sons and lovers’ and ‘I love to hear the crows go by’) by acknowledging language, structure and form. I will also consider how the two writers have used these devices to present the love of aspects of the world of nature.

It is clear that both of the extracts focus on aspects of nature to present two different themes and ideas, but the two extracts are also very different in their form and structure. Clare’s first person sonnet and his use of imagery are appropriate in evoking love for nature and his use of rhyming couplets and the poems simplicity seem almost song like.  Lawrence’s novel extract’s effective use of an omniscient narrative gives us a descriptive account of the characters feelings and their natural surroundings to depict a growing sexuality between the two characters. The theme of nature and Lawrence’s imagery of nature are used to intimately bond these two characters.  

Join now!

Clare’s love for nature is evident from the very beginning, his use of ‘I love’ highlights his feelings towards the ‘crows’ and ‘birds’. Clare’s love for nature is also highlighted in his use of  imagery; The use of human senses (synaesthesia) throughout the poem, to ‘hear’, ‘see’ and by ‘watching’ them convey his love of nature –. We can also see images of behaviour, (the robin ‘sings, ‘pecks’ and watches) which are effective in describing the wildlife around him as he watches it happen. Words such as ‘joy’, ‘pleasant’ and ‘merry’ also evoke an idyllic image of nature and the ...

This is a preview of the whole essay