• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Mabel In Making History Contradicts Prevailing Attitudes Towards Women Shown In Top Girls

Extracts from this document...


Mabel In Making History Contradicts Prevailing Attitudes Towards Women Shown In Top Girls. Discuss. Tom Roberts In Top Girls by Caryl Churchill, our protagonist is a hard working, hard living woman called Marlene, who gives up many aspects of her life in order to obtain a successful career. She gives up a real family life and even a social life in order to be a 'top girl'. In Making History by Brian Friel, the character of Mabel is also shown to do something similar; she leaves behind her family, who are from a different religion and belief system, in order to marry a man of power and to become powerful herself. These contradicting attitudes are interesting to the audience because although the characters both do the same thing, they have different reactions to it. In Top Girls, Marlene gives up a child, a mother, and her sister in order to pursue her ideal life choice of running an employment agency. She moves away from her family in their little out of town village, and seemingly does not regret this very much. More importantly, she gives up her own child in order to live out her dreams in a big city, and seems to forget about the fact that she ...read more.


She then placed her with her sister in a small village where she probably would never grow up to become anything of success, due to her surroundings. The way the two women react at childbirth is very contradictory, and says a lot about their personality and attitude towards submission to patriarchy. Another way in which the attitudes present in the two plays are contradictory is how the two main women in them react to criticism and to being put down. In act 2 of Top Girls, when Marlene is being shouted at by Mrs. Kidd about how she should give up her job so that her husband can have it, and insults her, Marlene stands her ground against her, at first in a calm way, by saying 'i'm sorry but i have some work to do' and later by saying 'could you please piss off?'. She does not care about the fact that she is being insulted and put down by Mrs. Kidd, and goes about her business in a tough way. She has had to do this all her life in order to get to the position we find her in at this point; if she hadn't had a tough exterior, she would not have been able to become successful, as part of being successful is to be able to take criticism lightly. ...read more.


Through the use of love, or lack of in the case of Marlene, the respective authors have told us a great deal about the attitudes that the women have, and the attitudes with which they have presented. Marlene is shown to be a feisty, well kept woman who knows how to look after herself and does not need a lover or family to keep her stable, instead choosing to put all her efforts into her career. Contradictory to this, Mabel both misses her family and her old life (unlike Marlene) and has a deep need for Hugh, needing his consolation when she is upset, and eventually giving up her life so that she can provide him with a child. Friel wrote Mabel in this way to show how women were below men in every way in the time period when Making History was set, even when it came to things out of their personal control. Churchill presents an opposing attitude in Top Girls, and basically shows the audience how a woman can be just as successful as a man, but that they will have to make some serious sacrifices in order to obtain what they want in life. Overall, although on first glance Mabel and Marlene do not seem all that different, they are very contradictory in nature and their attitude towards men (and submission to) differs greatly. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Brian Friel section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Brian Friel essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The History Boys. Consider the significance of finding your way in life, in ...

    3 star(s)

    Unfortunately for Posner, his life didn?t quite go as well as he thought it would. In fact, he ended up living a similar life to Hector?s; it?s easy to draw a parallel between the two characters. Of all the boys, he ends up being the one living the most precarious life.

  2. "Lady Windermere's Fan is a moral play about immoral people". Explore Wilde's presentation of ...

    abroad and he'll come back to you all right - slightly damaged, of course". Again, the use of the phrase "of course" suggests this is the norm when dealing with adulterous husbands. The hollow hypocrisy that is displayed is as much to be criticized as Lady Windermere's moral absolutes yet

  1. Protagonists in Top Girls (Caryl Churchill)

    In this scene, the focus is entirely on Angie, and thus we can wonder if she is in fact the "real" protagonist of Top Girls or whether she has another roleit seems possible for her to also be the or a protagonist in Top Girls..

  2. Assess the relevance of Pages 58 - 63 in the History Boys to ...

    So it is that we are reminded of our initial meeting with Irwin when, still in a wheelchair, he was addressing three or four unidentified MPs upon the best way of presenting a bill before Parliament, the effects of which would, if examined, would prove to be very contentious concerned,

  1. Pygmalion - the significance of accents and the characters of Eliza and Henry.

    Shaw meant for Higgins to be a dynamic character that created frustration due to his indifference to people, however Higgins is also very likeable based on his very frank thoughts and opinions. He creates great interest in the play with his intelligence and dry humour and we as an audience grow to like Higgins despite his flaws.

  2. Explore how Carol Churchill presents woman in the role of mother in "Top Girls".

    Only Nijo truly understands Griselda's life and she has been put in the same position, Marlene finds it an outrage that she let the Walter take her baby, "Walter was bonkers" and obviously, it will be hard for Gret to accept as she brought up her own children, "Bastard".

  1. The History Boys Essay

    you need to think for yourself and try to stand out within the crowd, your competitors. "What has that got to do with anything?"11 Writing an essay on history should not per se be about the truth. History is truth as far as the writers are concerned and is usually

  2. Scene by scene analysis of "Equus"

    The horseman said to Alan that he build a ?terrific castle?. But Alan gives all his attention to other things, in this case to the horse. From this moment, Alan didn?t say any word to the horseman anymore. He just nodded and let his desire free run.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work