• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In relation to the archetypal American Dream, compare and contrast the main characters in The Great Gatsby and Gone with the Wind: to what extent can Jay Gatsby and Rhett Butler be considered heroes?

Extracts from this document...


In relation to the archetypal 'American Dream', compare and contrast the main characters in 'The Great Gatsby' and 'Gone with the Wind': to what extent can Jay Gatsby and Rhett Butler be considered heroes? Neither Jay Gatsby nor Rhett Butler can be considered stereotypical heroes, them not being fairytale princes or purveyors or moral justice; yet they are protagonists in their own stories. Why do people believe they fulfil the model of a hero? Both Gatsby and Butler are the creations of authors with a great deal of satirical distaste for the situations they describe. Is this a clue to the type of character both Jay Gatsby and Rhett Butler are? They both seem to aspire to the 'American Dream' but are missing love from their lives. Could it be their pursuit of true love that persuades readers and characters to consider them as heroes? I believe that it is integral to both the stories to consider the main character's heroism, as our trust in the characters depends on this. I also want to account for the author's own visions for their characters - whether they wanted them to be wholesome, strong hero types or purveyors of moral guidance to the other characters. ...read more.


On what terms can Gatsby be considered a hero? Sarah Ellen5 said: To consider Gatsby to be a hero is really subjective. It is subjective upon which definition of heroism we use. Were his actions courageous and noble enough, or was the man just driven crazy over love? To consider Butler to be a hero is subjective based on the same factors as Gatsby and also depends on what is held in high regard as qualities determining a hero. If it is nobility and bravery, maybe these two are not the best examples of a hero, but if being an American hero is about the pursuit of happiness (and the American Dream) is there a possibility that these figures have more resemblance to heroes? The concept of 'The American Dream' is one that many people have attempted to define over the years, and its link with heroism is tenuous. The most successful definition I have read is James Evans': That dream of a land in which life should be better and richer and fuller for everyone, with opportunity for each according to ability or achievement. ...read more.


These heroes are also different in modern day society. Gatsby would be treated with less disdain than he was in his story - with television programmes such as 'Paris Hilton's British Best Friend' it is becoming more evident that people today can be bought. Love and friendship is more and more changed by money. However, with growing support for peace and knowledge of wars, Rhett would be a bigger hero than ever, because he would not support any side. I think that if Rhett was considered a hero it would not be a disaster, but Fitzgerald's Gatsby is a weaker role-model and would surely contribute to the down-turn of society. 1 The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald pg 150 2 Gone with the Wind, Margaret Mitchell pg 370 3 Gone with the Wind, Margaret Mitchell pg 188 4 http://honorsenglish.learnerblogs.org/2006/04/07/what-makes-gatsby-great/ Written on April 7th 2006 5 http://honorsenglish.learnerblogs.org/2006/04/07/what-makes-gatsby-great/ Written on April 14th 2006 6 James Trudlow Evans, The Epic of America 7 The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald pg 8 The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald pg 160 9 Gone with the Wind, Margaret Mitchell pg 115 10 The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald pg 7 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level F. Scott Fitzgerald section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level F. Scott Fitzgerald essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    The English Patient is a work of historical fiction set in the hills of Tuscany during World War II. It intersperses the factual and the imaginary into a tale of tragedy and passion. Structurally, the novel resists chronological order, alternating between present action in the Italian villa and flashbacks to memories of a mysterious desert romance that is gradually revealed.

  2. Chance, Accident and Coincidence in The Mayor of Casterbridge

    To cap it all, the use of chance in love, discovery of the goldfinch and forecasting accentuates Hardy's sense of fatalism towards one's destiny. Furthermore, the features aforesaid are the agents of Fate and that no miracle (a violation of laws of nature)

  1. Compare the Role of Magic and the Supernatural in The Tempest and A Midsummer ...

    who spend the entire production drunk, bedraggled, bemoaning their lot in life and scheming towards a level of power that they could not possibly comprehend. Their key scene involves them dressing in Prospero's finery and drunkenly cavorting before being hounded off stage by the spirits of the island.

  2. Odysseus: A Beloved Epic Hero

    The next value Odysseus shows is loyalty, which he embraces fairly well many times in this epic poem. Loyalty is faithfulness to one's country, friends, ideals, etc. ("loyalty"). Odysseus shows loyalty to his friend when he goes back to Circe's island on their return from the Underworld and gives Elpinor a proper funeral (Homer 114).

  1. How do the two main characters in your comparison novels compare? (The Great Gatsby ...

    This can be juxtaposed with the tight-knit friendship of the five pupils at Hampden, which Richard describes as an 'arresting party' on first encounter. Although both characters share the same enigmatic quality and our narrators must initially learn about them through word of mouth, Henry seems at first to be

  2. Free essay

    Discuss the way in which the female characters are presented in the Great Gatsby

    Fitzgerald for the majority of the novel looks into the variety of male reactions when women entered the public sphere in the 19th Century, as American culture became feminised. As a consequence, Fitzgerald presents these 'Flappers' as being ethically immoral, with one-track minds set on material wealth and achieving higher social status.

  1. In both The Great Gatsby and The Kite Runner, Fitzgerald and Hosseini constantly use ...

    The 'gigantic' nature of the billboard suggests that it is a dominant god-like feature of this setting and by presenting it with 'blue' eyes Fitzgerald uses the motif of colour to suggest that it gives hope to the 'ashen' setting.

  2. Compare and contrast American playwrights presentation of masculinity in Death of a Salesman, Whos ...

    him.? Both Biff and Jim falsely justify Willy?s belief that being well liked was the key to success as both were popular ?I?m not popular like you were? not understanding that they were well liked because they are successful. The plays show how masculine physicality was overvalued and both contemporary

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work